McLaughlin Brothers v. Hallowell
Citations
- 228 U.S. 278
- 33 S. Ct. 465
- 57 L. Ed. 835
- 1913 U.S. LEXIS 2371
Syllabus
<p>Au order of the United States Circuit Court remanding the cause to the state court is not reviewable here, Missouri Pacific By. v. Fitzgerald, 160 U- S. 556, nor can this object be accomplished by indirection. ' t</p> <p>Where the state court, in denying a second petition for removal, simply bows to the decision of the Federal court when it remanded the record after the first attempt to remove, it does not deny any Federal right of the petitioner within the meaning of § 709, Rev. Stat.</p> <p>Where the second petition to remove presents no different question from that presented by the first, it is proper for the state court to follow the decision of the Federal court remanding the record and deny the petition.</p> <p>In this case it does not appear that any different questions were presented on the second petition than on the first, and if any Federal right of the petitioner to remove was denied, it was denied by the ■Federal and not by the state court.</p> <p>Whether individual members of a copartnership should be joined as defendants or substitutéd for the copartnership in a suit brought against the partnership under a state law permitting copartnerships to be sued as entities is a question of local law only cognizable in this court so far as it may affect the right to remove.</p> <p>This court, having no jurisdiction to review the remanding order of the Circuit Court which the state court followed in denying a second petition to remove, refrains from expressing any opinion upon the correctness of that order.</p>
Judges: Pitney
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
30 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Puerto Rico v. Russell & Co.Supreme Court· 1933-03-13· cited 236×
- Browning v. NavarroFifth Circuit· 1984-10-01· cited 232×
- Pacific Live Stock Co. v. LewisSupreme Court· 1916-06-05· cited 131×
- Eric Rothner D/B/A Chicago Game Co., and D/B/A Bell Vending, Inc. v. City of Chicago, a Municipal CorporationSeventh Circuit· 1989-07-05· cited 100×
- Gay v. RuffSupreme Court· 1934-04-02· cited 99×
- Metropolitan Casualty Insurance v. StevensSupreme Court· 1941-03-17· cited 75×
- Western Life Indemnity Co. of Ill. v. RuppSupreme Court· 1914-11-30· cited 72×
- Bucy v. Nevada Const. Co.Ninth Circuit· 1942-01-26· cited 72×
- W. H. Pat O'Bryan v. Stephen S. ChandlerTenth Circuit· 1974-05-06· cited 46×
- Lewis v. CasenburgTennessee Supreme Court· 1928-07-02· cited 41×
- Yankaus v. FeltensteinSupreme Court· 1917-05-21· cited 33×
- Arrow Food Distributors, Inc. v. LoveMississippi Supreme Court· 1978-07-12· cited 31×
- People of Porto Rico v. Fortuna EstatesFirst Circuit· 1922-03-08· cited 19×
- Ex Parte Matthew Addy Steamship & Commerce Corp.Supreme Court· 1921-05-16· cited 18×
- Travelers' Protective Ass'n of America v. SmithFourth Circuit· 1934-06-11· cited 18×
- City of Waco v. United States Fidelity & Guaranty Co.Fifth Circuit· 1933-12-11· cited 13×
- Eddy v. Chicago & N. W. Ry. Co.W.D. Wisconsin· 1915-07-06· cited 13×
- Missouri Pacific Railroad Co. v. RogersSupreme Court of Arkansas· 1931-11-23· cited 9×
- People of Porto Rico v. HavemeyerFirst Circuit· 1932-06-27· cited 8×
- Wabash Ry. Co. v. WoodroughEighth Circuit· 1928-11-30· cited 6×
Cites
17 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Powers v. Chesapeake & Ohio Railway Co.Supreme Court· 1898-01-10· cited 456×
- Great Southern Fire Proof Hotel Company v. JonesSupreme Court· 1899-01-10· cited 402×
- Goldey v. Morning NewsSupreme Court· 1895-03-04· cited 318×
- Southern Pacific Co. v. DentonSupreme Court· 1892-11-21· cited 257×
- Ex Parte WisnerSupreme Court· 1906-12-10· cited 202×
- Wabash Western Railway v. BrowSupreme Court· 1896-11-30· cited 142×
- Thomas v. Board of Trustees of the Ohio State UniversitySupreme Court· 1904-11-14· cited 140×
- Mexican Central Railway Co. v. PinkneySupreme Court· 1893-05-01· cited 130×
- York v. TexasSupreme Court· 1890-11-03· cited 124×
- Missouri Pacific Railway Co. v. FitzgeraldSupreme Court· 1896-01-13· cited 115×
- Mechanical Appliance Co. v. CastlemanSupreme Court· 1910-01-03· cited 96×
- Davis v. Cleveland, Cincinnati, Chicago & St. Louis Railway Co.Supreme Court· 1910-04-04· cited 77×
- Fritzlen v. Boatmen's BankSupreme Court· 1909-02-23· cited 70×
- Locke v. Chicago Chronicle Co.Supreme Court of Iowa· 1899-01-27· cited 28×
- Kauffman v. WoottersSupreme Court· 1891-02-02· cited 18×
- Brumwell & Co. v. Stebbins Bros.Supreme Court of Iowa· 1891-10-14· cited 14×
- Baxter, Reed & Co. v. C. W. Rollins & Co.Supreme Court of Iowa· 1900-01-23· cited 4×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.