Jones v. Flowers
Citations
- 547 U.S. 220
- 126 S. Ct. 1708
- 164 L. Ed. 2d 415
- 2006 U.S. LEXIS 3451
About this case
Jones v. Flowers
Jones v. Flowers, 547 U.S. 220 (2006), was a decision by the Supreme Court of the United States involving the due process requirement that a state give notice to an owner before selling his property to satisfy his unpaid taxes . The Court ruled, 5-3,[1] that after a mailed notice was returned unclaimed, a state was required by the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment to take additional reasonable steps to notify the owner before the sale could proceed.[2] The Court's opinion was delivered by Chief Justice John G. Roberts , his fourth majority opinion after his confirmation to the Court in 2005 and his first to provoke any dissenting opinions .[3] [4] [5]
The Court had last addressed the issue of notice in _Dusenbery v. United States _,[6] which held that the government need only take steps reasonably calculated to provide notice even if actual notice is not achieved. The four justices who dissented in Dusenbery formed the majority with Roberts in Jones v. Flowers, distinguishing the prior case on the basis that the government in Dusenbery did not know that its method of notice had failed before the taking occurred. Justice Clarence Thomas , in dissent, believed the Court was instead undermining Dusenbery, which he argued implicitly dictated a result contrary to the majority's decision.
Contents
Background
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Jones_v._Flowers&action=edit§ion=1 "Edit section: Background")
Tax delinquency and sale
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Jones_v._Flowers&action=edit§ion=2 "Edit section: Tax delinquency and sale")
In 1967, Gary Jones purchased a house in Little Rock, Arkansas , in which he lived with his wife until they separated in 1993. Jones then moved into an apartment in Little Rock, and his wife continued to live in the house. Jones paid his mortgage each month for 30 years, and the mortgage company paid Jones' property taxes . However, after Jones paid off his mortgage in 1997, his wife failed to pay the property taxes, and the property was certified as delinquent .
In April 2000, Mark Wilcox , the Arkansas Commissioner of State Lands , attempted to notify Jones of his tax delinquency, and his right to redeem the property, by mailing a certified letter to Jones at the house.[7] The packet of information stated that unless Jones redeemed the property, it would be subject to public sale two years later on April 17, 2002. Nobody was home to sign for the letter, and nobody appeared at the post office to retrieve the letter within the next 15 days. The post office returned the unopened packet to the Commissioner marked "unclaimed."
Two years later, and just a few weeks before the public sale, the Commissioner published a notice of public sale in the _Arkansas Democrat-Gazette _. No bids were submitted, which permitted the State to negotiate a private sale of the property.[8] Several months later, Linda Flowers submitted a purchase offer. The Commissioner mailed another certified letter to Jones at the house, attempting to notify him that his house would be sold to Flowers if he did not pay his taxes. Like the first letter, the second was also returned to the Commissioner marked "unclaimed." Flowers subsequently purchased the house at approximately a quarter of its fair market value . Immediately after the 30-day period for postsale redemption passed,[9] Flowers had an unlawful detainer notice delivered to the property. The notice was served on Jones' daughter, who contacted Jones and notified him of the unpaid taxes and the tax sale.
State court proceedings
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Jones_v._Flowers&action=edit§ion=3 "Edit section: State court proceedings")
Jones filed a lawsuit in Pulaski County Circuit Court against the Commissioner and Flowers, alleging that the Commissioner's failure to provide notice of the tax sale and of Jones' right to redeem resulted in the taking of his property without due process .[10] The Commissioner and Flowers moved for summary judgment on the ground that the two unclaimed letters sent by the Commissioner were a constitutionally adequate attempt at notice, and Jones filed a cross-motion for summary judgment. The trial court granted summary judgment in favor of the Commissioner and Flowers, concluding that the Arkansas tax sale statute, which set forth the notice procedure followed by the Commissioner, complied with constitutional due process requirements.
Jones appealed , and the Arkansas Supreme Court affirmed the trial court's judgment.[11] The court noted Supreme Court precedent stating that due process does not require actual notice , and that attempting to provide notice by certified mail satisfied due process in the circumstances presented.
Opinion of the Court
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Jones_v._Flowers&action=edit§ion=4 "Edit section: Opinion of the Court")
The Supreme Court granted certiorari [12] to resolve a conflict among the Circuits and state supreme courts concerning whether the Due Process Clause requires the government to take additional reasonable steps to notify a property owner when notice of a tax sale is returned undelivered.[13] The United States Solicitor General was granted leave to participate as _amicus curiae _,[14] and argued in support of the Commissioner's position.
In a five-justice opinion delivered by Chief Justice John G. Roberts , the Court reversed the Arkansas Supreme Court and ruled that, under the circumstances, the State's sale of Jones' property violated due process.[15] It held that "when mailed notice of a tax sale is returned unclaimed, the State must take additional reasonable steps to attempt to provide notice to the property owner before selling his property, if it is practicable to do so." Justice Clarence Thomas filed a dissent , arguing that the State's attempts went beyond any requirements the Court's prior precedents had established.
Roberts' majority opinion
…
Editorial context from Wikipedia (CC-BY-SA 4.0).
