Shabaj v. Holder

How courts have described this case

Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.

• concluding that the Second Circuit, not the district court, could possibly have jurisdiction under subsection (a)(2)(D
• holding that, “while this [Circuit] court would have jurisdiction to review any constitutional claims or questions of law properly raised in a petition for review, the district court [does] not have jurisdiction”
• observing that regardless of the federal question statute, “the judicial review provisions of the APA do not apply ‘to the extent that . . . statutes preclude judicial review’”
• noting that the district court lacked jurisdiction over plaintiff’s claim because the language in 8 U.S.C. § 1252(a)(2)(D) requires that the claim be raised “upon a petition for review filed with an appropriate court of appeals.” (emphasis in original)
• finding the court lacked jurisdiction to review denial of an inadmissibility waiver under §§ 1182(i)(2) and 1252(a)(2)(B)
• finding that the APA challenge to USCIS’s denial of his application for a waiver of admissibility was barred by judicial review because “the judicial review provisions of the APA do not apply ‘to the extent that . . . statutes preclude judicial review.’ ”

Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).

Cited by

15 cases in this archive cite this case.

• Öztürk v. Hyde
  Second Circuit· 2025-05-07· cited 123×
• Greene v. Gerber Products Co.
  E.D. New York· 2017-08-02· cited 84×
• Sunrise Detox V, LLC v. City of White Plains
  Second Circuit· 2014-10-02· cited 42×
• Horsham v. Fresh Direct
  E.D. New York· 2015-09-28· cited 18×
• Nouritajer v. Jaddou
  Second Circuit· 2021-11-15· cited 13×
• Powell v. Delta Airlines
  E.D. New York· 2015-11-06· cited 13×
• Mahdawi v. Trump
  Second Circuit· 2025-05-09· cited 13×
• Edner v. NYCTA-MTA
  E.D. New York· 2015-09-18· cited 12×
• Lucas v. United States
  Second Circuit· 2015-01-07· cited 6×
• Makransky v. Johnson
  E.D. New York· 2016-03-29· cited 5×
• Yu Mei Chen v. Nielsen
  E.D. New York· 2019-03-06· cited 5×
• Ford v. United States
  E.D. New York· 2015-02-10· cited 2×
• Sunrise Detox v. City of White Plains
  Second Circuit· 2014-10-02
• Chairez v. Mayorkas
  Ninth Circuit· 2026-03-05
• Make The Road New York v. Markwayne Mullin
  D.C. Circuit· 2026-06-23

Cites

8 cases in this archive are cited by this case.

• Carol Aurecchione v. Schoolman Transportation System, Inc., Classic Coach and Bill Schoolman, Docket No. 04-0561-Cv
  Second Circuit· 2005-10-17· cited 517×
• Sharkey v. Quarantillo
  Second Circuit· 2008-09-03· cited 208×
• Nethagani v. Mukasey
  Second Circuit· 2008-07-09· cited 93×
• Jun Min Zhang v. Gonzales
  Second Circuit· 2006-07-12· cited 29×
• Camara v. Department of Homeland Security
  Second Circuit· 2007-08-02· cited 25×
• Sumbundu v. Holder
  Second Circuit· 2010-04-07· cited 19×
• Shabaj v. Holder
  Second Circuit· 2010-04-12· cited 18×
• Qi Liang Chen v. Napolitano
  S.D. New York· 2009-08-26· cited 4×

Other cases named Shabaj v. Holder

3 other CourtListener records share this case name.

• Shabaj v. Holder
  Second Circuit· 2010-04-12· cited 18×
• Shabaj v. Holder
  Second Circuit· 2013-01-15· cited 6×
• Shabaj v. Holder
  Second Circuit· 2013-04-25