Texas Supreme Court· 1/29/1992
Phillips v. Phillips
Citations
- 820 S.W.2d 785
- 1991 WL 260013
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that the defense that a liquidated damages provision is an unenforceable penalty generally will be waived if not affirmatively pleaded
- holding that defendant may rely on plaintiff’s anticipatory pleading in response to unpled defensive matters
- holding that under language of Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 94, penalty is matter constituting an avoidance or affirmative defense
- holding that a defense \is not waived by the failure to plead it if it is apparent on the face of the petition and established as a matter of law\
- holding that a liquidated damages provision is an unenforceable penalty unless the actual damages are difficult to estimate and the liquidated damages are a reasonable forecast of just compensation
- concluding that defense of penalty was not waived because face of plaintiff’s pleadings stated that she was “entitled to damages . . . in the amount of ten (10
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Hecht, Gonzalez, Mauzy, Doggett
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
198 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Valence Operating Co. v. DorsettTexas Supreme Court· 2005-05-20· cited 3,800×
- Harris County v. SmithTexas Supreme Court· 2002-12-19· cited 286×
- Aquaplex, Inc. v. Rancho La Valencia, Inc.Texas Supreme Court· 2009-10-30· cited 221×
- Lee C. Ritchie v. Ann Caldwell Rupe, as Trustee for the Dallas Gordon Rupe, III 1995 Family TrustTexas Supreme Court· 2014-06-20· cited 170×
- Citizens National Bank v. Allen Rae Investments Inc.Court of Appeals of Texas· 2004-07-15· cited 166×
- BMG Direct Marketing, Inc. v. PeakeTexas Supreme Court· 2005-11-18· cited 137×
- Shoemake v. Fogel, Ltd.Texas Supreme Court· 1992-04-29· cited 133×
- Adams v. H & H Meat Products, Inc.Tex. App. Ct., 13th Dist.· 2001-03-01· cited 127×
- Compass Bank v. MFP Financial Services, Inc.Tex. App. Ct., 5th Dist. (Dallas)· 2005-01-12· cited 119×
- Flores v. Millennium Interests, Ltd.Texas Supreme Court· 2005-09-30· cited 107×
- In Re: Dow Corning Corp., Debtor. Bear Stearns Government Securities, Inc. v. Dow Corning Corp.Sixth Circuit· 2005-08-22· cited 103×
- Crossmark, Inc. v. HazarTex. App. Ct., 5th Dist. (Dallas)· 2004-01-15· cited 100×
- Komet v. GravesTex. App. Ct., 4th Dist. (San Antonio)· 2001-01-31· cited 97×
- FPL Energy, LLC v. TXU Portfolio Management Co.Texas Supreme Court· 2014-03-21· cited 86×
- Rico v. FloresFifth Circuit· 2007-03-08· cited 80×
- Lesikar v. MoonTex. App. Ct., 14th Dist. (Houston)· 2007-10-18· cited 79×
- Feiger, Collison & Killmer v. JonesSupreme Court of Colorado· 1996-11-12· cited 78×
- Arthur's Garage, Inc. v. Racal-Chubb Security Systems, Inc.Tex. App. Ct., 5th Dist. (Dallas)· 1999-07-15· cited 75×
- Lafarge Corp. v. Wolff, Inc.Tex. App. Ct., 3rd Dist. (Austin)· 1998-09-24· cited 73×
- Arce v. BurrowTex. App. Ct., 14th Dist. (Houston)· 1998-01-15· cited 70×
Cites
30 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Burt v. LochausenTexas Supreme Court· 1952-05-21· cited 347×
- Turner, Collie & Braden, Inc. v. Brookhollow, Inc.Texas Supreme Court· 1982-07-21· cited 252×
- Stewart v. BaseyTexas Supreme Court· 1952-01-16· cited 249×
- Gorman v. Life Insurance Co. of North AmericaTexas Supreme Court· 1991-03-27· cited 200×
- Oil Field Haulers Ass'n v. Railroad CommissionTexas Supreme Court· 1964-06-03· cited 165×
- First National Bank in Dallas v. ZimmermanTexas Supreme Court· 1969-06-11· cited 71×
- Rio Grande Valley Sugar Growers, Inc. v. CampesiTexas Supreme Court· 1979-12-31· cited 58×
- Schepps v. American District Telegraph Co. of TexasCourt of Appeals of Texas· 1955-12-16· cited 51×
- Bethel v. Butler Drilling Co.Court of Appeals of Texas· 1982-05-27· cited 43×
- Lewkowicz v. El Paso Apparel Corp.Texas Supreme Court· 1981-12-02· cited 34×
- Commercial Union Insurance Co. v. La Villa Independent School DistrictTex. App. Ct., 13th Dist.· 1989-10-12· cited 32×
- Hammonds v. HammondsTexas Supreme Court· 1958-04-30· cited 28×
- Lefevere v. SearsCourt of Appeals of Texas· 1981-07-22· cited 26×
- Zucht v. Stewart Title Guaranty Co.Court of Appeals of Texas· 1947-11-26· cited 26×
- Raney v. WhiteCourt of Appeals of Texas· 1954-03-31· cited 21×
- Walsh v. Methodist Episcopal ChurchTexas Commission of Appeals· 1919-06-21· cited 19×
- Robinson v. Granite Equipment Leasing Corp.Court of Appeals of Texas· 1977-05-05· cited 18×
- Johnson Engineers, Inc. v. Tri-Water Supply Corp.Court of Appeals of Texas· 1979-05-15· cited 17×
- Muller v. LightCourt of Appeals of Texas· 1976-06-23· cited 17×
- Young v. J. F. Zimmerman & Sons, Inc.Court of Appeals of Texas· 1968-11-27· cited 17×
Other cases named Phillips v. Phillips
253 other CourtListener records share this case name; the 50 most cited are listed.
