Saudi Arabia v. Nelson
Citations
- 507 U.S. 349
- 113 S. Ct. 1471
- 123 L. Ed. 2d 47
- 1993 U.S. LEXIS 2398
About this case
Saudi Arabia v. Nelson
Learn more
This article includes a list of references , related reading , or external links , **but its sources remain unclear because it lacks inline citations **. Please help improve this article by introducing more precise citations. (September 2022) (Learn how and when to remove this message )
Saudi Arabia v. Nelson, 507 U.S. 349 (1993), is a United States Supreme Court case in which the Court considered the term "based upon a commercial activity" within the meaning of the first clause of 1605(a)(2) of the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act of 1976.
Contents
Background
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Saudi_Arabia_v._Nelson&action=edit§ion=1 "Edit section: Background")
A U.S. citizen Nelson filed suit against Saudi Arabia for alleged abuse and torture suffered while under arrest in Saudi Arabia.
A married couple of United States citizenry filed a tort action against the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, King Faisal Specialist Hospital in Riyadh owned by the Saudi government, and the hospital's corporate agent in the US, Royspec Purchasing Services. The tort claim against these three entities collectively referred to as the Saudi government alleged that Mr. Nelson, a hospital engineer in Riyadh, was subjected to illicit incarceration, routine torture spanning a four-day period, and failure to admonish him as to the potential risks incurred by whistle-blowing . Based on the Saudi government's alleged wrongful actions, Mr. Nelson believed the US Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act of 1976 (FSIA) authorized the court jurisdiction to hear the case.
The Hospital Corporation of America, Ltd. (HCA) , a career recruiting firm based in the US, placed ads in various media outlets for the position of monitoring systems engineer at the King Faisal Specialist Hospital in Riyadh. Mr. Nelson interviewed for the job in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, and later entered into an employment contract with the hospital through HCA. Mr. Nelson's family was informed Royspec Purchasing Services, based in the US, was the designated agent through which to contact Mr. Nelson in an emergency.
Mr. Nelson began his new job in December 1983, which entailed monitoring "facilities, equipment, utilities, and maintenance systems to ensure the safety of patients, hospital staff, and others" (Saudi Arabia v. Nelson). Shortly after employment began he discovered numerous safety violations and defects throughout the hospital, of which he promptly informed his superiors and a Saudi government commission of the infractions. He was asked to ignore the problems by the hospital, but he persisted.
On September 27, 1984, Mr. Nelson was detained and subsequently tortured until signing a coerced statement, which was in Arabic , a language he did not understand. Two days later he was imprisoned at Al Penitentiary without being charged with a crime. Mr. Nelson's wife was informed of her husband's whereabouts several days later but could not condition a release. On November 5, 1984, Mr. Nelson was released from prison through the plea of a US senator and left the country shortly thereafter through the permission of the Saudi Government. Mr. Nelson's employment contract was shortly terminated thereafter.
The plaintiff, Mr. Nelson, asserted the defendant, Saudi Arabia, was not immune to prosecution under the FSIA, which enumerates exceptions of which any must exist in order to deny a foreign state's sovereign immunity. The list of exceptions refer to a state's conduct only. A state is denied sovereign foreign immunity if the state's conduct is private, not public; private, not sovereign; commercial, not non-commercial; or trade-related, not political (Slomanson, 100). Specifically, the commercial activity immunity exception was used by Mr. Nelson. The plaintiff asserted job recruitment, contract of employment, and employment itself constituted the commercial activity that led to and associates the wrongful injury claim with the Saudi Government's commercial activity. Therefore, the plaintiff claims that the process of recruiting, hiring, and subsequent employment led to or indirectly are associated with his tortious injuries.
This case was first heard by a federal trial court that dismissed the case for lack of subject-matter jurisdiction
because the FSIA did not define commercial activity as imprisonment and torture.[_clarification needed
_] The case traveled to an appellate court, which held recruiting, hiring, and employing all entailed commercial activities that led to the wrongful injury, thus establishing jurisdiction to hear the case under FSIA. The appellate court overturned the district court's dismissal, but the Supreme Court reached the final, conclusive ruling.
