Witjaksono v. Holder

How courts have described this case

Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.

• holding assaults didn’t amount to persecution when they didn’t “requir[e] medical attention”
• applying de novo review over a ruling on due process because a legal issue was involved
• noting materiality and outcome-alteration as “foundational principles” guiding prejudice analysis in this context
• “Witjaksono’s descriptions of the 1998 Jakarta riots and the 1999 church bombing do not mandate relief.”
• “Without a showing of past persecution, an alien must demonstrate that it is more likely than not that he will be individually persecuted in the future.”
• “It is well settled that an alien in an immigration proceeding is entitled to a reasonably complete and accurate record to facilitate appellate review. . . . ”

Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).

Cited by

16 cases in this archive cite this case.

• Ritonga v. Holder
  Tenth Circuit· 2011-01-28· cited 110×
• Dallakoti v. Holder
  Tenth Circuit· 2010-10-05· cited 78×
• Karki v. Holder
  Tenth Circuit· 2013-04-30· cited 77×
• Galeano-Romero v. Barr
  Tenth Circuit· 2020-08-04· cited 47×
• Neri-Garcia v. Holder
  Tenth Circuit· 2012-10-03· cited 39×
• Ting Xue v. Lynch
  Tenth Circuit· 2016-11-25· cited 38×
• Zia v. Garland
  Ninth Circuit· 2024-08-26· cited 17×
• Gonzalez Aguilar v. Garland
  Tenth Circuit· 2022-03-29· cited 9×
• Takwi v. Garland
  Tenth Circuit· 2022-01-10· cited 8×
• Gallego-Arroyave v. Holder
  Tenth Circuit· 2012-12-12· cited 2×
• Halmenschlager v. Holder
  Tenth Circuit· 2009-07-31
• Semenov v. Attorney General of the United States
  Third Circuit· 2009-09-28
• Nalwamba v. Holder
  Tenth Circuit· 2010-04-08
• Zhe Sun v. Holder
  Tenth Circuit· 2015-04-20
• Chavez-Govea v. Bondi
  Tenth Circuit· 2025-08-05
• O.C.V. v. Bondi
  Tenth Circuit· 2025-08-26

Cites

30 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.

• Kamla Prasad Meena Kumari Prasad Catherine Sandhya Prasad Micky Sudesh Prasad Ricky Sumit Prasad v. Immigration & Naturalization Service
  Ninth Circuit· 1995-02-01· cited 928×
• Maryam Hartooni v. Immigration & Naturalization Service
  Ninth Circuit· 1994-04-07· cited 321×
• Vera KORABLINA, Petitioner, v. IMMIGRATION AND NATURALIZATION SERVICE, Respondent
  Ninth Circuit· 1998-10-23· cited 285×
• Sidabutar v. Gonzales
  Tenth Circuit· 2007-09-21· cited 240×
• Elzour v. Ashcroft
  Tenth Circuit· 2004-08-17· cited 205×
• Infanzon v. Ashcroft
  Tenth Circuit· 2004-10-28· cited 178×
• Niang v. Ashcroft
  Tenth Circuit· 2005-09-08· cited 162×
• Sarr v. Gonzales
  Tenth Circuit· 2007-01-22· cited 134×
• Fidelis Osuchukwu v. Immigration & Naturalization Service
  Fifth Circuit· 1984-10-26· cited 130×
• Tulengkey v. Ashcroft
  Tenth Circuit· 2005-10-13· cited 126×
• Vatulev v. Ashcroft
  Tenth Circuit· 2003-12-31· cited 125×
• Ramon Becerra-Jimenez v. Immigration & Naturalization Service
  Tenth Circuit· 1987-09-22· cited 110×
• Cruz-Funez v. Ashcroft
  Tenth Circuit· 2005-05-02· cited 99×
• Porfirio Garza-Moreno Mario Garza-Garcia v. Alberto Gonzales, Attorney General
  Sixth Circuit· 2007-06-05· cited 96×
• Marincas v. Lewis
  Third Circuit· 1996-08-09· cited 92×
• Vicente-Elias v. Mukasey
  Tenth Circuit· 2008-07-11· cited 77×
• Iraj Nazaraghaie v. Immigration & Naturalization Service, Joseph R. Greene and John Doe
  Tenth Circuit· 1996-12-13· cited 75×
• Khosrow Hadjimehdigholi v. Immigration & Naturalization Service
  Tenth Circuit· 1995-03-01· cited 73×
• Lyndon Erickson McLeod v. Immigration and Naturalization Service
  Third Circuit· 1986-10-01· cited 66×
• Ismaiel v. Mukasey
  Tenth Circuit· 2008-02-22· cited 63×