- Phillips v. PhillipsCourt of Civil Appeals of Alabama· 1993-03-19· cited 151×
- Phillips v. PhillipsCalifornia Supreme Court· 1953-12-24· cited 85×
- Phillips v. PhillipsTex. App. Ct., 8th Dist. (El Paso)· 2009-05-28· cited 65×
- Phillips v. . PhillipsNew York Court of Appeals· 1889-01-15· cited 57×
- Phillips v. PhillipsIdaho Supreme Court· 1969-12-05· cited 49×
- Phillips v. PhillipsCourt of Civil Appeals of Alabama· 1973-01-10· cited 42×
- Phillips v. PhillipsMississippi Supreme Court· 2004-12-02· cited 41×
- Phillips v. PhillipsTex. App. Ct., 9th Dist. (Beaumont)· 2002-05-02· cited 39×
- Phillips v. PhillipsMississippi Supreme Court· 1989-12-13· cited 38×
- Phillips v. PhillipsAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York· 1956-04-24· cited 35×
- Phillips v. PhillipsNebraska Supreme Court· 1960-07-08· cited 33×
- Phillips v. PhillipsAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York· 1979-08-13· cited 29×
- Phillips v. PhillipsNew York Court of Appeals· 1956-10-18· cited 27×
- Phillips v. PhillipsSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1864-07-01· cited 27×
- Phillips v. PhillipsCourt of Appeals of Mississippi· 2010-04-06· cited 26×
- Phillips v. PhillipsSupreme Court of Oklahoma· 1976-11-09· cited 23×
- Phillips v. PhillipsCourt of Civil Appeals of Alabama· 1986-02-05· cited 22×
- Phillips v. PhillipsNew Jersey Superior Court App Division· 1993-10-07· cited 21×
- Phillips v. PhillipsOhio Court of Appeals· 2014-12-08· cited 20×
- Phillips v. PhillipsWisconsin Supreme Court· 1870-06-15· cited 20×
- Phillips v. PhillipsSupreme Court of Arkansas· 1954-11-15· cited 17×
- Phillips v. PhillipsSupreme Court of Alabama· 1964-07-30· cited 17×
- Phillips v. PhillipsCourt of Appeals of South Carolina· 1986-12-15· cited 16×
- Phillips v. PhillipsSupreme Court of Georgia· 1955-01-12· cited 16×
- Phillips v. PhillipsCourt of Civil Appeals of Alabama· 1977-04-12· cited 15×
- Phillips v. PhillipsNebraska Supreme Court· 1978-03-08· cited 15×
- Phillips v. PhillipsTex. App. Ct., 1st Dist. (Houston)· 2007-10-18· cited 15×
- Phillips v. PhillipsMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1958-01-02· cited 15×
- Phillips v. PhillipsAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York· 1998-04-27· cited 15×
- Phillips v. PhillipsNew York Supreme Court· 1958-10-15· cited 15×
- Phillips v. PhillipsSupreme Court of Georgia· 1927-03-03· cited 14×
- Phillips v. PhillipsSupreme Court of Missouri· 1969-06-09· cited 13×
- Phillips v. PhillipsCourt of Appeals of Texas· 1976-01-14· cited 13×
- Phillips v. PhillipsSupreme Court of Georgia· 1916-10-20· cited 13×
- Phillips v. PhillipsLouisiana Court of Appeal· 1975-09-09· cited 12×
- Phillips v. PhillipsCourt of Appeals of Texas· 1992-03-05· cited 12×
- Phillips v. PhillipsSupreme Court of Kansas· 1947-11-08· cited 12×
- Phillips v. PhillipsCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1941-12-09· cited 11×
- Phillips v. PhillipsTex. App. Ct., 12th Dist. (Tyler)· 1990-06-26· cited 11×
- Phillips v. PhillipsMissouri Court of Appeals· 1991-11-21· cited 11×
- Phillips v. PhillipsSupreme Court of Iowa· 1960-09-20· cited 11×
- Phillips v. PhillipsWisconsin Supreme Court· 1867-09-15· cited 11×
- Phillips v. PhillipsIllinois Supreme Court· 1863-04-15· cited 11×
- Phillips v. PhillipsSupreme Court of Kansas· 1904-05-07· cited 11×
- Phillips v. PhillipsSupreme Court of Oklahoma· 1954-03-02· cited 10×
- Phillips v. PhillipsConnecticut Appellate Court· 2007-05-08· cited 10×
- Phillips v. PhillipsOhio Court of Appeals· 2014-01-27· cited 10×
- Phillips v. PhillipsSupreme Court of Arkansas· 1930-09-22· cited 10×
- Phillips v. PhillipsWest Virginia Supreme Court· 1884-09-20· cited 10×
- Phillips v. PhillipsSupreme Court of South Carolina· 1986-02-26· cited 10×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.