Opinion of the Court
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Saudi_Arabia_v._Nelson&action=edit§ion=2 "Edit section: Opinion of the Court")
The Court's majority opinion, delivered by Justice Souter, held that the wrongful injury claim brought by Mr. and Mrs. Nelson was not "based upon a commercial activity" according to the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act of 1976 (section 1605(a)(2)). The Court of Appeals judgment was thereby reversed, thus restoring the trial courts dismissal based upon a "lack of subject-matter jurisdiction".
The court reasoned that the tortious acts of the defendant were not "based upon a commercial activity", therefore not in violation of the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act of 1976. The defendant's conduct, however heinous, could not be classified as being "based upon a commercial activity". The tortious conduct rather is a gross abuse of state police power, which is an act only performed by sovereign states. Only States perform acts such as unlawful detention of private citizens, torture, conduct foreign engagements, and diplomatic relations. Private citizens cannot participate in acts of state.
Concurrences
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Saudi_Arabia_v._Nelson&action=edit§ion=3 "Edit section: Concurrences")
Justice White and Justice Blackmun concurred with Justice Souter's majority opinion, with one caveat. The justices disagreed that the defendant's tortious conduct was not "based upon a commercial activity", but nonetheless concurred with the majority judgment because the commercial acts did not occur in the US.
Dissents
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Saudi_Arabia_v._Nelson&action=edit§ion=4 "Edit section: Dissents")
Justice Kennedy believed the wrongful acts perpetrated by the defendant did constitute commercial activity. Under FSIA, the Saudi Government's operation of the hospital, employment practices, and disciplinary procedures were "based upon commercial activity" and therefore the plaintiff proved the court did have jurisdiction.
Additionally, unlike Justice White, he believed the defendant's commercial activities did have adequate contact within the United States to fulfill an immunity exception under the FSIA.
See also
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Saudi_Arabia_v._Nelson&action=edit§ion=5 "Edit section: See also")
External links
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Saudi_Arabia_v._Nelson&action=edit§ion=6 "Edit section: External links")
- Text of Saudi Arabia v. Nelson, 507 U.S. 349 (1993) is available from: Findlaw Internet Archive (docket files) Justia Library of Congress Oyez (oral argument audio)
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Saudi_Arabia_v._Nelson&oldid=1363544912 "
Editorial context from Wikipedia (CC-BY-SA 4.0).
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- \a foreign state's exercise of the power of its police has long been understood... as particularly sovereign in nature\
- \[A] foreign state's exercise of the power of its police has long been understood... as peculiarly sovereign in nature.\
- “Under the [FSIA], a foreign state is presumptively immune from the jurisdiction of the United States courts; unless a specified exception applies, a federal court lacks subject-matter jurisdiction over a claim against a foreign state.”
- “If this is a definition, it is one distinguished 20 only by its diffidence.”
