Sumbundu v. Holder

How courts have described this case

Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.

• noting that courts of appeals retain jurisdiction to review the agency’s hardship determinations for constitutional claims and questions of law
• expressly leaving open the issue whether catchall moral character decisions are non-discretionary and fully reviewable because the question was not necessary in that case

Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).

Cited by

6 cases in this archive cite this case.

• Shabaj v. Holder
  Second Circuit· 2013-01-15· cited 73×
• Argueta v. Holder
  Second Circuit· 2010-08-06· cited 52×
• Elias Jimenez-Galicia v. U.S. Attorney General
  Eleventh Circuit· 2012-08-13· cited 40×
• Dos Reis v. McCleary
  D. Massachusetts· 2016-08-11· cited 3×
• Adolfo Acevedo Ibarra v. Pamela Bondi
  Fourth Circuit· 2025-04-29· cited 2×
• Shabaj v. Holder
  Second Circuit· 2013-04-25

Cites

17 cases in this archive are cited by this case.

• Xiao Ji Chen v. United States Department of Justice, Attorney General Alberto R. Gonzales
  Second Circuit· 2006-12-07· cited 2,764×
• Azmond Ali v. Alberto R. Gonzales, Attorney General of the United States
  Second Circuit· 2006-05-12· cited 1,744×
• Bah v. Mukasey
  Second Circuit· 2008-06-11· cited 1,199×
• Unnamed case
  Ninth Circuit· 1997-12-01· cited 851×
• Barco-Sandoval v. Gonzales
  Second Circuit· 2008-01-25· cited 309×
• Mendez v. Holder
  Second Circuit· 2009-05-08· cited 269×
• Efrain Modesto Calle-Vujiles v. John Ashcroft, Attorney General of the United States
  Third Circuit· 2003-03-05· cited 261×
• Enriquez-Alvarado v. Ashcroft
  Fifth Circuit· 2004-05-19· cited 156×
• Bernal-Vallejo v. Immigration & Naturalization Service
  First Circuit· 1999-11-02· cited 127×
• Luis Sepulveda v. Alberto Gonzales, Attorney General of the United States, 1
  Second Circuit· 2005-05-04· cited 120×
• Luis v. Immigration & Naturalization Service
  First Circuit· 1999-11-08· cited 98×
• PEREZ-CONTRERAS
  Board of Immigration Appeals· 1992-07-01· cited 46×
• Martha Leticia Salvador-Calleros v. John Ashcroft, Attorney General
  Ninth Circuit· 2004-11-23· cited 37×
• Jun Min Zhang v. Gonzales
  Second Circuit· 2006-07-12· cited 29×
• S-A-K- and H-A-H
  Board of Immigration Appeals· 2008-07-01· cited 13×
• URPI-SANCHO
  Board of Immigration Appeals· 1970-07-01· cited 5×
• LOCICERO
  Board of Immigration Appeals· 1966-07-01· cited 3×