United States v. Stanley
Citations
- 483 U.S. 669
- 107 S. Ct. 3054
- 97 L. Ed. 2d 550
- 1987 U.S. LEXIS 2890
- 55 U.S.L.W. 5101
About this case
United States v. Stanley
Learn more
This article **needs more citations
**. Please help improve this article
by adding citations to reliable sources
. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed
.
Find sources: "United States v. Stanley"
– news
· newspapers
· books
· scholar
· JSTOR (June 2013) (Learn how and when to remove this message
)
United States v. Stanley, 483 U.S. 669 (1987), was a United States Supreme Court case in which the Court held that a serviceman could not file a tort action against the federal government even though the government secretly administered doses of LSD to him as part of an experimental program, because his injuries were found by the lower court to be service-related.
Contents
Background
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=United_States_v._Stanley&action=edit§ion=1 "Edit section: Background")
In February 1958, James B. Stanley, a master sergeant in the Army stationed at Fort Knox , Kentucky , volunteered for a chemical warfare testing program . Stanley was administered lysergic acid diethylamide (LSD ) in a US Army plan to test the effects of the drug on human subjects. Stanley claimed he was unknowingly given the drug.[1]
Stanley claimed that as a result of the LSD exposure, he suffered from hallucinations, periods of incoherence, and memory loss due to his unawareness of having taken the drug. He suffered severe personality changes that led to his discharge and the dissolution of his marriage.
Stanley filed a lawsuit under the Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA) alleging negligence in the administration, supervision, and subsequent monitoring of the experimental program.
The United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit held that the serviceman could assert his claims under the FTCA and refused to dismiss the serviceman's _Bivens _ claims.
Opinion of the Court
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=United_States_v._Stanley&action=edit§ion=2 "Edit section: Opinion of the Court")
After granting certiorari , the Supreme Court held that the circuit court had no jurisdiction to give orders to dismiss FTCA claims. The Supreme Court also held there was no Bivens claim for the serviceman's injuries because the lower court ruled the injuries occurred during Stanley's military service.[2]
The majority argued that "a test for liability that depends on the extent to which particular suits would call into question military discipline and decision making would itself require judicial inquiry into, and hence intrusion upon, military matters." In dissent, Justice William Brennan argued that the need to preserve military discipline should not protect the government from liability and punishment for serious violations of constitutional rights :
The medical trials at Nuremberg in 1947 deeply impressed upon the world that experimentation with unknowing human subjects is morally and legally unacceptable. The United States Military Tribunal established the Nuremberg Code as a standard against which to judge German scientists who experimented with human subjects... [I]n defiance of this principle, military intelligence officials [...] began surreptitiously testing chemical and biological materials, including LSD.
Justice Sandra Day O'Connor , writing a separate dissent, stated:
No judicially crafted rule should insulate from liability the involuntary and unknowing human experimentation alleged to have occurred in this case. Indeed, as Justice Brennan observes, the United States played an instrumental role in the criminal prosecution of Nazi officials who experimented with human subjects during the Second World War, and the standards that the Nuremberg Military Tribunals developed to judge the behavior of the defendants stated that the 'voluntary consent of the human subject is absolutely essential [...] to satisfy moral, ethical, and legal concepts.' If this principle is violated, the very least that society can do is to see that the victims are compensated, as best they can be, by the perpetrators.
Aftermath
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=United_States_v._Stanley&action=edit§ion=3 "Edit section: Aftermath")
In 1994 Congress passed a private claims bill to redress the case. In 1996 an arbitration panel awarded Stanley $400,577 (the maximum amount allowed under the bill) after a 2-1 vote.[3]
References
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=United_States_v._Stanley&action=edit§ion=4 "Edit section: References")
- ↑ Norbert Ehrenfreund (2007). The Nuremberg Legacy: How the Nazi War Crimes Trials Changed the Course of History. Palgrave Macmillan. p. 151. ISBN 978-0-230-61078-1 .
