Bailey v. United States
Citations
- 516 U.S. 137
- 116 S. Ct. 501
- 133 L. Ed. 2d 472
- 1995 U.S. LEXIS 8536
About this case
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
For the 2013 Supreme Court case concerning search and seizure, see Bailey v. United States (2013) .
1995 United States Supreme Court case
Bailey v. United States, 516 U.S. 137 (1995), was a United States Supreme Court case in which the Court interpreted a frequently used section of the federal criminal code . At the time of the decision, 18 U.S.C. § 924 (c) imposed a mandatory, consecutive five-year prison term on anyone who "during and in relation to any... drug trafficking crime... uses a firearm." The lower court had sustained the defendants ' convictions , defining "use" in such a way as to mean little more than mere possession. The Supreme Court ruled instead that "use" means "active employment" of a firearm, and sent the cases back to the lower court for further proceedings. As a result of the Court's decision in Bailey, Congress amended the statute to expressly include possession of a firearm as requiring the additional five-year prison term.
Background
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Bailey_v._United_States&action=edit§ion=1 "Edit section: Background")
]
In May 1989, Bailey was stopped in the District of Columbia for not having a front license plate on his car. Bailey could not produce a driver's license, and the officers ordered him out of the car. As Bailey was exiting the car, the officers saw him stuff something between the seat and the front console. A subsequent search of the passenger compartment revealed 27 plastic bags containing a total of 30 grams of cocaine. In the trunk of the car the officers found a loaded nine-millimeter pistol.
In June 1991, Robinson was the target of two controlled purchases of cocaine. The police then obtained a search warrant and searched Robinson's one-bedroom apartment, where they found an unloaded .22 caliber pistol and 11 grams of crack cocaine. They also found a marked $20 bill from one of the prior controlled purchases.
Both Bailey and Robinson were charged with numerous crimes, including violations of 18 U.S.C. § 924(c)(1), which forbade using or carrying a firearm during and in relation to a drug crime. At Bailey's trial, a government witness testified that drug dealers frequently carry a firearm to protect both the drugs and themselves. There was similar testimony at Robinson's trial. Bailey and Robinson were both convicted of all the charges against them, including the § 924(c) charge. They each appealed their convictions to the District of Columbia Circuit .
A three-judge panel of the court affirmed Bailey's § 924(c) conviction, but another three-judge panel reversed Robinson's. To correct this disparity, the court consolidated both cases and reheard them en banc . It held that "one uses a gun, i.e., avails oneself of a gun, and therefore violates [§ 924(c)(1)], whenever one puts or keeps the gun in a particular place from which one (or one's agent) can gain access to it if and when needed to facilitate a drug crime ." Because in both Bailey's and Robinson's cases the gun was sufficiently accessible and proximate to the drugs that the jury could have concluded that the gun was there to protect the drugs. The Supreme Court agreed to review the case to resolve a split of authority among the federal courts of appeals about the meaning of the word "use" in § 924(c).
Opinion of the Court
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Bailey_v._United_States&action=edit§ion=2 "Edit section: Opinion of the Court")
]
The Supreme Court rejected the interpretation of the D.C. Circuit, and held that "use" of a firearm requires "active employment" of the firearm, "a use that makes the firearm an operative factor in relation to the predicate offense." Context is important because the word "use" has so many meanings—"I use a gun to protect my house, but I've never had to use it." The statute did not impose liability for mere possession, though Congress could easily have done so if it had wanted to.
Accordingly, the D.C. Circuit's mistake stemmed from its defining "use" by "accessibility and proximity," a standard that in practice swept up more than active employment but most instances of mere possession. "In practice, nearly every possession of a firearm by a person engaged in drug trafficking would satisfy the standard." Because Congress did not draft the statute to criminalize mere possession, the D.C. Circuit's gloss ran contrary to Congress's intent. But the language of the statute by itself did not answer the real question at the heart of the case—if use was not the same as mere possession, what else beyond mere possession would the government have to prove to make out a violation of § 924(c)? Webster's Dictionary and Black's Law Dictionary defined "use" as "[t]o convert to one's service," "to employ," "to avail oneself of," and "to carry out a purpose or action by means of." These definitions implied action and implementation. Furthermore, the statute also made it illegal for someone to carry a firearm in relation to a drug crime, and the Court assumed that "carrying" was meant to supply an alternative basis for a § 924(c) charge. By limiting "use" to "active employment," the Court left room for someone to use a firearm without carrying it, as by brandishing the gun or bartering it, and to carry a firearm without using it, as by hiding it in clothing during the transaction.
