Goldman v. Weinberger
Citations
- 475 U.S. 503
- 106 S. Ct. 1310
- 89 L. Ed. 2d 478
- 1986 U.S. LEXIS 34
- 54 U.S.L.W. 4298
- 39 Empl. Prac. Dec. (CCH) 35,947
- 40 Fair Empl. Prac. Cas. (BNA) 543
About this case
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
1986 United States Supreme Court case
Goldman v. Weinberger, 475 U.S. 503 (1986), was a United States Supreme Court case in which a Jewish Air Force officer was denied the right to wear a yarmulke when in uniform on the grounds that the Free Exercise Clause applies less strictly to the military than to ordinary citizens.
The 5-4 decision by the majority elicited unusually harsh dissents from the other justices and was heavily criticized by legal scholars.[1] Congress responded to the case by enacting legislation to accommodate yarmulkes and similar unobtrusive religious apparel for members of the military.
Background
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Goldman_v._Weinberger&action=edit§ion=1 "Edit section: Background")
]
Goldman joined the United States Air Force as an inactive reservist in 1973. He received a Health Professions scholarship to work towards a PhD in Psychology at the Loyola University of Chicago . Subsequently, Goldman entered service at March Air Force Base in Riverside , California as a commissioned officer and clinical psychologist at the on-base mental health clinic. As an Orthodox Jew and rabbi , Goldman's faith required him to wear a yarmulke to show that he is aware that God is a higher power and above him.
For years, Goldman wore his yarmulke without controversy by staying near his station at the clinic and wearing his service cap above the yarmulke while outdoors. In 1981, however, he was required to testify as a defense witness at a court-martial . His testimony discredited the prosecution witness. Subsequently, a government attorney lodged a complaint about Goldman's wearing of the yarmulke. Subsequently, his commanding officer at the hospital, Colonel Joseph Gregory, informed him that he was violating Air Force Regulation 35-10, which states that "headgear will not be worn... while indoors except by armed security police in the performance of their duties." The officer then ordered him to not wear the yarmulke while in uniform outside the hospital.
Goldman refused this order, and instead his attorney filed a complaint to the Air Force General Counsel. Gregory then ordered that Goldman cease wearing his yarmulke even when within the hospital. Goldman requested to be allowed to report for duty in civilian clothes until the issue was settled in court, but he was denied this and was threatened with court-martial. It was at this point that Goldman sued the Secretary of Defense , Caspar Weinberger , who was himself of Jewish descent, for Free Exercise Clause violations. He was favored at the District Court of Washington, D.C. , but that decision was reversed in the Court of Appeals . The Supreme Court granted the writ of certiorari .
Supreme Court decision
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Goldman_v._Weinberger&action=edit§ion=2 "Edit section: Supreme Court decision")
]
Because Goldman alleged that this was a Free Exercise violation, he indicated that the defense had to pass the Sherbert test : by demonstrating a "compelling interest" for the violation. He then submitted evidence that there was not a compelling interest for preventing the display of religious apparel, because it presented no danger to military discipline. However, the Court decided against him on a 5–4 decision. The majority opinion, written by Rehnquist, held that this was of no consequence—it contended that the Sherbert test did not apply because the Free Exercise Clause and even the First Amendment in general did not apply to the military in the same way that it did to civilian society. The justification for this was a need to "foster instinctive obedience, unity, commitment, and esprit de corps ." The dissenters argued that the decision gave too much deference to the military's judgment and that some judicial scrutiny of military necessity claims should be required.[2] According to Samuel J. Levine, the dissenting opinions were "unusually harsh," and legal scholars have also heavily criticized the decision.[1]
Congressional response
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Goldman_v._Weinberger&action=edit§ion=3 "Edit section: Congressional response")
]
In the Court's ruling it was only decided that the Constitution failed to protect the freedom to wear religious apparel in uniform—it did not outright bar it. This distinction gave Congress the power to enact legislation that would reverse the policy. Allowing "neat and conservative" religious apparel accommodations had been in consideration since 1985, following the case's ruling in the Court of Appeals.[3] Proposals to do so failed during the case's trial period, but finally succeeded in 1988 through a provision to the annual National Defense Authorization Act . It provides for a general rule that "a member of the armed forces may wear an item of religious apparel while wearing the uniform of the member's armed force." The bill containing the provision was passed by both houses of Congress and signed into law by President Ronald Reagan .
See also
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Goldman_v._Weinberger&action=edit§ion=4 "Edit section: See also")
]
References
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Goldman_v._Weinberger&action=edit§ion=5 "Edit section: References")
]
- Jump up to: 1 2 Levine, Samuel J. (2018). "Untold Stories of Goldman v. Weinberger: Religious Freedom Confronts Military Uniformity". Jewish Law and American Law, Volume 2: A Comparative Study . Academic Studies Press. pp. 121–141. ISBN 978-1-61811-657-4 .
- ↑ Goldman v. Weinberger, 475 U.S. 503 (1986).