- ↑ United States v. Stanley, 483 U.S. 669 (1987)
- ↑ Bob Erlandson, Ex-sergeant compensated for LSD experiments Tests by Army, CIA done at Edgewood , March 07, 1996, _Baltimore Sun _
External links
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=United_States_v._Stanley&action=edit§ion=5 "Edit section: External links")
Text of United States v. Stanley, 483 U.S. 669 (1987) is available from: Internet Archive (docket files) Justia Library of Congress Oyez (oral argument audio)
Tom Bowman, Former sergeant seeks compensation for LSD testing at Edgewood Arsenal , July 11, 1991, _Baltimore Sun _
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=United_States_v._Stanley&oldid=1351345023 "
Editorial context from Wikipedia (CC-BY-SA 4.0).
Judges: Scalia, Rehnquist, White, Blackmun, Powell, Brennan, Marshall, Stevens, O'Connor
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
351 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Ziglar v. AbbasiSupreme Court· 2017-06-19· cited 2,879×
- Correctional Services Corp. v. MaleskoSupreme Court· 2001-11-27· cited 1,854×
- Washington v. HarperSupreme Court· 1990-04-16· cited 1,489×
- Swint v. Chambers County CommissionSupreme Court· 1995-03-01· cited 1,403×
- Schweiker v. ChilickySupreme Court· 1988-06-24· cited 1,110×
- Egbert v. BouleSupreme Court· 2022-06-08· cited 977×
- Webster v. DoeSupreme Court· 1988-06-15· cited 942×
- Hernandez v. MesaSupreme Court· 2020-02-25· cited 817×
- Michael H. v. Gerald D.Supreme Court· 1989-08-30· cited 719×
- Wilkie v. RobbinsSupreme Court· 2007-06-25· cited 682×
- Yamaha Motor Corp., USA v. CalhounSupreme Court· 1996-01-09· cited 570×
- Armstrong v. Exceptional Child Center, Inc.Supreme Court· 2015-03-31· cited 544×
- Minneci v. PollardSupreme Court· 2012-01-10· cited 443×
- Burge v. Parish of St. TammanyFifth Circuit· 1999-08-25· cited 428×
- Arar v. AshcroftSecond Circuit· 2009-11-02· cited 338×
- Roger Vanderklok v. United StatesThird Circuit· 2017-08-22· cited 334×
- Hui v. CastanedaSupreme Court· 2010-05-03· cited 314×
- Louis Cale v. J.R. Johnson, Warden, F.C.I., James Wahl, Food Service Administrator, F.C.I., Milan, and Melvin Persky, Inmate and Clerk to James WahlSixth Circuit· 1988-11-17· cited 312×
- Charles Mack v. John YostThird Circuit· 2020-08-04· cited 311×
- Sergeant Perry Watkins v. United States ArmyNinth Circuit· 1989-05-03· cited 256×
Cites
45 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Harlow v. FitzgeraldSupreme Court· 1982-06-24· cited 22,846×
- Scheuer v. RhodesSupreme Court· 1974-04-17· cited 13,385×
- Mitchell v. ForsythSupreme Court· 1985-06-19· cited 8,858×
- Imbler v. PachtmanSupreme Court· 1976-03-02· cited 7,274×
- Allen v. McCurrySupreme Court· 1980-12-09· cited 4,909×
- Pierson v. RaySupreme Court· 1967-04-11· cited 4,282×
- Butz v. EconomouSupreme Court· 1978-06-29· cited 3,397×
- Davis v. PassmanSupreme Court· 1979-06-05· cited 3,039×
- Carlson v. GreenSupreme Court· 1980-04-22· cited 2,910×
- Parker v. LevySupreme Court· 1974-06-19· cited 1,846×
- Feres v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1950-12-04· cited 1,830×
- Frontiero v. RichardsonSupreme Court· 1973-05-14· cited 1,487×
- Bush v. LucasSupreme Court· 1983-06-13· cited 1,430×
- Barr v. MatteoSupreme Court· 1959-06-29· cited 1,312×
- O'Connor v. DonaldsonSupreme Court· 1975-06-26· cited 1,231×
- Chappell v. WallaceSupreme Court· 1983-06-13· cited 1,183×
- Nixon v. FitzgeraldSupreme Court· 1982-06-24· cited 972×
- Procunier v. NavaretteSupreme Court· 1978-02-22· cited 925×
- Burns v. WilsonSupreme Court· 1953-06-15· cited 669×
- United States v. BrownSupreme Court· 1954-12-06· cited 440×
Other cases named United States v. Stanley
57 other CourtListener records share this case name; the 50 most cited are listed.