- “[A] foreign state is presumptively immune from suit in United States’ courts.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Souter, Rehnquist, O'Connor, Scalia, Thomas, Kennedy, White, Blackmun, Stevens, I-B
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
515 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Mwani, Odilla Mutaka v. Bin Ladin, UsamaD.C. Circuit· 2005-08-05· cited 552×
- Price v. Socialist People's Libyan Arab JamahiriyaD.C. Circuit· 2002-06-28· cited 329×
- Phoenix Consulting, Inc. v. Republic of AngolaD.C. Circuit· 2000-06-16· cited 314×
- Kelly v. Syria Shell Petroleum Development B.V.Fifth Circuit· 2000-05-31· cited 248×
- Flatow v. Islamic Republic of IranDistrict of Columbia· 1999-01-25· cited 233×
- James Owens v. Republic of SudanD.C. Circuit· 2017-07-28· cited 215×
- Doe v. SeeNinth Circuit· 2009-03-03· cited 188×
- Tara Ann Jungquist v. Sheikh Sultan Bin Khalifa Al NahyanD.C. Circuit· 1997-08-12· cited 184×
- The Export Group Emilio Figueroa Jack Andrews v. Reef Industries, Inc., and Mexican Coffee InstituteNinth Circuit· 1995-05-22· cited 181×
- Transaero, Inc. v. La Fuerza Aerea BolivianaD.C. Circuit· 1994-07-29· cited 177×
- Cargill International S.A., and Cargill, B v. V. M/t Pavel Dybenko, Her Engines, Tackle, Etc., in Rem Novorossiysk Shipping Co., in PersonamSecond Circuit· 1993-04-19· cited 173×
- Swarna v. Al-AwadiSecond Circuit· 2010-09-24· cited 158×
- Hughes v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2018-06-04· cited 158×
- In re PapandreouD.C. Circuit· 1998-04-10· cited 151×
- World Wide Minerals, Ltd. v. Republic of KazakhstanD.C. Circuit· 2002-08-02· cited 150×
- Creighton Ltd. v. Government of QatarD.C. Circuit· 1999-07-02· cited 144×
- Securities Investor Protection Corp. v. Bernard L. Madoff Investment Securities LLCS.D. New York· 2012-10-11· cited 144×
- Filetech S.A. v. France Telecom S.A.Second Circuit· 1998-10-06· cited 132×
- Republic of Iraq v. BeatySupreme Court· 2009-06-08· cited 130×
- David De Csepel v. Republic of HungaryD.C. Circuit· 2013-04-19· cited 130×
Cites
32 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Adickes v. S. H. Kress & Co.Supreme Court· 1970-06-01· cited 15,427×
- Wilson v. GarciaSupreme Court· 1985-04-17· cited 4,134×
- Montana v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1979-02-22· cited 3,633×
- Melkonyan v. SullivanSupreme Court· 1991-06-10· cited 3,376×
- United States v. GaubertSupreme Court· 1991-03-26· cited 2,087×
- Feres v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1950-12-04· cited 1,830×
- English v. General Electric Co.Supreme Court· 1990-06-04· cited 1,390×
- Verlinden B. v. v. Central Bank of NigeriaSupreme Court· 1983-05-23· cited 1,062×
- Lawlor v. National Screen Service Corp.Supreme Court· 1955-06-06· cited 1,049×
- Argentine Republic v. Amerada Hess Shipping Corp.Supreme Court· 1989-01-23· cited 993×
- Republic of Argentina v. Weltover, Inc.Supreme Court· 1992-06-12· cited 709×
- First National City Bank v. Banco Para El Comercio Exterior De CubaSupreme Court· 1983-06-17· cited 608×
- United States v. ShearerSupreme Court· 1985-06-27· cited 602×
- Sheridan v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1988-06-24· cited 442×
- Alfred Dunhill of London, Inc. v. Republic of CubaSupreme Court· 1976-05-24· cited 428×
- US Bank v. PLANTERS'BANKSupreme Court· 1824-03-22· cited 220×
- Texas Trading & Milling Corp. v. Federal Republic of NigeriaSecond Circuit· 1981-04-16· cited 207×
- Ramiro Arango and Gabriella Arango, Individually, Etc., Plaintiffs v. Guzman Travel Advisors Corporation, Etc.Fifth Circuit· 1980-07-25· cited 172×
- William F. Callejo, Individually and as Trustee, and Adelfa B. Callejo, as Trustee v. Bancomer, S.A.Fifth Circuit· 1985-07-16· cited 155×
- Victory Transport Incorporated, Owner of the S.S. Hudson v. Comisaria General De Abastecimientos Y Transportes, Voyage Charterer of thes.s. HudsonSecond Circuit· 1964-09-09· cited 126×
Other cases named Saudi Arabia v. Nelson
4 other CourtListener records share this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.