- ↑ Sullivan, Dwight H. (1988), "The Congressional Response to Goldman v. Weinberg ". Military Law Review, Volume 121, pp. 125–152.
External links
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Goldman_v._Weinberger&action=edit§ion=6 "Edit section: External links")
]
- Text of Goldman v. Weinberger, 475 U.S. 503 (1986) is available from: Cornell Findlaw Internet Archive (docket files) Justia
hide
U.S. Supreme Court Free Exercise Clause case law
**First Amendment to the United States Constitution **
Exclusion of religion
from public benefits
- _[Locke v. Davey](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Locke_v._Davey
…
Editorial context from Wikipedia (CC-BY-SA 4.0).
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that the First Amendment did not prevent the Air Force from passing regulations which prohibited the wearing of headgear required by a person's religion
- explaining that to succeed “the military must foster instinctive obedience, unity, commitment, and esprit de corps”
- upholding military regulation which draws a line between visible and nonvisible religious apparel, allowing only the latter to be worn by service personnel
- upholding military regulation which draws a line between visible and nonvisible religious apparel, allowing only the latter to be worn by service personnel
- upholding against First Amendment challenge military uniform regulation barring wearing of yarmulke
- upholding military requirement of a uniform dress code as essential aspect of military discipline
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Blackmun, Brennan, Burger, O'Connor, Powell, Rehnquist, Stevens, White
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
299 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Winter v. Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc.Supreme Court· 2008-11-12· cited 11,986×
- Employment Div., Dept. of Human Resources of Ore. v. SmithSupreme Court· 1990-04-17· cited 2,569×
- Church of the Lukumi Babalu Aye, Inc. v. City of HialeahSupreme Court· 1993-06-11· cited 1,769×
- Cutter v. WilkinsonSupreme Court· 2005-05-31· cited 1,462×
- County of Allegheny v. American Civil Liberties UnionSupreme Court· 1989-07-03· cited 1,111×
- United States v. WashingtonCourt of Appeals for the Armed Forces· 2002-09-30· cited 860×
- United States v. StanleySupreme Court· 1987-06-25· cited 644×
- Leal v. Holy Spirit Ass'n for Unification of World ChristianityCalifornia Supreme Court· 1988-10-17· cited 422×
- John D. Holley v. United StatesFederal Circuit· 1997-11-20· cited 403×
- Bowen v. RoySupreme Court· 1986-06-11· cited 399×
- Daniels v. City of ArlingtonFifth Circuit· 2001-04-09· cited 388×
- United States v. JohnsonSupreme Court· 1987-05-18· cited 351×
- Texas Monthly, Inc. v. BullockSupreme Court· 1989-02-21· cited 334×
- Navajo Nation v. United States Forest ServiceNinth Circuit· 2008-08-08· cited 279×
- Solorio v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1987-09-21· cited 274×
- Sergeant Perry Watkins v. United States ArmyNinth Circuit· 1989-05-03· cited 256×
- Rigoberto Yepes-Prado v. U.S. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceNinth Circuit· 1993-11-12· cited 189×
- Webb v. City of PhiladelphiaThird Circuit· 2009-04-07· cited 173×
- United States v. HardmanTenth Circuit· 2002-08-05· cited 170×
- United States v. MarcavageThird Circuit· 2010-06-16· cited 138×
Cites
19 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Wisconsin v. YoderSupreme Court· 1972-05-15· cited 3,250×
- Sherbert v. VernerSupreme Court· 1963-06-17· cited 2,650×
- West Virginia State Board of Education v. BarnetteSupreme Court· 1943-06-14· cited 2,477×
- Parker v. LevySupreme Court· 1974-06-19· cited 1,846×
- Thomas v. Review Board of the Indiana Employment Security DivisionSupreme Court· 1981-04-06· cited 1,701×
- Metromedia, Inc. v. City of San DiegoSupreme Court· 1981-07-02· cited 1,213×
- Chappell v. WallaceSupreme Court· 1983-06-13· cited 1,183×
- Orloff v. WilloughbySupreme Court· 1953-04-06· cited 957×
- Wallace v. JaffreeSupreme Court· 1985-06-04· cited 898×
- United States v. LeeSupreme Court· 1982-02-23· cited 834×
- Korematsu v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1945-02-26· cited 827×
- Committee for Public Education & Religious Liberty v. NyquistSupreme Court· 1973-06-25· cited 806×
- Greer v. SpockSupreme Court· 1976-03-24· cited 746×
- Schlesinger v. CouncilmanSupreme Court· 1975-03-25· cited 724×
- Gillette v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1971-03-08· cited 603×
- Rostker v. GoldbergSupreme Court· 1981-06-25· cited 560×
- Brown v. GlinesSupreme Court· 1980-01-21· cited 275×
- S. Simcha Goldman v. Secretary of DefenseD.C. Circuit· 1984-08-10· cited 16×
- Goldman v. Secretary of DefenseDistrict of Columbia· 1981-07-10· cited 7×
Other cases named Goldman v. Weinberger
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.