Ninth Circuit· 9/21/2012
Native Ecosystems Council v. Leslie Weldon
Citations
- 697 F.3d 1043
- 12 Cal. Daily Op. Serv. 10
- 42 Envtl. L. Rep. (Envtl. Law Inst.) 20199
- 2012 WL 4215919
- 75 ERC (BNA) 1385
- 2012 U.S. App. LEXIS 19872
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that a reporting inadequacy does not violate NFMA absent a causal link between the inadequacy and the challenge to the project
- stating that the agency's interpretation is entitled to \substantial deference\
- deferring to the challenged agency’s conclusion where the agency “reasonably determined” reports that the agency considered were “based upon corrected and more recent data and various studies”
- “Forest plans are designed to manage forest resources by balancing the eon-sideration of environmental and economic factors.”
- “[A]n agency must have discretion to rely on the reasonable opinions of its own qualified experts.”
- “Forest plans are designed to manage forest resources by balancing the consideration of environmental and economic factors.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Reinhardt, Kleinfeld, Smith
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
38 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Friends of the Wild Swan v. Chip WeberNinth Circuit· 2014-09-24· cited 158×
- Alliance for the Wild Rockies v. UsfsNinth Circuit· 2018-10-25· cited 72×
- Great Old Broads for Wildernes v. Abigail KimbellNinth Circuit· 2013-03-04· cited 52×
- United States v. Jonathan ThomasNinth Circuit· 2013-08-08· cited 41×
- Protect Our Communities Foundation v. JewellNinth Circuit· 2016-06-07· cited 30×
- Alliance for the Wild Rockies v. Christopher SavageNinth Circuit· 2018-07-26· cited 21×
- Desert Protective Council v. United States Department of the InteriorS.D. California· 2013-02-27· cited 17×
- Bess Bair v. Cal. Dept of Transp.Ninth Circuit· 2020-12-02· cited 15×
- Audubon Society of Portland v. Deb HaalandNinth Circuit· 2022-07-18· cited 13×
- Southeast Alaska Conservation Council v. United States Forest ServiceNinth Circuit· 2017-05-23· cited 12×
- Alliance for the Wild Rockies v. Paul BradfordNinth Circuit· 2017-05-17· cited 10×
- Aqualliance v. U.S. Bureau of ReclamationE.D. California· 2018-02-15· cited 9×
- Earth Island Inst. v. ElliottE.D. California· 2018-07-09· cited 7×
- Native Ecosystems Council v. EricksonD. Montana· 2018-08-01· cited 7×
- Sierra Club v. Tahoe Regional Planning AgencyNinth Circuit· 2016-11-02· cited 6×
- WildEarth Guardians v. JeffriesD. Oregon· 2019-01-03· cited 6×
- Wild v. United States Forest ServiceD. Oregon· 2015-05-29· cited 4×
- Backcountry Against Dumps v. ChuS.D. California· 2015-09-29· cited 4×
- Sierra Club v. Tahoe Regional Planning AgencyE.D. California· 2013-01-04· cited 4×
- Idaho Wool Growers Ass'n v. VilsackD. Idaho· 2014-03-25· cited 3×
Cites
18 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Winter v. Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc.Supreme Court· 2008-11-12· cited 11,986×
- Motor Vehicle Mfrs. Assn. of United States, Inc. v. State Farm Mut. Automobile Ins. Co.Supreme Court· 1983-06-24· cited 8,453×
- Singleton v. WulffSupreme Court· 1976-07-01· cited 3,831×
- Marsh v. Oregon Natural Resources CouncilSupreme Court· 1989-05-01· cited 2,029×
- Robertson v. Methow Valley Citizens CouncilSupreme Court· 1989-05-01· cited 1,465×
- Baltimore Gas & Electric Co. v. Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc.Supreme Court· 1983-06-06· cited 1,328×
- Ohio Forestry Assn., Inc. v. Sierra ClubSupreme Court· 1998-05-26· cited 757×
- The Lands Council v. McNairNinth Circuit· 2008-07-02· cited 543×
- Citizens For Better Forestry v. U.S. Department Of AgricultureNinth Circuit· 2003-08-28· cited 179×
- Tri-Valley Cares v. U.S. Department of EnergyNinth Circuit· 2012-02-07· cited 141×
- Morongo Band of Mission Indians v. Federal Aviation Administration William Withycombe, Regional Administrator, FaaNinth Circuit· 1998-11-23· cited 141×
- Neighbors of Cuddy Mountain v. AlexanderNinth Circuit· 2002-09-05· cited 130×
- Native Ecosystems Council v. U.S. Forest Service, an agency of U.S. Dept. of AgricultureNinth Circuit· 2005-08-11· cited 129×
- Northern Plains Resource Council, Inc. v. Surface Transportation BoardNinth Circuit· 2011-12-29· cited 119×
- MacDonald v. Grace Church SeattleNinth Circuit· 2006-08-10· cited 117×
- Ecology Center v. CastanedaNinth Circuit· 2009-07-22· cited 107×
- Bering Strait Citizens for Responsible Resource Development v. United States Army Corps of EngineersNinth Circuit· 2008-01-02· cited 86×
- Hapner v. TidwellNinth Circuit· 2010-09-15· cited 28×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.