W-Y-C-& H-O-B
Citations
- 27 I. & N. Dec. 189
Syllabus
W-Y-C-& H-O-B-, 27 I&N Dec. 189 (BIA 2018) (1) An applicant seeking asylum or withholding of removal based on membership in a particular social group must clearly indicate on the record before the Immigration Judge the exact delineation of any proposed particular social group. (2) The Board of Immigration Appeals generally will not address a newly articulated particular social group that was not advanced before the Immigration Judge.
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- concluding that BIA may not consider new social groups raised for the first time on appeal
- holding that we generally will not consider an argument that could have been, but was not, raised before the Immigration Judge
- holding that BIA 2 “review[s] the ultimate determination whether a proposed group is cognizable de 3 novo,” but “review[s] an [IJ]’s factual findings underlying that determination for 4 clear error”
- noting that a petitioner must delineate his or her proposed social group before the IJ, and may not reframe the group on appeal
- stating that the Board “generally will not consider an argument or claim that could have been, but was not, advanced before the Immigration Judge”
- noting that Board has long held that it will generally not consider arguments or claims that could have, but were not, raised before the IJ
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Cited by
37 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- A-BBoard of Immigration Appeals· 2018-07-01· cited 277×
- Sontos Diaz-Reynoso v. William BarrNinth Circuit· 2020-08-07· cited 207×
- Jaco v. GarlandFifth Circuit· 2021-10-27· cited 125×
- Wendy Cantarero-Lagos v. William Barr, U. SFifth Circuit· 2019-05-06· cited 58×
- Miguel Arevalo-Quintero v. Merrick GarlandFourth Circuit· 2021-05-26· cited 56×
- Sonia Perez Vasquez v. Merrick GarlandFourth Circuit· 2021-07-09· cited 53×
- Barnica-Lopez v. GarlandFirst Circuit· 2023-02-08· cited 34×
- J-R-G-PBoard of Immigration Appeals· 2018-07-01· cited 31×
- Espinoza-Ochoa v. GarlandFirst Circuit· 2023-12-27· cited 27×
- Mauricio Gonzalez Ruano v. William P. BarrSeventh Circuit· 2019-04-24· cited 23×
- Carlos Mayorga-Rosa v. Jefferson B. Sessions, IIIEighth Circuit· 2018-04-24· cited 20×
- Maria Amaya-De Sicaran v. William BarrFourth Circuit· 2020-10-30· cited 17×
- Carlos Inestroza-Tosta v. Attorney General United States of AmericaThird Circuit· 2024-06-21· cited 16×
- Varela-Chavarria v. GarlandFirst Circuit· 2023-11-09· cited 15×
- Y-I-MBoard of Immigration Appeals· 2019-07-01· cited 14×
- Donis-Hernandez de Cabrera v. GarlandFirst Circuit· 2024-05-02· cited 13×
- Lee v. BarrFirst Circuit· 2020-09-22· cited 10×
- Marta Tista-Ruiz de Ajualip v. Merrick B. GarlandSixth Circuit· 2024-08-09· cited 10×
- Ferreira v. GarlandFirst Circuit· 2024-03-21· cited 9×
- Chun Mendez v. GarlandFirst Circuit· 2024-03-15· cited 8×
Cites
26 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- M-E-V-GBoard of Immigration Appeals· 2014-07-01· cited 1,009×
- COELHOBoard of Immigration Appeals· 1992-07-01· cited 405×
- Jopie Eduard v. John Ashcroft, U.S. Attorney General, Yuliana Pakkung v. John Ashcroft, U.S. Attorney GeneralFifth Circuit· 2004-07-21· cited 381×
- W-G-RBoard of Immigration Appeals· 2014-07-01· cited 359×
- Silvana Paloka v. Eric H. Holder, Jr.Second Circuit· 2014-08-07· cited 249×
- J-Y-CBoard of Immigration Appeals· 2007-07-01· cited 238×
- Valdiviezo-Galdamez v. Attorney General of the United StatesThird Circuit· 2011-11-08· cited 176×
- A-R-C-GBoard of Immigration Appeals· 2014-07-01· cited 121×
- L-E-ABoard of Immigration Appeals· 2017-07-01· cited 104×
- Joel Hernandez-De La Cruz v. Loretta LynchFifth Circuit· 2016-04-26· cited 88×
- Torres De La Cruz v. MaurerTenth Circuit· 2007-04-03· cited 77×
- S-HBoard of Immigration Appeals· 2002-07-01· cited 72×
- Prabhudial v. HolderSecond Circuit· 2015-03-12· cited 72×
- N-MBoard of Immigration Appeals· 2011-07-01· cited 69×
- L-A-CBoard of Immigration Appeals· 2015-07-01· cited 66×
- Claudio v. HolderFifth Circuit· 2010-03-18· cited 65×
- Francisca Sanchez-Robles v. Loretta E. LynchSixth Circuit· 2015-12-17· cited 64×
- Valdiviezo-Galdamez v. Attorney General of the United StatesThird Circuit· 2007-09-07· cited 63×
- Pinos-Gonzalez v. MukaseyEighth Circuit· 2008-03-05· cited 55×
- JIMENEZBoard of Immigration Appeals· 1996-07-01· cited 42×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.