Ninth Circuit· 9/17/2014
George Gibbs v. Robert Legrand
Citations
- 767 F.3d 879
- 2014 U.S. App. LEXIS 17941
- 2014 WL 4627991
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- concluding that attorney abandonment constituted an extraordinary circumstance while it “obstruct[ed] [the petitioner’s] ability to file [her] federal petition”
- holding that a prisoner was “adequately diligent” when he wrote to his attorney three times over the course of seven months to find out if the state supreme court had ruled on his state petition
- holding that counsel’s failure to notify petitioner of state supreme court’s denial of his claim for post-conviction relief “constituted abandonment, and thereby created extraordinary circumstances sufficient to justify equitable tolling” of the federal habeas filing deadline
- highlighting that Gibbs wrote to his attorney several times, and his attorney did not respond
- finding that the defendant acted with reasonable diligence when he relied on his attorney during the period in question and had no reason to contact the court
- explaining that “a prisoner’s lack of knowledge that the state courts have reached a final resolution of his case can provide grounds for equitable tolling” (internal quotation marks omitted)
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Thomas, Fisher, Berzon
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
16 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Anthony Smith v. Ron DavisNinth Circuit· 2020-03-20· cited 311×
- Benito Luna v. Scott KernanNinth Circuit· 2015-04-28· cited 275×
- Rudin v. MylesNinth Circuit· 2014-09-10· cited 102×
- Willie Grant v. Gary SwarthoutNinth Circuit· 2017-07-07· cited 81×
- Steven Fue v. Martin BiterNinth Circuit· 2016-11-17· cited 78×
- Choice Hotels International In v. Anuj GroverSeventh Circuit· 2015-07-07· cited 40×
- Mark Foley v. Martin BiterNinth Circuit· 2015-07-14· cited 24×
- Milby v. Templeton (In Re Milby)Ninth Circuit· 2017-11-21· cited 10×
- Uwakwe v. Pelham Acad.District of Columbia· 2017-12-11· cited 8×
- Roger Coulter v. Wendy KelleyEighth Circuit· 2017-09-14· cited 6×
- Chad Lee v. Ryan ThornellNinth Circuit· 2024-06-11· cited 3×
- In re Pers. Restraint of FowlerWashington Supreme Court· 2021-02-04· cited 3×
- Steven Fue v. Martin BiterNinth Circuit· 2016-01-15· cited 2×
- Margaret Rudin v. Carolyn MylesNinth Circuit· 2015-03-10
- Chad Lee v. Ryan ThornellNinth Circuit· 2024-09-30
- Gladys Perez v. William ReubartNinth Circuit· 2025-08-28
Cites
19 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Pace v. DiGuglielmoSupreme Court· 2005-04-27· cited 4,510×
- Holland v. FloridaSupreme Court· 2010-06-14· cited 3,974×
- Oscar Socop-Gonzalez v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceNinth Circuit· 2001-12-05· cited 738×
- Maples v. ThomasSupreme Court· 2012-01-18· cited 724×
- Willie Lee Miles v. K.W. Prunty, Warden Attorney General of the State of CaliforniaNinth Circuit· 1999-08-13· cited 646×
- Sergey Spitsyn v. Robert Moore, WardenNinth Circuit· 2003-11-03· cited 488×
- Alixcair Valverde v. James Stinson, Superintendent, Great Meadow Corr. Fac.Second Circuit· 2000-09-11· cited 466×
- Armando Sossa v. Ralph M. DiazNinth Circuit· 2013-09-10· cited 388×
- Michael Lacava v. Kenneth D. Kyler the District Attorney for Philadelphia County the Attorney General of the State of PennsylvaniaThird Circuit· 2005-02-11· cited 292×
- Ramirez v. YatesNinth Circuit· 2009-07-10· cited 246×
- Anthony Lewis Whalem/hunt v. Rchard Early, WardenNinth Circuit· 2000-12-07· cited 207×
- Doe v. BusbyNinth Circuit· 2011-10-24· cited 202×
- Harris v. CarterNinth Circuit· 2008-02-08· cited 192×
- Robert Lee Lott v. Glenn A. Mueller, WardenNinth Circuit· 2002-09-19· cited 179×
- Robert Jerome Espinoza-Matthews v. People of the State of California, Attorney GeneralNinth Circuit· 2005-12-28· cited 138×
- Woodward v. WilliamsTenth Circuit· 2001-08-17· cited 123×
- Robert Charles Towery v Charles RyanNinth Circuit· 2012-02-27· cited 68×
- Andrew MacKey v. Thomas HoffmanNinth Circuit· 2012-06-25· cited 58×
- Margaret Rudin v. Carolyn MylesNinth Circuit· 2014-09-10· cited 6×
Other cases named George Gibbs v. Robert Legrand
2 other CourtListener records share this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.