Seventh Circuit· 9/7/2011
Escobar v. Holder
Citations
- 657 F.3d 537
- 2011 U.S. App. LEXIS 18583
- 2011 WL 4349403
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that a social group “cannot be defined solely by the fact that its members suffer persecution from the government or from a group that the government cannot or will not control”
- instructing that we cannot tease out one component of the group’s characteristics to defeat the defini- tion of social group
- instructing that we cannot tease out one component of the group’s characteristics to defeat the definition of social group
- noting that “[w]here a proposed group is defined only by the characteristic that it is persecuted, it does not qualify, as a ‘social group’”
- instructing that we cannot tease out one component of the group’s characteristics to defeat the definition of social group.
- instructing that we 8 No. 11-1989 cannot tease out one component of the group’s charac- teristics to defeat the definition of social group.
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Easterbrook, Wood, Tinder
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
23 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Milligan v. Board of Trustees of Southern Illinois UniversitySeventh Circuit· 2012-07-10· cited 122×
- Johana Cece v. Eric Holder, Jr.Seventh Circuit· 2013-08-09· cited 80×
- N.L.A. v. Eric Holder, Jr.Seventh Circuit· 2014-03-03· cited 52×
- Espinoza-Ochoa v. GarlandFirst Circuit· 2023-12-27· cited 27×
- Perez-Rabanales v. SessionsFirst Circuit· 2018-01-26· cited 26×
- Mauricio Gonzalez Ruano v. William P. BarrSeventh Circuit· 2019-04-24· cited 23×
- Nazirmohammad I. Vah v. Eric H. HolSeventh Circuit· 2013-02-25· cited 15×
- Marina Hernandez v. Eric Holder, Jr.Fourth Circuit· 2015-04-14· cited 15×
- Sarmiento v. HolderSeventh Circuit· 2012-05-21· cited 14×
- Ferreira v. LynchSeventh Circuit· 2016-07-12· cited 14×
- R. R. D. v. Eric Holder, Jr.Seventh Circuit· 2014-03-19· cited 12×
- Salim v. HolderSeventh Circuit· 2013-08-28· cited 12×
- Mohsin Siddiqui v. Eric Holder, Jr.Seventh Circuit· 2012-01-12· cited 10×
- Cheikh Lam v. Eric Holder, Jr.Seventh Circuit· 2012-10-16· cited 8×
- Melvin Osorio-Morales v. Merrick GarlandSeventh Circuit· 2023-07-05· cited 8×
- Melnik v. SessionsSeventh Circuit· 2018-05-25· cited 6×
- Benjamin Ruiz-Cabrera v. Eric Holder, Jr.Seventh Circuit· 2014-04-08· cited 3×
- Borjas Cruz v. Merrick GarlandSeventh Circuit· 2024-03-21· cited 3×
- Johana Cece v. Eric Holder, Jr.Seventh Circuit· 2012-02-06· cited 2×
- Mahvash Akram v. Eric Holder, Jr.Seventh Circuit· 2013-07-09· cited 2×
Cites
25 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Chevron U. S. A. Inc. v. Natural Resources Defense Council, Inc.Supreme Court· 1984-06-25· cited 20,645×
- Immigration & Naturalization Service v. Elias-ZacariasSupreme Court· 1992-01-22· cited 8,324×
- Immigration & Naturalization Service v. Cardoza-FonsecaSupreme Court· 1987-03-09· cited 4,149×
- United States v. Mead Corp.Supreme Court· 2001-06-18· cited 3,086×
- Immigration & Naturalization Service v. StevicSupreme Court· 1984-06-05· cited 1,666×
- Virginia v. BlackSupreme Court· 2003-04-07· cited 1,109×
- Gonzales v. ThomasSupreme Court· 2006-04-17· cited 486×
- KASINGABoard of Immigration Appeals· 1996-07-01· cited 184×
- C-ABoard of Immigration Appeals· 2006-07-01· cited 170×
- Ferdinant Mema v. Alberto R. GonzalesSeventh Circuit· 2007-01-11· cited 114×
- Arqile Gjerazi, Klarita Gjerazi, Alba Gjerazi, and Justin Gjerazi v. Alberto Gonzales, 1Seventh Circuit· 2006-01-30· cited 93×
- Jose A. Bazan-Reyes, Wincenty Z. MacIasowicz and Arnoldo Gomez-Vela v. Immigration and Naturalization Service and John D. AshcroftSeventh Circuit· 2001-07-05· cited 89×
- Espinosa-Cortez v. Attorney General of United StatesThird Circuit· 2010-06-02· cited 82×
- Abdelhadi Hor v. Alberto R. GonzalesSeventh Circuit· 2005-08-29· cited 81×
- Gatimi v. HolderSeventh Circuit· 2009-08-20· cited 80×
- Soroya Sharif v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceSeventh Circuit· 1996-07-03· cited 76×
- Arobelidze v. HolderSeventh Circuit· 2011-07-27· cited 67×
- Nazani Yadegar-Sargis v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceSeventh Circuit· 2002-07-22· cited 65×
- Vahora v. HolderSeventh Circuit· 2010-11-15· cited 61×
- Volodymyr Pavlyk, Natalia Pavlyk, and Iryna Pavlyk v. Alberto R. GonzalesSeventh Circuit· 2006-12-07· cited 60×
Other cases named Escobar v. Holder
9 other CourtListener records share this case name.
- Escobar v. HolderNinth Circuit· 2009-05-27· cited 23×
- Escobar v. HolderFirst Circuit· 2012-10-22· cited 9×
- Escobar v. HolderNinth Circuit· 2009-07-10· cited 1×
- Escobar v. HolderNinth Circuit· 2009-07-10· cited 1×
- Escobar v. HolderNinth Circuit· 2009-05-27
- Escobar v. HolderNinth Circuit· 2009-07-10
- Escobar v. HolderSupreme Court· 2010-06-21
- Escobar v. HolderNinth Circuit· 2009-07-15
- Escobar v. HolderNinth Circuit· 2009-07-15
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.