Ninth Circuit· 4/23/2008
Villegas v. Mukasey
Citations
- 523 F.3d 984
- 2008 U.S. App. LEXIS 8730
- 2008 WL 1808390
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- concluding that the conditions in the Mexican mental health system did not amount to torture because they did not exist out of a deliberate intent to inflict harm
- holding that although Mexican mental patients were “housed in terrible squalor,” nothing indicated that Mexican officials created those conditions for the specific purpose of inflicting suffering upon patients
- holding that specific intent to torture is a necessary showing for a CAT claim
- holding that “deplorable” prison conditions did not constitute torture absent an intent to harm
- explaining that circumstances evincing “desire to improve” confirmed that mistreatment resulted from “historical gross negligence and misunderstanding” of mental health issues, not a “deliberate intent to inflict harm”
- finding that conditions in the Mexican mental health system did not warrant CAT relief where “nothing indicates that Mexican [mental health] officials . . . created these conditions for the specific purpose of inflicting suffering upon the patients”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Cynthia Holcomb Hall, T.G. Nelson, and Barry G. Silverman, Circuit Judges
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
29 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Cole v. HolderNinth Circuit· 2011-09-22· cited 436×
- Jose Guerra v. William BarrNinth Circuit· 2020-03-03· cited 128×
- Jean Ridore v. Eric H. Holder Jr.Ninth Circuit· 2012-10-03· cited 116×
- Julio Benedicto v. Merrick GarlandNinth Circuit· 2021-09-09· cited 58×
- Eneh v. HolderNinth Circuit· 2010-04-15· cited 49×
- Uribe Andrade v. GarlandNinth Circuit· 2024-03-01· cited 34×
- J-R-G-PBoard of Immigration Appeals· 2018-07-01· cited 31×
- Cherichel v. HolderEighth Circuit· 2010-01-12· cited 28×
- Delgado v. HolderNinth Circuit· 2009-04-17· cited 26×
- Wilber Acevedo Granado v. Merrick GarlandNinth Circuit· 2021-03-24· cited 25×
- Gourdet v. HolderFirst Circuit· 2009-11-04· cited 22×
- Rene Lemus-Escobar v. Pamela BondiNinth Circuit· 2025-06-16· cited 12×
- Wilerms Oxygene v. Loretta LynchFourth Circuit· 2016-02-22· cited 11×
- Delgado v. MukaseyNinth Circuit· 2008-10-08· cited 9×
- Prasoprat v. BenovC.D. California· 2009-05-25· cited 4×
- Lawal v. LynchS.D. Texas· 2016-01-12· cited 4×
- Tifow v. MukaseyNinth Circuit· 2008-12-09· cited 1×
- Gambino v. HolderNinth Circuit· 2009-02-18· cited 1×
- Shoodley Cherichel v. Eric H. Holder, Jr.Eighth Circuit· 2010-01-12
- Delgado v. MukaseyNinth Circuit· 2008-10-07
Cites
13 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Immigration & Naturalization Service v. Aguirre-AguirreSupreme Court· 1999-05-03· cited 1,159×
- Mario Ernesto Navas v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceNinth Circuit· 2000-06-20· cited 674×
- Takky Zubeda v. John Ashcroft, Attorney General of the United StatesThird Circuit· 2003-06-23· cited 642×
- Li Chen Zheng, AKA Zheng Li Chen v. John Ashcroft, Attorney GeneralNinth Circuit· 2003-06-18· cited 500×
- Pierre v. GonzalesSecond Circuit· 2007-09-11· cited 212×
- Auguste v. RidgeThird Circuit· 2005-01-20· cited 196×
- Majd v. GonzalesFifth Circuit· 2006-04-17· cited 188×
- Mudher Jassim Mohamed Al-Saher v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceNinth Circuit· 2001-10-23· cited 158×
- J-EBoard of Immigration Appeals· 2002-07-01· cited 156×
- Jatinder Pal Singh v. John Ashcroft, Attorney General Charles H. DemoreNinth Circuit· 2003-12-05· cited 140×
- Nancy Arabillas Morales v. Alberto R. Gonzales, Attorney GeneralNinth Circuit· 2007-01-03· cited 137×
- Ehi Joseph Unuakhaulu v. Alberto R. Gonzales, Attorney GeneralNinth Circuit· 2005-08-04· cited 98×
- Anatoly Aelkseevich Matsuk v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceNinth Circuit· 2001-04-25· cited 78×
Other cases named Villegas v. Mukasey
3 other CourtListener records share this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.