Brigham City v. Stuart
Citations
- 547 U.S. 398
- 126 S. Ct. 1943
- 164 L. Ed. 2d 650
- 2006 U.S. LEXIS 4155
About this case
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
2006 United States Supreme Court case
Brigham City v. Stuart, 547 U.S. 398 (2006), is a United States Supreme Court case involving the exigent circumstances exception to the Fourth Amendment 's warrant requirement. The Court ruled that police may enter a home without a warrant if they have an objectively reasonable basis for believing that an occupant is or is about to be seriously injured.
The case involved the arrest of four adults seen restraining a juvenile, who punched one of the adults who was restraining him. The trial court granted the defendants' motion to dismiss, arguing that the warrantless entry was not supported by exigent circumstances ; the Utah Court of Appeals and Utah Supreme Court both affirmed the trial court's ruling. However, the U.S. Supreme Court reversed and remanded the case on May 22, 2006.
Background
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Brigham_City_v._Stuart&action=edit§ion=1 "Edit section: Background")
]
On July 23, 2001, at about 3:00 AM, four Brigham City police officers were dispatched to a loud house party . At the front door, the officers determined that knocking would not be productive and made their way down the driveway alongside the house to investigate. Through a slat fence they saw two minors drinking and entered the backyard, having probable cause to do so. While in the backyard, the officers saw a fight inside the house, which appeared to be four adults restraining a juvenile. At one point, the juvenile broke free and struck one of the occupants of the house in the nose with his hand.
Two officers opened the screen door and "hollered" to identify themselves, but the occupants didn't notice. After entering the house, one officer shouted again to identify himself, this time alerting the occupants. The occupants then became upset at the presence of the officers in the residence without permission. The officers arrested the adults and charged them with contributing to the delinquency of a minor , disorderly conduct , and intoxication . The defendants filed a motion to suppress with the trial court. The trial court sided with the defendants, and the city twice appealed to the Utah Court of Appeals and the Utah Supreme Court, which both affirmed the trial court's ruling.
Opinion of the Court
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Brigham_City_v._Stuart&action=edit§ion=2 "Edit section: Opinion of the Court")
]
The Supreme Court reversed the decision of the Utah Supreme Court, in a unanimous opinion delivered by Chief Justice John Roberts . Justice John Paul Stevens delivered a separate concurring opinion.
Exigency
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Brigham_City_v._Stuart&action=edit§ion=3 "Edit section: Exigency")
]
The Court ruled that the officers' warrantless entry into the home was justified under the emergency aid exception to getting a warrant because their entry "was plainly reasonable under the circumstances." In ruling the officers' entry was supported by exigency , the Court cited _Mincey v. Arizona _, 437 U.S. 385 (1978), 393–394:
[W]arrants are generally required to search a person’s home or his person unless 'the exigencies of the situation' make the needs of law enforcement so compelling that the warrantless search is objectively reasonable under the Fourth Amendment." ... One exigency obviating the requirement of a warrant is the need to assist persons who are seriously injured or threatened with such injury. ... Accordingly, law enforcement officers may enter a home without a warrant to render emergency assistance to an injured occupant or to protect an occupant from imminent injury. Mincey, supra, at 392; see also _Georgia v. Randolph _, 547
The court found that "the officers had an objectively reasonable basis for believing both that the injured adult might need help and that the violence in the kitchen was just beginning."
"Knock and announce" rule
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Brigham_City_v._Stuart&action=edit§ion=4 "Edit section: "Knock and announce" rule")
]
The Court found that "the manner of the officers' entry was also reasonable." The court found that after seeing the punch, one officer opened the screen door to the kitchen and yelled in "police." Upon nobody hearing him, he stepped into the kitchen and then announced himself again, which prompted the tumult to subside. The Court ruled that:
...the officer's announcement of his presence was at least equivalent to a knock on the screen door. Indeed, it was probably the only option that had even a chance of rising above the din. Under these circumstances, there was no violation of the Fourth Amendment’s knock-and-announce rule.
Also, the Court ruled that once the officers announced their presence, they were free to enter the house to deal with the tumult, as it would be pointless to stand at the door waiting for a response while people brawled inside.
External links
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Brigham_City_v._Stuart&action=edit§ion=5 "Edit section: External links")
]
Text of Brigham City v. Stuart, 547 U.S. 398 (2006) is available from: Findlaw Google Scholar Internet Archive (docket files) Justia Oyez (oral argument audio) Supreme Court (slip opinion) (archived)
hide
United States Fourth Amendment case law
show
Scope of the Fourth Amendment
Definition of search
- _Boyd v. United States _ (1886)
- _United States v. Lee _ (1927)
- _Olmstead v. United States _ (1928)
- _Abel v. United States _ (1960)
- _Silverman v. United States _ (1961)
- _Katz v. United States _ (1967)
- _United States v. Knotts _ (1983)
- _United States v. Place _ (1983)
- _United States v. Karo _ (1984)
- _California v. Greenwood _ (1988)
- _Skinner v. Railway Labor Executives Ass'n _ (1989)
- _United States v. Verdugo-Urquidez _ (1990)
- _Bond v. United States _ (2000)
- _Kyllo v. United States _ (2001)
- _Illinois v. Caballes _ (2005)
- _United States v. Jones _ (2012)
- _Florida v. Jardines _ (2013)
- _Klayman v. Obama _ (D.D.C. 2013)
- _American Civil Liberties Union v. Clapper _ (D.D.C. 2013)
Definition of seizure
- _Counselman v. Hitchcock _ (1892)
- _Hale v. Henkel _ (1906)
- _Terry v. Ohio _ (1968)
- _United States v. Mendenhall _ (1980)
- _Florida v. Royer _ (1983)
- _INS v. Delgado _ (1984)
- _California v. Hodari D. _ (1991)
- _Florida v. Bostick _ (1991)
- _Soldal v. Cook County _ (1992)
- _[United Sta
…
Editorial context from Wikipedia (CC-BY-SA 4.0).
