Seventh Circuit· 10/9/2019
David McDaniel v. Progress Rail Locomotive, Inc.
Citations
- 940 F.3d 360
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- explaining that plaintiffs must offer evidence of a similarly situated comparator to survive summary judgment
- suggesting that submitting comparators’ names in addition to comparable “work history [and] performance reviews” would be enough to survive summary judgment
- holding the plaintiff’s discrimination claim failed under the Ortiz holistic approach and McDonnell Douglas framework
- holding a plaintiff’s prima facie case failed where she failed to identify any similarly situated employees to allow a factfinder to conduct a “meaningful comparison”
- holding the plaintiff’s discrimination and retaliation claims failed under the Ortiz holistic approach and McDonnell Douglas framework
- noting that the plaintiff failed to pro- vide the proposed comparator employees’ “names, work his- tory, performance review, or—most importantly [given the type of claim]—their ages”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: St__Eve
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
14 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Linda Brooks v. AvancezSeventh Circuit· 2022-07-06· cited 142×
- Romuald Tyburski v. City of ChicagoSeventh Circuit· 2020-07-01· cited 139×
- Nazariy Lesiv v. Illinois Central Railroad ComSeventh Circuit· 2022-07-13· cited 118×
- Emily Lewis v. Indiana Wesleyan UniversitySeventh Circuit· 2022-06-10· cited 108×
- Anne Marnocha v. St. Vincent Hospital and HealSeventh Circuit· 2021-01-22· cited 91×
- Amit Sinha v. Bradley UniversitySeventh Circuit· 2021-04-26· cited 36×
- Alice Huff v. Pete ButtigiegSeventh Circuit· 2022-07-28· cited 33×
- Kristie Alley v. Penguin Random HouseSeventh Circuit· 2023-03-09· cited 23×
- Kimberly Barnes-Staples v. Robin CarnahanSeventh Circuit· 2023-12-18· cited 23×
- Brad Sandefur v. Thomas DartSeventh Circuit· 2020-11-04· cited 19×
- Anthony Smith v. City of JanesvilleSeventh Circuit· 2022-07-22· cited 16×
- Ron Morris v. BNSF Railway CompanySeventh Circuit· 2020-08-11
- Kristie Alley v. Penguin Random HouseSeventh Circuit· 2023-03-10
- Mary Arnold v. UALSeventh Circuit· 2025-07-25
Cites
23 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- McDonnell Douglas Corp. v. GreenSupreme Court· 1973-05-14· cited 38,518×
- Henry Ortiz v. Werner Enterprises, IncorporatSeventh Circuit· 2016-08-19· cited 1,674×
- Otis Grant v. Trustees of Indiana UniversitySeventh Circuit· 2017-08-31· cited 1,306×
- Denise Coleman v. Patrick R. DonahoSeventh Circuit· 2012-01-06· cited 861×
- Skiba v. Ill. Cent. R.R. Co.Seventh Circuit· 2018-03-08· cited 727×
- Boss v. CastroSeventh Circuit· 2016-03-18· cited 582×
- David v. Board of Trustees of Community College District No. 508Seventh Circuit· 2017-01-13· cited 443×
- Hedrick G. Humphries v. Cbocs West, Inc.Seventh Circuit· 2007-01-29· cited 431×
- Nichols v. Michigan City Plant Planning DepartmentSeventh Circuit· 2014-06-19· cited 346×
- Spurling v. C & M Fine Pack, Inc.Seventh Circuit· 2014-01-13· cited 274×
- Gates v. Caterpillar, Inc.Seventh Circuit· 2008-01-16· cited 247×
- Patterson v. INDIANA NEWSPAPERS, INCORPORATEDSeventh Circuit· 2009-12-08· cited 192×
- Lewis v. WilkieSeventh Circuit· 2018-11-29· cited 184×
- Aaron Carson v. Lake County, IndianaSeventh Circuit· 2017-07-26· cited 159×
- Shannon Kampmier v. Emeritus CorporationSeventh Circuit· 2007-01-02· cited 149×
- Barton v. Zimmer, Inc.Seventh Circuit· 2011-10-18· cited 134×
- Lena C. Barricks v. Eli Lilly and CompanySeventh Circuit· 2007-04-04· cited 129×
- Martino v. MCI Communications Services, Inc.Seventh Circuit· 2009-07-28· cited 126×
- Schandelmeier-Bartels v. Chicago Park DistrictSeventh Circuit· 2011-02-08· cited 125×
- Filar v. Board of Educ. of City of ChicagoSeventh Circuit· 2008-05-22· cited 121×
Other cases named David McDaniel v. Progress Rail Locomotive, Inc.
2 other CourtListener records share this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.