Eighth Circuit· 4/2/2010
Barzilay v. Barzilay
Citations
- 600 F.3d 912
- 2010 U.S. App. LEXIS 6918
- 2010 WL 1253732
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- considering that the intent of the parents to stay in one country or another country was uncertain or differed between the parents
- observing that an agreement between two parents purporting to set a child’s habitual residence in a country where the child has “never lived” would be ineffectual
- noting that to establish a new habitual residence, a family's “settled purpose need not be to stay [there] forever, but [with] a sufficient degree of continuity to be properly described as settled”
- explaining that “the text of the Convention directs courts to only one point in time in determining habitual residence: the point in time immediately before the removal or retention” (internal quotation marks and citations omitted)
- explaining that even though parents may not have intended to remain in the United States permanently, the children habitually resided in the United States because the children lived here “most or all of their young lives”
- explaining that court considering ICARA petition must determine child’s habitual residence immediately prior to removal, whether removal violated petitioner’s custody rights under law of habitual residence, and whether petitioner was exercising those rights at time of removal
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Murphy, Bye, Strom
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
25 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Evelyn Larbie v. Derek LarbieFifth Circuit· 2012-07-31· cited 75×
- Derek Redmond v. Mary RedmondSeventh Circuit· 2013-07-25· cited 71×
- Darin v. Olivero-HuffmanFirst Circuit· 2014-03-19· cited 46×
- Nicolson v. PappalardoFirst Circuit· 2010-04-30· cited 44×
- Haimdas v. HaimdasE.D. New York· 2010-07-02· cited 34×
- Michelle Berezowsky v. Pablo OjedaFifth Circuit· 2014-08-26· cited 29×
- Guzzo v. CristofanoSecond Circuit· 2013-06-11· cited 27×
- Ricardo Acosta v. Anne Marie AcostaEighth Circuit· 2013-08-05· cited 27×
- Eduardo Custodio v. Cecilia Marianela Torres SamilEighth Circuit· 2016-12-02· cited 22×
- Faisal Ahmed v. Mardia Mohsin AhmedSixth Circuit· 2017-08-16· cited 17×
- Neergaard v. Neergaard ColonFirst Circuit· 2014-05-21· cited 13×
- Asli Baz v. Anthony PattersonSeventh Circuit· 2024-04-30· cited 11×
- Morales v. MartinezM.D. Florida· 2014-06-19· cited 8×
- Maurice Didon v. Alicia CastilloThird Circuit· 2016-09-26· cited 7×
- Lakeman v. Weed (In re Weed)D. Minnesota· 2012-09-18· cited 7×
- Sami Abou-Haidar v. Maria Sanin VazquezD.C. Circuit· 2019-12-27· cited 6×
- Cunningham v. CunninghamM.D. Florida· 2017-02-17· cited 6×
- Stern v. SternEighth Circuit· 2011-05-06· cited 5×
- Naoteru Tsuruta v. Sarah TsurutaEighth Circuit· 2023-08-10· cited 5×
- Nisbet v. BridgerNinth Circuit· 2024-12-20· cited 5×
Cites
14 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- In Re: The Application Of, Arnon Mozes v. Michal MozesNinth Circuit· 2001-01-09· cited 276×
- Edward M. Feder v. Melissa Ann Evans-FederThird Circuit· 1995-08-24· cited 250×
- Jeremiah W. Holder v. Carla R. Holder, Jeremiah W. Holder v. Carla R. HolderNinth Circuit· 2002-09-06· cited 244×
- Tsai-Yi Yang v. Fu-Chiang TsuiThird Circuit· 2005-08-03· cited 166×
- Robert Hechter Silverman v. Julie Hechter SilvermanEighth Circuit· 2003-08-05· cited 98×
- Haim Shalit v. Cheryl Coppe, A/K/A Cheryl Gardner ShalitNinth Circuit· 1999-09-14· cited 91×
- Stephen Halladay Croll v. Mei Yee CrollSecond Circuit· 2000-09-20· cited 86×
- Carrascosa v. McGuireThird Circuit· 2008-03-20· cited 85×
- Tom A. Furnes v. Pamela Kay ReevesEleventh Circuit· 2004-03-10· cited 74×
- McCreary v. McCrearyMissouri Court of Appeals· 1997-08-19· cited 45×
- Barzilay v. BarzilayEighth Circuit· 2008-08-04· cited 30×
- Ripplin Shoals Land Company, Llc v. United States Army Corps Of EngineersEighth Circuit· 2006-03-17· cited 22×
- Villegas Duran v. Arribada BeaumontSecond Circuit· 2008-07-18· cited 18×
- Sorenson v. SorensonEighth Circuit· 2009-03-23· cited 12×
Other cases named Barzilay v. Barzilay
2 other CourtListener records share this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.