Perry v. Schwarzenegger
Citations
- 591 F.3d 1147
- 2010 U.S. App. LEXIS 164
- 38 Media L. Rep. (BNA) 1107
- 2010 WL 26439
About this case
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
(Redirected from Perry v. Schwarzenegger )
Series of U.S. federal court cases that reinstated same-sex marriage in California
2013 United States Supreme Court case
Hollingsworth v. Perry was a series of United States federal court cases that reinstated same-sex marriage in the state of California. The case began in 2009 in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California , which found that banning same-sex marriage violates equal protection under the law . This decision overturned California ballot initiative Proposition 8 , which had banned same-sex marriage. After the State of California refused to defend Proposition 8, the official sponsors of Proposition 8 intervened and appealed to the Supreme Court. The case was litigated during the governorships of both Arnold Schwarzenegger and Jerry Brown , and was thus known as Perry v. Schwarzenegger and Perry v. Brown, respectively. As Hollingsworth v. Perry, it eventually reached the United States Supreme Court , which held that, in line with prior precedent , the official sponsors of a ballot initiative measure did not have Article III standing to appeal an adverse federal court ruling when the state refused to do so.[1] The effect of the ruling was that same-sex marriage in California resumed under the district court trial decision from 2010.[2]
Background
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Hollingsworth_v._Perry&action=edit§ion=1 "Edit section: Background")
]
In May 2008, the California Supreme Court held in the case _In re Marriage Cases _ that state statutes limiting marriage to opposite-sex applicants violated the California Constitution .[3] The following month, same-sex couples became able to marry in California.[4] In November 2008, California's voters approved Proposition 8, an amendment to the state constitution that sought to restore a prior opposite-sex-couple limitation on marriage;[5] but following its adoption, several lawsuits were filed that challenged the validity of the amendment, under various state constitutional provisions.[6] On May 26, 2009, the California Supreme Court held, in _Strauss v. Horton _ that (while Proposition 8 was a lawful enactment), all same-sex marriages that had been contracted before the proposition's passage remained valid.[7]
The National Center for Lesbian Rights , Lambda Legal and American Civil Liberties Union had originally obtained the right to same-sex marriage in California , in In re Marriage Cases, and defended it in Strauss v. Horton. Three days before the Strauss decision occurred, the American Foundation for Equal Rights (AFER) filed suit in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California , to challenge the validity of Proposition 8 on behalf of two same-sex couples.[8] [9] [10] The couples' legal team was led by David Boies and former U.S. Solicitor General Theodore Olson (who, incidentally, had previously represented opposite parties in _Bush v. Gore _, with Boies representing Al Gore and Olson representing George W. Bush , the case that, effectively, decided the 2000 U.S. presidential election ).[11] In the 2010 Time 100 , they were listed, for "their nonpartisan and strong legal approach to challenging Proposition 8."[12]
Lambda Legal and the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) opposed the filing because they felt a federal challenge at this time might do more harm than good.[9] Olson and AFER rebuffed this argument and defended the timing of the lawsuit.[13] Following a pre-trial hearing on July 2, 2009, the three legal groups moved to intervene in the lawsuit, as did the City of San Francisco in a separate filing.[14] The plaintiffs opposed allowing the groups or the city to intervene.[15] On August 19, Judge Walker denied the legal groups' motions to intervene, but granted the City's, albeit in a limited capacity.[16] Despite the other groups' failed attempt to intervene in the lawsuit, they offered support to the legal team litigating the case, with James Esseks of the ACLU saying: "We are interested in doing whatever we can to make sure their case is as successful as possible".[8]
Parties
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Hollingsworth_v._Perry&action=edit§ion=2 "Edit section: Parties")
]
Plaintiffs
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Hollingsworth_v._Perry&action=edit§ion=3 "Edit section: Plaintiffs")
]
It was still emotional to be denied [a marriage license]. But in all fairness [to the clerk], she handled it really well. [Her words] reiterated that we were denied equal rights . It made us feel that we made the right decision to be a part of this case.[15]
— Jeffrey Zarrillo, co-plaintiff
In May 2009, the Alameda County Clerk-Registrar, Patrick O'Connell, denied Kristin Perry and Sandra Stier a marriage license because they are a same-sex couple.[17] For the same reason, Dean Logan, the Los Angeles County Clerk, denied Paul Katami and Jeffrey Zarrillo a marriage license.[10] The couples sued the two county clerks and several state officials: Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger , Attorney General Jerry Brown , and two officials in the Department of Public Health .[10] [18]
Several groups sought to intervene as plaintiffs, including the groups who had prosecuted the actions entitled _In re Marriage Cases _ and _Strauss v. Horton _.[19] San Francisco also filed a motion to intervene in the case. The City cited its work in the earlier cases that had provided "extensive evidence and proposed findings on strict scrutiny factors and factual rebuttals to long claimed justifications for marriage discrimination".[20] City Attorney Dennis Herrera said that his office is "singularly well-prepared" to help "put [anti-gay discrimination](https://en.wikipedia.org/wik
…
Editorial context from Wikipedia (CC-BY-SA 4.0).
