Cate v. State

How courts have described this case

Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.

• holding jury was free to reject unanimous opinion of five psychiatrists that defendant was legally insane where psychiatrists' assertions were not uncontroverted by other evidence
• affirming the defendant's conviction because of inconsistencies in his story, which suggested feigning, and because there was probative demeanor evidence of defendant's lucidity upon arrest
• affirming the defendant's conviction because of inconsistencies in his story, which suggested feigning, and because there was probative demeanor evidence of defendant's lucidity upon arrest
• explaining that this Court has “never held expert testimony to be conclusive”
• explaining that this Court has “never held expert testimony to be conclusive”
• evidence showing defendant's \deliberation in accomplishing the killing\ supported the factfinder's rejection of insanity defense

Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).

Cited by

24 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.

• Thompson v. State
  Indiana Supreme Court· 2004-03-23· cited 150×
• Roach v. State
  Indiana Supreme Court· 1998-06-19· cited 94×
• Cook v. State
  Indiana Supreme Court· 1996-12-23· cited 88×
• McEwen v. State
  Indiana Supreme Court· 1998-04-30· cited 77×
• Gambill v. State
  Indiana Supreme Court· 1996-12-18· cited 74×
• Galloway v. State
  Indiana Supreme Court· 2010-12-22· cited 64×
• Donald W. Myers, III. v. State of Indiana
  Indiana Supreme Court· 2015-04-08· cited 53×
• Walker v. Cuppett
  Indiana Court of Appeals· 2004-05-05· cited 37×
• Anderson v. State
  Indiana Supreme Court· 1998-08-20· cited 14×
• Lori Barcroft v. State of Indiana
  Indiana Supreme Court· 2018-12-03· cited 14×
• Garner v. State
  Indiana Supreme Court· 1998-12-18· cited 9×
• Derek Hutchinson v. State of Indiana
  Indiana Court of Appeals· 2017-08-10· cited 8×
• Jones v. State
  Indiana Court of Appeals· 2005-04-22· cited 8×
• Joseph Spaulding v. Joseph Cook (mem. dec.)
  Indiana Court of Appeals· 2017-12-12· cited 7×
• Smith v. State
  Indiana Court of Appeals· 1995-11-29· cited 6×
• Reginald Lee Robinson v. State of Indiana
  Indiana Court of Appeals· 2016-05-04· cited 5×
• Mauricio v. State
  Indiana Court of Appeals· 1997-08-04· cited 4×
• Watson v. State
  Indiana Supreme Court· 1995-12-05· cited 2×
• Jason Lee Sowers v. State of Indiana
  Indiana Court of Appeals· 2013-05-16· cited 2×
• Miller v. State
  Indiana Court of Appeals· 1998-05-04· cited 1×

Cites

4 cases in this archive are cited by this case.

• Anthony v. State
  Indiana Supreme Court· 1980-09-25· cited 41×
• Turner v. State
  Indiana Supreme Court· 1981-12-15· cited 25×
• Mayes v. State
  Indiana Supreme Court· 1982-10-20· cited 10×
• Lyon v. State
  Indiana Supreme Court· 1993-02-12· cited 9×