- United States v. StanleyNinth Circuit· 1976-11-05· cited 71×
- United States v. StanleyCourt of Appeals for the Armed Forces· 2012-03-22· cited 42×
- United States v. StanleySupreme Court· 1883-10-15· cited 42×
- United States v. StanleyN.D. California· 1978-04-20· cited 11×
- United States v. StanleyUnited States Court of Military Appeals· 1968-02-09· cited 11×
- United States v. StanleyAir Force Court of Criminal Appeals· 2004-07-01· cited 10×
- United States v. StanleyNinth Circuit· 2011-08-02· cited 7×
- United States v. StanleyU.S. Circuit Court for the District of Indiana· 1855-05-15· cited 6×
- United States v. StanleyUnited States Court of Military Appeals· 1986-01-27· cited 6×
- United States v. StanleyN.D. Georgia· 1973-06-13· cited 4×
- United States v. StanleyArmy Court of Criminal Appeals· 1995-09-25· cited 3×
- United States v. StanleyCourt of Appeals for the Armed Forces· 2011-03-31· cited 3×
- United States v. StanleyCourt of Appeals for the Armed Forces· 2011-07-21· cited 2×
- United States v. StanleyS.D. New York· 2012-08-07· cited 2×
- United States v. StanleyNinth Circuit· 2004-05-18· cited 1×
- United States v. StanleyU S Air Force Court of Military Review· 1983-03-30· cited 1×
- United States v. StanleyFourth Circuit· 1973-11-28
- United States v. StanleyFourth Circuit· 1973-12-13
- United States v. StanleyFourth Circuit· 1974-01-28
- United States v. StanleyFifth Circuit· 1974-06-25
- United States v. StanleyD.C. Circuit· 1974-07-16
- United States v. StanleyFifth Circuit· 1975-10-01
- United States v. StanleyNinth Circuit· 1976-11-24
- United States v. StanleySixth Circuit· 1980-10-21
- United States v. StanleySixth Circuit· 1981-11-10
- United States v. StanleyNinth Circuit· 1983-07-27
- United States v. StanleyFifth Circuit· 1984-06-08
- United States v. StanleyEleventh Circuit· 1989-01-11
- United States v. StanleyEleventh Circuit· 1989-11-16
- United States v. StanleyFifth Circuit· 1992-04-03
- United States v. StanleyEleventh Circuit· 1993-10-19
- United States v. StanleyEleventh Circuit· 1995-08-17
- United States v. StanleyEleventh Circuit· 1995-08-31
- United States v. StanleyNavy-Marine Corps Court of Criminal Appeals· 2014-09-30
- United States v. StanleyNavy-Marine Corps Court of Criminal Appeals· 2020-10-27
- United States v. StanleyCourt of Appeals for the Armed Forces· 2011-03-17
- United States v. StanleyCourt of Appeals for the Armed Forces· 2011-05-19
- United States v. StanleyCourt of Appeals for the Armed Forces· 2011-06-17
- United States v. StanleyCourt of Appeals for the Armed Forces· 2011-08-17
- United States v. StanleyCourt of Appeals for the Armed Forces· 2017-01-23
- United States v. StanleySupreme Court· 1883-10-15
- United States v. StanleySupreme Court· 1883-07-01
- United States v. StanleySupreme Court· 1883-07-01
- United States v. StanleyNinth Circuit· 2012-08-16
- United States v. StanleySixth Circuit· 2004-03-03
- United States v. StanleyFourth Circuit· 2011-04-26
- United States v. StanleyFourth Circuit· 2012-07-23
- United States v. StanleyUnited States Court of Military Appeals· 1969-03-21
- United States v. StanleyFourth Circuit· 2003-02-13
- United States v. StanleyFourth Circuit· 2003-06-18
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.