Butler v. Elle

How courts have described this case

Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.

• “Materiality is for the 9 court, state of mind is for the jury.”

Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).

Cited by

59 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.

• Ewing v. City of Stockton
  Ninth Circuit· 2009-12-09· cited 451×
• Esau Awabdy v. City of Adelanto Scott Burnell Ted Hartz Richard Althouse, Michael Sakamoto, Does I-X, Inclusive
  Ninth Circuit· 2004-05-20· cited 353×
• Galbraith v. County of Santa Clara
  Ninth Circuit· 2002-10-09· cited 352×
• Bravo v. City of Santa Maria
  Ninth Circuit· 2011-12-09· cited 162×
• VALADEZ-LOPEZ v. Chertoff
  Ninth Circuit· 2011-08-26· cited 111×
• KRL v. Moore
  Ninth Circuit· 2004-09-27· cited 98×
• Neveu v. City of Fresno
  E.D. California· 2005-07-15· cited 83×
• Greene v. Camreta
  Ninth Circuit· 2009-12-10· cited 81×
• Green v. Baca
  C.D. California· 2005-01-24· cited 67×
• Sanchez v. City of Fresno
  E.D. California· 2012-12-26· cited 56×
• Pervaiz Chaudhry v. Tomas Aragon
  Ninth Circuit· 2023-05-23· cited 43×
• Chism v. Washington State
  Ninth Circuit· 2011-08-25· cited 36×
• Hannah David v. Gina Kaulukukui
  Ninth Circuit· 2022-06-27· cited 35×
• Johnson v. Shasta County
  E.D. California· 2015-01-06· cited 29×
• Donahoe v. Arpaio
  D. Arizona· 2012-04-09· cited 29×
• Mateos-Sandoval v. County of Sonoma
  N.D. California· 2013-01-31· cited 24×
• Rachel Scanlon v. County of Los Angeles
  Ninth Circuit· 2024-02-02· cited 23×
• Garcia v. City of Merced
  E.D. California· 2008-01-10· cited 21×
• Marshall v. County of San Diego
  California Court of Appeal· 2015-07-22· cited 19×
• Herrera v. Las Vegas Metropolitan Police Department
  D. Nevada· 2004-01-20· cited 16×

Cites

30 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.

• Monell v. New York City Dept. of Social Servs.
  Supreme Court· 1978-06-06· cited 41,449×
• Harlow v. Fitzgerald
  Supreme Court· 1982-06-24· cited 22,846×
• Anderson v. Creighton
  Supreme Court· 1987-06-25· cited 12,768×
• Kentucky v. Graham
  Supreme Court· 1985-06-28· cited 11,385×
• City of Canton v. Harris
  Supreme Court· 1989-02-28· cited 10,043×
• Mitchell v. Forsyth
  Supreme Court· 1985-06-19· cited 8,858×
• Imbler v. Pachtman
  Supreme Court· 1976-03-02· cited 7,274×
• Pembaur v. City of Cincinnati
  Supreme Court· 1986-03-25· cited 6,061×
• Hunter v. Bryant
  Supreme Court· 1991-12-16· cited 3,271×
• Johnson v. Jones
  Supreme Court· 1995-06-12· cited 2,857×
• Gomez v. Toledo
  Supreme Court· 1980-05-27· cited 2,697×
• Crawford-El v. Britton
  Supreme Court· 1998-05-04· cited 2,583×
• Burns v. Reed
  Supreme Court· 1991-05-30· cited 1,988×
• United Brotherhood of Carpenters & Joiners of America, Local 610 v. Scott
  Supreme Court· 1983-07-05· cited 1,347×
• Bray v. Alexandria Women's Health Clinic
  Supreme Court· 1993-01-13· cited 871×
• Gibson v. United States
  Ninth Circuit· 1986-01-30· cited 352×
• United States v. Stanley Mills Stanert
  Ninth Circuit· 1985-08-28· cited 258×
• Jeffers v. Gomez
  Ninth Circuit· 2001-10-03· cited 240×
• Hervey v. Estes
  Ninth Circuit· 1995-09-12· cited 239×
• James H. McLellan v. Mississippi Power & Light Company, International Brotherhood of Electricalworkers, Local 605 Electrical Workers
  Fifth Circuit· 1977-01-20· cited 226×

Other cases named Butler v. Elle

1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.

• Butler v. Elle
  Ninth Circuit· 2002-02-26