Fifth Circuit· 3/17/2006
Shehu v. Gonzales
Citations
- 443 F.3d 435
- 2006 U.S. App. LEXIS 6739
- 2006 WL 679020
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that private violence “cannot be labeled ‘persecution’ absent some proof” that government “condoned it or at least demonstrated a complete helplessness to protect the victims” (internal quotation marks omitted)
- concluding that the evidence did not compel a determination that Shehu was entitled to humanitarian asylum after finding that she failed to demonstrate she had suffered past persecution
- holding that private party violence “cannot be labeled ‘persecution’ absent some proof that the … government condoned it or at least demonstrated a complete helplessness to protect the victims”
- upholding the IJ’s finding of changed conditions following changes in the country’s government and significant decreases in violence
- denying petition for review on humanitarian-asylum claim because applicant failed to demonstrate past persecution
- presumption from past persecution at the hands of the Serbian-dominated police or Serbian paramilitary forces rebutted where the Serbs were no longer in control of the government of Kosovo
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Smith, Garza, Prado
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
17 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Cole v. HolderNinth Circuit· 2011-09-22· cited 436×
- Maria Gonzales-Veliz v. William Barr, U. S. Atty GFifth Circuit· 2019-09-10· cited 186×
- Singh v. GarlandSecond Circuit· 2021-08-25· cited 128×
- Scarlett v. BarrSecond Circuit· 2020-04-28· cited 121×
- Edil Galeas Figueroa v. Attorney General United StatesThird Circuit· 2021-05-19· cited 43×
- Visca Imelda v. U.S. Attorney GeneralEleventh Circuit· 2010-07-12· cited 35×
- Sanchez-Amador v. GarlandFifth Circuit· 2022-04-11· cited 27×
- Bertrand v. GarlandFifth Circuit· 2022-06-03· cited 16×
- El Paso Healthcare System, Ltd. v. Molina Healthcare of New Mexico, Inc.W.D. Texas· 2010-01-21· cited 12×
- Mejia-Alvarenga v. GarlandFifth Circuit· 2024-03-08· cited 12×
- Mejia-Alvarenga v. GarlandFifth Circuit· 2024-01-03· cited 1×
- M-KBoard of Immigration Appeals· 2026-04-09· cited 1×
- A-BBoard of Immigration Appeals· 2021-07-01
- Eminovska v. GonzalesFifth Circuit· 2006-04-21
- Qin Qin Wang v. United States Department of JusticeSecond Circuit· 2007-01-17
- Montiel Rubio v. BondiFifth Circuit· 2025-08-13
- Fuentes-Pineda v. BondiFifth Circuit· 2026-03-24
Cites
19 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Immigration & Naturalization Service v. Elias-ZacariasSupreme Court· 1992-01-22· cited 8,324×
- Tatiana Poradisova, Pavel Poradisov, and Gennadi Poradisov v. Alberto Gonzales, 1Second Circuit· 2005-08-16· cited 496×
- Michael Andrew Gormley Edith Carol Gormley v. John Ashcroft, Attorney GeneralNinth Circuit· 2004-04-22· cited 376×
- CHENBoard of Immigration Appeals· 1989-07-01· cited 297×
- Saleh Capric, Camila Capric, Albert Capric, and Elvis Capric v. John D. Ashcroft, Attorney General of the United States, 1Seventh Circuit· 2004-01-23· cited 285×
- Nabil Raja Dandan, Ketty Dandan, Souzi Dandan, A.K.A. Souzy Dandan, Sandra Dandan, and Raja Nabil Dandan v. John Ashcroft, Attorney GeneralSeventh Circuit· 2003-08-11· cited 229×
- Elrem Islami v. Alberto Gonzales, United States Attorney General, Bureau of Citizenship and Immigration ServicesSecond Circuit· 2005-06-23· cited 195×
- David Daada Gonahasa v. U.S. Immigration & Naturalization ServiceFourth Circuit· 1999-05-14· cited 145×
- Svetlana Galina and Viatcheslav Galin v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceSeventh Circuit· 2000-05-22· cited 130×
- Jan Zalega v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceSeventh Circuit· 1990-10-26· cited 114×
- Unnamed caseSeventh Circuit· 1997-03-26· cited 90×
- Soroya Sharif v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceSeventh Circuit· 1996-07-03· cited 76×
- Gjergj Prela, Also Known as Grergi Prela v. John D. AshcroftSeventh Circuit· 2005-01-07· cited 73×
- Rafael Barreto-Claro v. The U.S. Attorney GeneralEleventh Circuit· 2001-12-19· cited 56×
- Tedros G. Medhin v. John Ashcroft, United States Attorney GeneralSeventh Circuit· 2003-12-01· cited 51×
- Yuqing Zhu v. AshcroftFifth Circuit· 2004-08-19· cited 49×
- Christina Dobrota and Ovidiu Teodorescu v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceSeventh Circuit· 2000-01-06· cited 45×
- Grishaj v. Immigration & Naturalization ServiceSixth Circuit· 2004-06-17· cited 1×
- Erebara v. AshcroftSeventh Circuit· 2005-02-18· cited 1×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.