Doe v. Chao
Citations
- 540 U.S. 614
- 124 S. Ct. 1204
- 157 L. Ed. 2d 1122
- 2004 U.S. LEXIS 1622
About this case
Doe v. Chao
This article **relies excessively on references
to primary sources
**. Please improve this article by adding secondary or tertiary sources
.
Find sources: "Doe v. Chao"
– news
· newspapers
· books
· scholar
· JSTOR (August 2019) (Learn how and when to remove this message
)
Doe v. Chao, 540 U.S. 614 (2004), is a decision by the United States Supreme Court [1] that interpreted the statutory damages provision of the Privacy Act of 1974 .[2]
Prior to the case, lower federal courts had split over whether plaintiffs whose rights were violated were automatically entitled to the statutory minimum damages award of $1000, or whether those plaintiffs had to prove that they had suffered at least some actual damage from the privacy breach (which would then be raised to $1000 if their actual damages were less than that).
The Court's 6–3 decision determined that the latter interpretation was correct; as a result, it will be more difficult for a plaintiff to prevail as he or she must now prove both a violation and some damages before being entitled to recovery.
This result is generally applauded by proponents of greater freedoms for the press, as a contrary result may have made government agencies more reluctant to release information out of fear of lawsuits.
Contents
Background of the case
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Doe_v._Chao&action=edit§ion=1 "Edit section: Background of the case")
The plaintiff in the case, coal miner Buck Doe (a pseudonym ), filed for benefits under the federal Black Lung Benefits Act .[3] The Department of Labor, which ran the benefits program, required applicants to provide a Social Security number as a part of the application. The government's practice was to use the number for identification purposes, and as a result, claimants such as Doe had their Social Security numbers displayed on various legal documents and published in case reports and online legal research databases.
Doe, along with six other black lung claimants, sued the Department of Labor for violating their rights under the Privacy Act. The government conceded that it had violated the statute. At trial, Doe testified that he suffered "distress" from the release of his private information. The district court awarded Doe $1000, which was the statutory minimum amount of damages that could be awarded under the statute.
The Fourth Circuit reversed. It interpreted the statute to require a plaintiff to show some actual damages before the statutory minimum damages could be awarded. Further, it found that plaintiff's testimony about his "distress" was not legally sufficient to show that he had been damaged by the disclosure.[4]
This decision conflicted with decisions of the First, Fifth, Ninth, Eleventh, and District of Columbia circuits, and the Supreme Court granted certiorari to resolve the dispute.
Statutory language
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Doe_v._Chao&action=edit§ion=2 "Edit section: Statutory language")
The statutory language at issue provided that if a government agency violated the act "in a manner which was intentional or willful, the United States shall be liable to the individual in an amount equal to the sum of actual damages sustained by the individual as a result of the refusal or failure, but in no case shall a person entitled to recovery receive less than the sum of $1,000."[5]
Supreme Court
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Doe_v._Chao&action=edit§ion=3 "Edit section: Supreme Court")
The Court, in an opinion written by Justice David Souter , agreed with the Fourth Circuit's interpretation as a matter of "straightforward textual analysis."
The Court supported its interpretation with an analysis of the history of the statute, which showed that Congress specifically removed language from the bill that explicitly would have awarded $1000 without proof of any damages. (Justice Antonin Scalia , an opponent of using legislative history in interpreting statutes, did not join this paragraph of the opinion).
Dissenting opinions
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Doe_v._Chao&action=edit§ion=4 "Edit section: Dissenting opinions")
Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg wrote a dissenting opinion, arguing that a "sensible" reading of the statutory language supported Doe's position. She also noted that reading the statute to require some proof of actual damages would have little practical effect. She noted that it would be very easy for a plaintiff to prove actual damages in a similar case merely by purchasing a credit report following the publication of his Social Security number. This small amount of damages would then be raised to $1000 by operation of the statute.
Justice Stephen Breyer also dissented, noting that the government's stated fear of large damage awards under a more permissive reading of the statute would likely not materialize, as courts had interpreted the statute to only permit damages where the government released private information in bad faith (as opposed to accidentally).
See also
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Doe_v._Chao&action=edit§ion=5 "Edit section: See also")
References
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Doe_v._Chao&action=edit§ion=6 "Edit section: References")
- ↑ Doe v. Chao, 540 U.S. 614 (2004).
- ↑ 5 U.S.C. § 552a .
- ↑ 30 U.S.C. § 901 et seq.
- ↑ Doe v. Chao, 306 F.3d 170 (4th Cir. 2002).
- ↑ 5 U.S.C. § 552a(g)(4) .
External links
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Doe_v._Chao&action=edit§ion=7 "Edit section: External links")
- Text of Doe v. Chao, 540 U.S. 614 (2004) is available from: Cornell CourtListener Findlaw Google Scholar Internet Archive (docket files) Justia Library of Congress Oyez (oral argument audio)
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Doe_v._Chao&oldid=1351338010 "
Editorial context from Wikipedia (CC-BY-SA 4.0).