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that mandamus is appropriate to review a discovery order that raises novel and important questions
- holding that mandamus is appropriate to review a discovery order that raises novel and important questions
- noting that proponents’ evidence was “lacking in particularity but consistent with the self-evidence conclusion” that a discovery request seeking internal campaign communications implicates important First Amendment questions
- finding that proponents had made a prima facie ease for application of the First Amendment privilege against compelled disclosure based on declarations tending to show disclosure would chill their associational rights
- noting that a protective order can ameliorate the harms of disclosure
- granting a petition for mandamus regarding a discovery order compelling disclosure of political campaign information
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Wardlaw, Fisher, Berzon
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
65 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- National Organization for Marriage v. McKeeFirst Circuit· 2011-08-11· cited 116×
- Hernandez v. TanninenNinth Circuit· 2010-05-12· cited 65×
- In Re Motor Fuel Temperature Sales Practices LitigationD. Kansas· 2010-03-26· cited 61×
- Perry v. BrownNinth Circuit· 2012-02-07· cited 56×
- Dc Comics v. Pacific Pictures CorporationNinth Circuit· 2013-01-10· cited 55×
- Anonymous Online Speakers v. United States District CourtNinth Circuit· 2011-01-07· cited 47×
- Mount Hope Church v. Bash Back!Ninth Circuit· 2012-11-26· cited 47×
- Pit River Tribe v. United States Forest ServiceNinth Circuit· 2010-08-02· cited 45×
- Perry v. SchwarzeneggerN.D. California· 2010-03-22· cited 44×
- In Re MOTOR FUEL TEMPERATURE SALES PRACTICES LITIGATIONTenth Circuit· 2011-05-24· cited 37×
- United States v. United States District CourtNinth Circuit· 2017-11-16· cited 37×
- Whole Woman's Health v. Charles SmithFifth Circuit· 2018-07-15· cited 37×
- Eric O'Keefe v. John ChisholmSeventh Circuit· 2014-09-24· cited 32×
- Zermeno-Gomez v. United States District Court for the District of ArizonaNinth Circuit· 2017-08-25· cited 31×
- United States v. James GuerreroNinth Circuit· 2012-08-31· cited 25×
- Metabolic Research, Inc. v. Scott FerrellNinth Circuit· 2012-06-18· cited 22×
- The League of Women Voters of Florida, etc. v. Ken Detzner OpinionSupreme Court of Florida· 2015-07-09· cited 22×
- Islamic Shura Council v. Federal Bureau of InvestigationNinth Circuit· 2011-03-30· cited 21×
- In Re CorrinetNinth Circuit· 2011-07-19· cited 21×
- United States v. Amy UnknownFifth Circuit· 2011-03-22· cited 20×
Cites
45 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Buckley v. ValeoSupreme Court· 1976-02-27· cited 4,982×
- Coopers & Lybrand v. LivesaySupreme Court· 1978-06-21· cited 3,269×
- National Ass'n for the Advancement of Colored People v. Alabama Ex Rel. PattersonSupreme Court· 1958-06-30· cited 2,614×
- Roberts v. United States JayceesSupreme Court· 1984-07-03· cited 2,030×
- Cheney v. United States District Court for District of ColumbiaSupreme Court· 2004-06-24· cited 1,878×
- Williams v. RhodesSupreme Court· 1968-10-15· cited 1,576×
- Romer v. EvansSupreme Court· 1996-06-03· cited 1,427×
- Cobbledick v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1940-02-26· cited 1,204×
- Schlagenhauf v. HolderSupreme Court· 1965-01-18· cited 1,194×
- Flanagan v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1984-02-21· cited 989×
- Digital Equipment Corp. v. Desktop Direct, Inc.Supreme Court· 1994-06-06· cited 964×
- McIntyre v. Ohio Elections CommissionSupreme Court· 1995-04-19· cited 940×
- American Communications Assn. v. DoudsSupreme Court· 1950-05-08· cited 933×
- Mohawk Industries, Inc. v. CarpenterSupreme Court· 2009-12-08· cited 931×
- Bates v. City of Little RockSupreme Court· 1960-02-23· cited 775×
- Eu v. San Francisco County Democratic Central CommitteeSupreme Court· 1989-02-22· cited 706×
- Van Cauwenberghe v. BiardSupreme Court· 1988-06-13· cited 667×
- Kusper v. PontikesSupreme Court· 1973-11-19· cited 640×
- Tashjian v. Republican Party of ConnecticutSupreme Court· 1986-12-10· cited 602×
- Holly W. BAUMAN Et Al., Petitioners, v. UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT, Respondent, Union Oil Company, Real Party in InterestNinth Circuit· 1977-07-01· cited 551×
Other cases named Perry v. Schwarzenegger
14 other CourtListener records share this case name.
- Perry v. SchwarzeneggerN.D. California· 2010-08-04· cited 67×
- Perry v. SchwarzeneggerN.D. California· 2010-03-22· cited 44×
- Perry v. SchwarzeneggerNinth Circuit· 2009-12-11· cited 22×
- Perry v. SchwarzeneggerN.D. California· 2011-06-14· cited 8×
- Perry v. SchwarzeneggerNinth Circuit· 2010-04-12· cited 7×
- Perry v. SchwarzeneggerN.D. California· 2010-08-12· cited 1×
- Perry v. SchwarzeneggerNinth Circuit· 2009-12-16· cited 1×
- Perry v. SchwarzeneggerNinth Circuit· 2009-12-30· cited 1×
- Perry v. SchwarzeneggerN.D. California· 2009-10-01· cited 1×
- Perry v. SchwarzeneggerNinth Circuit· 2009-12-30
- Perry v. SchwarzeneggerNinth Circuit· 2009-12-16
- Perry v. SchwarzeneggerNinth Circuit· 2009-12-11
- Perry v. SchwarzeneggerNinth Circuit· 2009-12-30
- Perry v. SchwarzeneggerN.D. California· 2018-01-17
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.