State v. Franqui
Syllabus
Convicted of conspiracy to commit murder, accessory to murder, and accessory to assault in the first degree in connection with the shooting of the victim and another person, the defendant appealed to this court. Two individuals in an Infiniti had approached the vehicle that the victim was driving, and the passenger in the Infiniti shot and killed the victim, which caused the victim's vehicle to crash. At the scene of the crash, O, who was the victim's girlfriend and one of the passengers in his vehicle, immediately identified the perpetrators to a responding police officer as the defendant and his elder brother, E. Later that day, O submitted a signed, written statement to the police in which she identified the defendant as the driver of the Infiniti and E as the passenger who fired the shots that caused the victim's death. The following day, E admitted to J, his other brother, that E had killed the victim. At trial, O identified E as the shooter sitting in the passenger seat of the Infiniti but testified that she was not sure that the defendant was the driver. The prosecutor then introduced O's written statement that the defendant was the driver as a prior inconsistent statement for substantive purposes under State v. Whelan (200 Conn. 743) and the Connecticut Code of Evidence (§ 8-5 (1)). On appeal, the defendant claimed, inter alia, that his conviction violated his constitutional right to due process because it was based solely on O's uncorroborated, prior inconsistent statement identifying him as the driver of the Infiniti from which E shot and killed the victim. Held: The defendant could not prevail on his unpreserved claim that this court should overrule Whelan on the ground that the admission of prior inconsis- tent statements for substantive purposes violates principles of due process because of the unreliability of such statements. The defendant's conclusory legal arguments were insufficient to establish that Whelan's rejection of arguments challenging the
Judges: Mullins; McDonald; D’Auria; Ecker; Alexander; Dannehy; Bright
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCites
24 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- State v. GoldingSupreme Court of Connecticut· 1989-12-19· cited 2,736×
- State v. WhelanSupreme Court of Connecticut· 1986-08-05· cited 393×
- California v. TybergSupreme Court· 1986-12-01· cited 383×
- State v. KellySupreme Court of Connecticut· 2001-05-08· cited 162×
- State v. NewsomeSupreme Court of Connecticut· 1996-08-06· cited 111×
- Tracey Lust v. Sealy, Inc.Seventh Circuit· 2004-09-07· cited 92×
- State v. LockhartSupreme Court of Connecticut· 2010-10-12· cited 68×
- State v. SlaterSupreme Court of Connecticut· 2008-01-22· cited 62×
- State v. HolleySupreme Court of Connecticut· 2018-01-12· cited 51×
- State v. Patrick M.Supreme Court of Connecticut· 2022-09-02· cited 42×
- State v. StangeSupreme Court of Connecticut· 1989-08-15· cited 37×
- State v. NelsonConnecticut Appellate Court· 2008-01-22· cited 22×
- State v. ChemlenSupreme Court of Connecticut· 2016-06-29· cited 20×
- State v. BrownSupreme Court of Connecticut· 2022-12-06· cited 15×
- State v. SerranoConnecticut Appellate Court· 2010-09-07· cited 13×
- State v. TomlinsonSupreme Court of Connecticut· 2021-09-08· cited 13×
- State v. HaynesSupreme Court of Connecticut· 2025-07-01· cited 10×
- In re Aisjaha N.Supreme Court of Connecticut· 2022-06-20· cited 7×
- State v. Ervin B.Connecticut Appellate Court· 2020-12-22· cited 6×
- State v. HintonSupreme Court of Connecticut· 2025-06-24· cited 6×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.