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that emotional anguish alone is insufficient, and that a plaintiff must show actual damages to recover under the Privacy Act
- holding that the statute guarantees $1,000 only to plaintiffs who have suffered some actual damages
- holding that the district court has discretion to refuse to aecépt supplemental evidence not presented to the magistrate judge
- concluding that summary judgment should have been granted on plaintiffs Privacy Act damages claim for emotional distress where plaintiff failed to present evidence of actual damages
- holding plaintiffs must prove some actual damages to qualify for the Privacy Act’s minimum statutory award
- explaining that an individual may suffer Article III injury and yet fail to plead a proper cause of action
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Souter, Rehnquist, O'Connor, Kennedy, Thomas, Ginsburg, Stevens, Breyer
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
261 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Sussman v. United States Marshals ServiceD.C. Circuit· 2007-07-31· cited 655×
- Federal Aviation Administration v. CooperSupreme Court· 2012-03-28· cited 461×
- Hamdan v. RumsfeldSupreme Court· 2006-06-29· cited 395×
- Richard Beck v. Robert McDonaldFourth Circuit· 2017-02-06· cited 353×
- Speaker v. U.S. Department of Health & Human Services Centers for Disease Control & PreventionEleventh Circuit· 2010-10-22· cited 324×
- In Re Horizon Healthcare Services Inc. Data Breach LitigationThird Circuit· 2017-01-20· cited 324×
- Jacobs v. NATIONAL DRUG INTELLIGENCE CENTERFifth Circuit· 2008-11-10· cited 257×
- Wilson v. LibbyD.C. Circuit· 2008-08-12· cited 203×
- McCready, Sheila v. Nicholson, R. JamesD.C. Circuit· 2006-09-19· cited 199×
- Pichler v. UNITEThird Circuit· 2008-09-09· cited 196×
- In Re Nickelodeon Consumer Privacy LitigationThird Circuit· 2016-06-27· cited 187×
- Succar v. AshcroftFirst Circuit· 2005-01-05· cited 185×
- Texas Disposal Systems Landfill, Inc. v. Waste Management Holdings, Inc.Tex. App. Ct., 3rd Dist. (Austin)· 2007-04-03· cited 178×
- Beaven v. United States Department of JusticeSixth Circuit· 2010-09-27· cited 174×
- Krottner v. Starbucks Corp.Ninth Circuit· 2010-12-14· cited 135×
- Quinton Brown v. Nucor CorporationFourth Circuit· 2015-05-11· cited 131×
- In Re Google Inc. Cookie Placement Consumer Privacy LitigationThird Circuit· 2015-11-10· cited 121×
- Doe v. ChaoFourth Circuit· 2007-12-28· cited 111×
- United States v. Lopez de VictoriaCourt of Appeals for the Armed Forces· 2008-02-26· cited 83×
- In re Sony Gaming Networks & Customer Data Security Breach LitigationS.D. California· 2014-01-21· cited 82×
Cites
33 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- City of Los Angeles v. LyonsSupreme Court· 1983-04-20· cited 5,797×
- Alyeska Pipeline Service Co. v. Wilderness SocietySupreme Court· 1975-05-12· cited 4,586×
- Immigration & Naturalization Service v. Cardoza-FonsecaSupreme Court· 1987-03-09· cited 4,149×
- Farrar v. HobbySupreme Court· 1992-12-14· cited 3,072×
- Russello v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1983-11-01· cited 2,703×
- Consumer Product Safety Commission v. GTE Sylvania, Inc.Supreme Court· 1980-06-09· cited 2,564×
- Duncan v. WalkerSupreme Court· 2001-06-18· cited 2,368×
- Bowen v. Georgetown University HospitalSupreme Court· 1988-12-12· cited 2,039×
- TRW Inc. v. AndrewsSupreme Court· 2001-11-13· cited 1,407×
- Davis v. Michigan Department of the TreasurySupreme Court· 1989-03-28· cited 1,222×
- Barnhart v. Sigmon Coal Co.Supreme Court· 2002-02-19· cited 1,044×
- United States v. MenascheSupreme Court· 1955-04-04· cited 1,032×
- Watt v. AlaskaSupreme Court· 1981-04-21· cited 843×
- Montclair v. RamsdellSupreme Court· 1883-03-18· cited 485×
- Solid Waste Agency of Northern Cook County v. United States Army Corps of EngineersSupreme Court· 2001-01-09· cited 479×
- Pollard v. E. I. Du Pont De Nemours & Co.Supreme Court· 2001-06-04· cited 356×
- Director, Office of Workers' Compensation Programs v. Newport News Shipbuilding & Dry Dock Co.Supreme Court· 1995-03-21· cited 192×
- Hudson v. RenoSixth Circuit· 1997-12-04· cited 163×
- Johnson v. Sawyer,et alFifth Circuit· 1997-08-22· cited 155×
- Albright v. United StatesD.C. Circuit· 1984-04-10· cited 137×
Other cases named Doe v. Chao
7 other CourtListener records share this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.