Gallegos v. LeHouillier
Citations
- 2017 COA 35
- 434 P.3d 698
Syllabus
Legal Malpractice—Burden of Proof—Collectability—Affirmative Defense. Plaintiff Gallegos sued defendants LeHouillier, an attorney, and his law firm, LeHouillier & Associates, P.C. (collectively, LeHouillier), for legal malpractice. The jury found that LeHouillier had negligently breached his duty of professional care when handling an underlying medical malpractice case for Gallegos. The trial court placed the burden on Gallegos to prove that any judgment in the underlying case was collectable, and it ruled that Gallegos had provided sufficient evidence to prove that point, entering judgment in her favor. On appeal, LeHouillier contended that the judgment must be reversed because collectibility is an element that a plaintiff must prove in a legal malpractice case, and Gallegos did not prove that any judgment that she would have received in the underlying malpractice case would have been collectible. Gallegos countered that the issue of collectibility is an affirmative defense and the court should have required LeHouillier to prove that the judgment was not collectible. The Court of Appeals determined that the record did not contain sufficient evidence that the judgment was collectible. In addition, the trial court erred when it placed the burden on Gallegos to prove that any judgment in the underlying medical malpractice case would have been collectible it should have required LeHouillier (1) to raise the question of collectibility as an affirmative defense and (2) to prove that any judgment Gallegos would have received would not have been collectible. The judgment was reversed and the case was remanded for a new trial.
Cited by
1 case in this archive cites this case.
Cites
45 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Allen v. SteeleSupreme Court of Colorado· 2011-05-09· cited 701×
- Bebo Construction Co. v. Mattox & O'Brien, P.C.Supreme Court of Colorado· 1999-12-06· cited 307×
- Hall v. FrankelColorado Court of Appeals· 2008-06-26· cited 189×
- Green v. CASTLE CONCRETE COMPANYSupreme Court of Colorado· 1973-04-23· cited 171×
- Kituskie v. CorbmanSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1998-08-07· cited 153×
- Loretta Klump v. J. David Duffus, Jr., Law Offices of Dixon, Duffus & Doub, a Partnership, and Accident and Injury Referral ServiceSeventh Circuit· 1996-01-12· cited 90×
- Jourdain v. DineenSupreme Judicial Court of Maine· 1987-07-09· cited 87×
- Beeck v. Aquaslide 'N' Dive Corp.Supreme Court of Iowa· 1984-05-16· cited 86×
- Power Constructors, Inc. v. Taylor & HintzeAlaska Supreme Court· 1998-06-19· cited 74×
- Miller v. ByrneColorado Court of Appeals· 1995-10-05· cited 63×
- Rantz v. KaufmanSupreme Court of Colorado· 2005-02-28· cited 60×
- Prutch v. Ford Motor Co.Supreme Court of Colorado· 1980-10-20· cited 59×
- Hoppe v. RanziniNew Jersey Superior Court App Division· 1978-03-15· cited 58×
- CHANDRIS, SA v. YanakakisSupreme Court of Florida· 1995-12-21· cited 53×
- Gibbons v. LudlowSupreme Court of Colorado· 2013-07-01· cited 51×
- Carbone v. TierneySupreme Court of New Hampshire· 2004-12-10· cited 45×
- McDow v. DixonCourt of Appeals of Georgia· 1976-04-06· cited 43×
- Kituskie v. CorbmanSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1996-08-29· cited 42×
- City of Westminster v. Centric-Jones ConstructorsColorado Court of Appeals· 2004-11-08· cited 37×
- Morris v. GeerColorado Court of Appeals· 1986-03-06· cited 36×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.