Eleventh Circuit· 6/22/2020
Wade Steven Gardner v. William Mutz
Citations
- 962 F.3d 1329
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- instructing that “the district court should dismiss without prejudice for lack of jurisdiction”
- observing the “fundamentally temporal!” nature of mootness and noting a case can become moot “due to the march of time or intervening events”
- finding Plaintiff’s alleged injuries are too abstract for Article III standing, as “surely the naked recitation of a constitutional claim isn’t sufficient; if it were, every § 1983 plaintiff would, by definition, have standing to sue.”
- “[T]he Supreme Court has ex- pressly condemned the exercise of a so-called ‘“hypothetical juris- diction” that enables a court to resolve contested questions of law when its jurisdiction is in doubt.’”
- “[A] plaintiff whose suit goes moot once had a ‘Case’ but lost it due to the march of time or intervening events, whereas the plaintiff who lacks standing never had a ‘Case’ to begin with.”
- “[T]he plaintiffs’ inchoate agreement with what they take to be the cenotaph’s meaning or message—and their consequent disagreement with the monument’s relocation [or removal]—does not alone give rise to a concrete injury for Article III purposes.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Cited by
14 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Mr. Eddie I. Sierra v. City of Hallandale Beach FloridaEleventh Circuit· 2021-05-06· cited 66×
- Catherine Regina Harper v. Professional Probation Services Inc.Eleventh Circuit· 2020-09-25· cited 13×
- Art Rojas v. City of Ocala, FloridaEleventh Circuit· 2022-07-22· cited 6×
- Cobb County School DistrictEleventh Circuit· 2024-08-13· cited 5×
- Schoenhorn v. MossSupreme Court of Connecticut· 2023-08-08· cited 3×
- Jarvis Arrington v. Burger King Worldwide, Inc.Eleventh Circuit· 2022-08-31· cited 1×
- T. Davis Humphries v. Newton County Board of CommissionersCourt of Appeals of Georgia· 2021-07-23
- Ladies Memorial Association, Inc. v. City of Pensacola, FloridaEleventh Circuit· 2022-05-16
- Animal Legal Defense Fund v. VilsackDistrict of Columbia· 2022-11-14
- United Daughters of the Confederacy, N.C. Div. v. City of Winston-SalemSupreme Court of North Carolina· 2022-12-16
- Taquila Monroe v. Board of Regents of the University System of GeorgiaEleventh Circuit· 2024-02-15
- Kerl v. United StatesFederal Claims· 2025-09-11
- Csi Aviation, Inc. v. United StatesFederal Claims· 2026-05-12
- Earl M. Johnson, Jr. v. Mayor, City of JacksonvilleEleventh Circuit· 2026-06-10
Cites
34 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Lujan v. Defenders of WildlifeSupreme Court· 1992-06-12· cited 24,791×
- Kokkonen v. Guardian Life Insurance Co. of AmericaSupreme Court· 1994-05-16· cited 12,961×
- Steel Co. v. Citizens for a Better EnvironmentSupreme Court· 1998-03-04· cited 10,096×
- Spokeo, Inc. v. RobinsSupreme Court· 2016-05-16· cited 7,043×
- Valley Forge Christian College v. Americans United for Separation of Church and State, Inc.Supreme Court· 1982-01-12· cited 4,651×
- Ruhrgas Ag v. Marathon Oil Co.Supreme Court· 1999-05-17· cited 3,295×
- Sierra Club v. MortonSupreme Court· 1972-04-19· cited 3,248×
- Clapper v. Amnesty International USASupreme Court· 2013-02-26· cited 3,172×
- Sinochem International Co. v. Malaysia International Shipping Corp.Supreme Court· 2007-03-05· cited 1,961×
- Access Now, Inc. v. Southwest Airlines Co.Eleventh Circuit· 2004-09-24· cited 1,498×
- Diamond v. CharlesSupreme Court· 1986-04-30· cited 1,118×
- Hollingsworth v. PerrySupreme Court· 2013-06-26· cited 967×
- Chafin v. ChafinSupreme Court· 2013-02-19· cited 949×
- Pleasant Grove City v. SummumSupreme Court· 2009-02-25· cited 739×
- David L. Morrison v. Amway Corporation, N.K.A. Alticor, Inc., a Michigan Corporation, Magic Carpet Aviation, a Delaware CorporationEleventh Circuit· 2003-03-05· cited 533×
- Stalley Ex Rel. United States v. Orlando Regional Healthcare System, Inc.Eleventh Circuit· 2008-04-18· cited 465×
- Luis E. Garcia, M.D. v. Copenhaver, Bell & Associates, m.d.'s, P.A., Defendant-Third Party St. Paul Fire & Marine Insurance Company, Third PartyThird Circuit· 1997-02-03· cited 342×
- Friends of the Everglades v. South Florida Water Management DistrictEleventh Circuit· 2009-06-04· cited 154×
- Christian Coalition of Florida, Inc. v. United StatesEleventh Circuit· 2011-11-15· cited 153×
- United States v. ArdleyEleventh Circuit· 2001-02-20· cited 135×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.