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- asserting that notice is “constitutionally sufficient if it was reasonably calculated to reach the intended recipient when sent”
- finding that posting notice on the front door or addressing otherwise undeliverable mail to the “occupant” is a reasonable follow-up measure
- rejecting the Arkansas Commissioner’s argument that the property owner waived service of process by failing to update his address with the state
- holding notice of impending tax sale of property was not reasonably calculated to reach property owner when notice sent via certified letter by state was returned unclaimed and state did not take additional reasonable steps to ensure notice was provided
- due process requires state to take additional steps to notice owner of property when certified mail notice of tax sale is returned unclaimed
- notice due to property owner in advance of tax sale
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Roberts, Thomas, Alito, Scalia, Kennedy
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
497 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- United Student Aid Funds, Inc. v. EspinosaSupreme Court· 2010-03-23· cited 1,364×
- District Attorney's Office for the Third Judicial District v. OsborneSupreme Court· 2009-06-18· cited 782×
- Maples v. ThomasSupreme Court· 2012-01-18· cited 724×
- In the Interest of E.R.Texas Supreme Court· 2012-07-06· cited 418×
- In Re RoodMichigan Supreme Court· 2009-04-02· cited 364×
- Cordell v. KlingsheimColorado Court of Appeals· 2018-05-31· cited 313×
- People ex rel. J.C.S.Colorado Court of Appeals· 2007-07-12· cited 194×
- Intellectual Ventures I LLC v. Symantec Corp.Federal Circuit· 2016-09-30· cited 193×
- Tyler v. Hennepin CountySupreme Court· 2023-05-25· cited 193×
- Miner v. Clinton County, NYSecond Circuit· 2008-09-05· cited 186×
- Oneida Indian Nation v. Madison CountySecond Circuit· 2011-10-20· cited 152×
- Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. v. AMH Roman Two NC, LLCFourth Circuit· 2017-06-12· cited 115×
- Sidun v. Wayne County TreasurerMichigan Supreme Court· 2008-07-02· cited 109×
- Garcia-Rubiera v. CalderonFirst Circuit· 2009-06-30· cited 105×
- S.M. v. E.M.B.R.Supreme Court of Missouri· 2011-01-25· cited 105×
- Espinosa v. United Student Aid Funds, Inc.Ninth Circuit· 2008-12-10· cited 102×
- In Re PETITION BY WAYNE COUNTY TREASURERMichigan Supreme Court· 2007-05-23· cited 81×
- City of Santa Monica v. GonzalezCalifornia Supreme Court· 2008-05-19· cited 78×
- People v. CardonaIllinois Supreme Court· 2013-04-26· cited 75×
- Snider International Corporation v. Town of Forest Heights, MDFourth Circuit· 2014-01-07· cited 71×
Cites
36 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Miranda v. ArizonaSupreme Court· 1966-06-13· cited 58,288×
- Mullane v. Central Hanover Bank & Trust Co.Supreme Court· 1950-06-05· cited 10,395×
- United States v. Donald Lawrence Ritchie, Heather Horner, Claimant-AppellantNinth Circuit· 2003-08-26· cited 2,266×
- Dickerson v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2000-06-26· cited 1,932×
- Mennonite Board of Missions v. AdamsSupreme Court· 1983-06-22· cited 1,416×
- Dusenbery v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2002-01-08· cited 924×
- Tulsa Professional Collection Services, Inc. v. PopeSupreme Court· 1988-04-19· cited 906×
- Schroeder v. City of New YorkSupreme Court· 1962-12-17· cited 569×
- Walker v. City of HutchinsonSupreme Court· 1956-12-10· cited 459×
- Greene v. LindseySupreme Court· 1982-05-17· cited 396×
- Barrera-Montenegro v. USA & Drug Enforcement AdministrationFifth Circuit· 1996-02-09· cited 377×
- Robinson v. HanrahanSupreme Court· 1972-10-24· cited 330×
- Covey v. Town of SomersSupreme Court· 1956-05-07· cited 240×
- The MARY, Stafford, MastfSupreme Court· 1815-02-25· cited 152×
- Terry L. Madewell v. Mike Downs, Anthony P. Grootens, and John PrineEighth Circuit· 1995-08-29· cited 151×
- Tracy v. County of Chester, Tax Claim BureauSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1985-04-03· cited 124×
- Jorge Sarit and Dennie Espaillat v. U.S. Drug Enforcement AdministrationFirst Circuit· 1993-02-23· cited 114×
- Clara Torres v. $36,256.80 U.S. CurrencySecond Circuit· 1994-06-10· cited 109×
- Kennedy v. MossafaNew York Court of Appeals· 2003-02-25· cited 82×
- Dahn v. TrownsellSouth Dakota Supreme Court· 1998-04-08· cited 70×
Other cases named Jones v. Flowers
6 other CourtListener records share this case name.
- Jones v. FlowersSupreme Court of Arkansas· 2008-04-17· cited 11×
- Jones v. FlowersSupreme Court of Arkansas· 2004-11-18· cited 10×
- Jones v. FlowersDistrict Court of Appeal of Florida· 1974-04-23· cited 1×
- Jones v. FlowersSupreme Court· 2005-09-27
- Jones v. FlowersSupreme Court· 2005-09-27
- Jones v. FlowersSupreme Court· 2006-01-06
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.