Third Circuit· 8/5/1993
Abnathya v. Hoffmann-La Roche, Inc.
Citations
- 2 F.3d 40
- 1993 WL 290387
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that “alien who has failed 3 to comply substantially with the Lozada requirements . . . 4 forfeits h[is] ineffective assistance of counsel claim in 5 this Court”
- if plan contains language giving administrator discretion to make eligibility determinations, arbitrary and capricious standard applies
- discretion found where plan gave benefit committee “power to interpret and construe the Plan ... and to determine all questions relating to eligibility ... for disability income benefits.”
- a reviewing court “may overturn a decision of the [p]lan administrator only if it is without reason, unsupported by substantial evidence or erroneous as a matter of law”
- held to be reasonable for plan administrator to base his decision to terminate long-term disability benefits on independent evaluations by two doctors chosen by the plan, rather than the testimony of Abnathya’s physician
- court should defer to administrator unless administrator failed to comply with plan procedure
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Becker, Hutchinson, Weis
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
110 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Fleisher v. Standard InsuranceThird Circuit· 2012-05-17· cited 357×
- Goldie Miller, as of the Estate of Sarah M. Potok v. United Welfare FundSecond Circuit· 1995-12-19· cited 332×
- Maria H. Pinto v. Reliance Standard Life Insurance CompanyThird Circuit· 2000-07-19· cited 244×
- Jane Donaho v. Fmc Corporation, a Delaware Corporation, as Plan Administrator of the Fmc Long-Term Disability PlanEighth Circuit· 1996-01-31· cited 220×
- George W. Mitchell v. Eastman Kodak CompanyThird Circuit· 1997-05-08· cited 208×
- Meditrust Financial Services Corp. v. Sterling Chemicals, Inc.Fifth Circuit· 1999-03-04· cited 195×
- Gallo v. Amoco Corp.Seventh Circuit· 1996-12-17· cited 163×
- Viera v. Life Insurance Co. of North AmericaThird Circuit· 2011-06-10· cited 132×
- Post v. Hartford InsuranceThird Circuit· 2007-09-13· cited 111×
- Estate of Schwing v. the Lilly Health PlanThird Circuit· 2009-04-14· cited 96×
- Stephen P. Lasser v. Reliance Standard Life Insurance CompanyThird Circuit· 2003-09-18· cited 78×
- Doroshow v. Hartford Life & Accident InsuranceThird Circuit· 2009-07-30· cited 75×
- John Cottillion v. United Refining CoThird Circuit· 2015-03-18· cited 75×
- Abnathya v. Hoffmann-La RocheThird Circuit· 1993-08-05· cited 62×
- Roganti v. Metropolitan Life InsuranceSecond Circuit· 2015-05-14· cited 52×
- Funk v. Cigna Group InsuranceThird Circuit· 2011-08-04· cited 49×
- Irene Sahulka v. Lucent Technologies, Inc.Eighth Circuit· 2000-03-13· cited 47×
- Shirley Mcleod v. Hartford Life And Accident Insurance CompanyThird Circuit· 2004-06-22· cited 46×
- Joyce Vitale v. Latrobe Area HospitalThird Circuit· 2005-08-29· cited 42×
- In re Estate of SauersSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2011-11-23· cited 35×
Cites
9 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Firestone Tire & Rubber Co. v. BruchSupreme Court· 1989-02-21· cited 6,595×
- Connie M. Miller v. Metropolitan Life Insurance CompanySixth Circuit· 1991-02-15· cited 349×
- Jim L. Woolsey v. Marion Laboratories, Inc. Marion Laboratories, Inc., Profit Sharing PlanTenth Circuit· 1991-06-04· cited 191×
- Nazay v. MillerThird Circuit· 1991-12-06· cited 96×
- Adamo v. Anchor Hocking Corp.W.D. Pennsylvania· 1989-07-27· cited 45×
- Lucash v. Strick Corp.E.D. Pennsylvania· 1984-06-01· cited 32×
- Stoetzner v. United States Steel Corp.Third Circuit· 1990-02-26· cited 32×
- Daniels v. Anchor Hocking Corp.W.D. Pennsylvania· 1991-02-27· cited 17×
- Roberson v. General Motors Corp.Sixth Circuit· 1986-06-17· cited 5×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.