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that the Fourth Amendment does not require police “to wait until another blow render[s] someone ‘unconscious’ or ‘semi-conscious’ or worse before entering”
- holding that emergency doctrine applied because the officers were confronted with violence then occurring within the home
- holding that emergency doctrine applied because the officers were confronted with violence then occurring within the home
- holding that-a warrantless police entry did not violate the Fourth Amendment where 'officers standing* outside' a house witnessed a fight between a juvenile and four adults inside
- holding that, under the emergency-aid exception to the Fourth Amendment’s warrant requirement, “[t]he officer’s subjective motivation is irrelevant”
- holding that “law enforcement officers may enter a home without a warrant . . . to protect an occupant from imminent injury”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Roberts, Stevens
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
1,180 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Michael Lacey v. Joseph ArpaioNinth Circuit· 2012-08-29· cited 4,653×
- District of Columbia v. HellerSupreme Court· 2008-06-26· cited 3,086×
- Ziglar v. AbbasiSupreme Court· 2017-06-19· cited 2,879×
- Rodriguez v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2015-04-21· cited 2,086×
- McDonald v. City of ChicagoSupreme Court· 2010-06-28· cited 2,024×
- Ashcroft v. al-KiddSupreme Court· 2011-05-31· cited 1,740×
- Florida v. JardinesSupreme Court· 2013-03-26· cited 1,615×
- Kentucky v. KingSupreme Court· 2011-05-16· cited 1,457×
- Birchfield v. N. Dakota. William Robert BernardSupreme Court· 2016-06-23· cited 1,440×
- City and County of San Francisco v. SheehanSupreme Court· 2015-05-18· cited 1,017×
- Cortez v. McCauleyTenth Circuit· 2007-02-19· cited 554×
- United States v. ScrogginsFifth Circuit· 2010-03-04· cited 540×
- People v. Letner and TobinCalifornia Supreme Court· 2010-07-29· cited 530×
- Jose Chavez v. James ZiglarNinth Circuit· 2012-06-20· cited 467×
- v. AllenSupreme Court of Colorado· 2019-10-28· cited 412×
- Michigan v. FisherSupreme Court· 2009-12-07· cited 389×
- Gates v. Texas Deparment of Protective & Regulatory ServicesFifth Circuit· 2008-07-31· cited 355×
- Collins v. VirginiaSupreme Court· 2018-05-29· cited 347×
- Kansas v. MarshSupreme Court· 2006-06-26· cited 332×
- Nunez v. DuncanNinth Circuit· 2010-01-11· cited 290×
Cites
25 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Graham v. ConnorSupreme Court· 1989-05-15· cited 16,485×
- Katz v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1967-12-18· cited 13,304×
- Payton v. New YorkSupreme Court· 1980-04-15· cited 7,618×
- Whren v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1996-05-15· cited 7,105×
- Mincey v. ArizonaSupreme Court· 1978-06-21· cited 3,849×
- Michigan v. LongSupreme Court· 1983-07-06· cited 3,763×
- Ker v. CaliforniaSupreme Court· 1963-06-10· cited 3,146×
- Welsh v. WisconsinSupreme Court· 1984-05-15· cited 1,874×
- Scott v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1978-06-26· cited 1,598×
- Michigan v. TylerSupreme Court· 1978-05-31· cited 1,386×
- United States v. SantanaSupreme Court· 1976-06-24· cited 1,382×
- Groh v. RamirezSupreme Court· 2004-02-24· cited 1,303×
- City of Indianapolis v. EdmondSupreme Court· 2000-11-28· cited 1,205×
- Florida v. WellsSupreme Court· 1990-04-18· cited 1,010×
- Lewis L. Wayne v. United StatesD.C. Circuit· 1963-04-04· cited 479×
- People v. MitchellNew York Court of Appeals· 1976-04-06· cited 458×
- Bond v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2000-04-17· cited 413×
- Flippo v. West VirginiaSupreme Court· 1999-10-18· cited 198×
- United States v. Hector Morales Cervantes, AKA Benito C. CarilloNinth Circuit· 2000-06-12· cited 115×
- In Re Sealed Case 96-3167D.C. Circuit· 1998-09-04· cited 81×
Other cases named Brigham City v. Stuart
3 other CourtListener records share this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.