In Bailey, the Supreme Court was required to clarify the meaning of the disputed statutory term “use” under § 924(c)(1), which imposed a five-year mandatory minimum sentence on a person who “uses or carries a firearm” during a crime of violence or drug trafficking crime.[1] Ultimately, the Court assumed that Congress intended both “use” and “carry” to “have a particular, nonsuperfluous meaning,” and thereby gave “use” a more limited overtone.[2] The unanimous decision narrowed the Court’s previous decision in _Smith v. United States _ in which the majority contended that Congress intended to give the word “use” a “broad meaning,”[3] and accordingly rejected the defense’s argument[4] that the statute was limited to the use of a firearm “as a weapon.”[5]
Defining "use" as "active employment" required the Court to remand the cases for further proceedings. Bailey's gun was in the trunk of his car; there was no evidence that he was actively employing the gun at the time of his arrest. Similarly, Robinson's gun was in a locked footlocker in her bedroom closet. But the court of appeals had not considered whether the "carry" prong supported the convictions, so the Court remanded the case for further proceedings.
Subsequent developments
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Bailey_v._United_States&action=edit§ion=3 "Edit section: Subsequent developments")
]
After Bailey was issued, however, Congress responded by broadening the statute, essentially overruling the Court's decision by statutory amendment. The statute now criminalizes using or carrying a firearm in connection with a drug trafficking offense or crime of violence, as well as the mere possession of a firearm in furtherance of such an offense. This did not affect the Bailey defendants themselves, or any defendant whose "crime" had occurred before Congress amended 18 U.S.C. § 924(c) since the Constitution forbids enactment of ex post facto law . A cascade of sentence reductions and collateral appeals followed the decision, since it effectively held that the conduct to which thousands of defendants had pleaded guilty did not constitute a crime at the time that conduct was undertaken.
References
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Bailey_v._United_States&action=edit§ion=4 "Edit section: References")
]
- ↑ Bailey v. United States, 516 U.S. 137, 138-39 (1995) (quoting 18 U.S.C. § 924(c)(1)). Cited in Brannon, Valerie C. (2018) “Statutory Interpretation: Theories, Tools, and Trends” (CRS Report No. R45153), Congressional Research Service. p.28
- ↑ Bailey v. United States, 516 U.S. 137 (1995). p.146. Cited in Brannon, Valerie C. (2018) “Statutory Interpretation: Theories, Tools, and Trends” (CRS Report No. R45153), Congressional Research Service. p.28
- ↑ Smith v. United States, 508 U.S. 223 (1993). p.246
- ↑ Smith v. United States, 508 U.S. 223 (1993). p.225. Cited in Brannon, Valerie C. (2018) “Statutory Interpretation: Theories, Tools, and Trends”(CRS Report No. R45153), Congressional Research Service. p.23
- ↑ Smith v. United States, 508 U.S. 223 (1993). p.227. Cited in Brannon, Valerie C. (2018) “Statutory Interpretation: Theories, Tools, and Trends”(CRS Report No. R45153), Congressional Research Service. p.23
External links
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Bailey_v._United_States&action=edit§ion=5 "Edit section: External links")
]
- Text of Bailey v. United States, 516 U.S. 137 (1995) is available from: Cornell Findlaw Google Scholar Justia Library of Congress [Oyez (oral argument audio)](https://www.oyez.org/cases/1995/94-74
…
Editorial context from Wikipedia (CC-BY-SA 4.0).
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that the language “use and carry” in § 924(c)(1) requires active employment of a firearm
- holding that the Government must show “active employment” of a gun to prove “use” within the meaning of § 924(e)
- holding that the Government must show “active employment” of a gun to prove “use” within the meaning of § 924(c)
- holding that “ ‘use’ must connote more than mere possession of a firearm by a person who commits a drug offense”
- recognizing that sentencing guidelines may provide enhancements for mere possession of a firearm during other offenses
- holding that a firearm must be actively employed to satisfy the \use\ prong of § 924(c)(1)
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: O'Connor
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
2,097 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Bousley v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1998-05-18· cited 5,336×
- Johnson v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2010-03-02· cited 1,738×
- Tannenbaum v. United StatesEleventh Circuit· 1998-08-04· cited 1,700×
- Williams v. TaylorSupreme Court· 2000-04-18· cited 1,620×
- Welch v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2016-04-18· cited 1,417×
- Leocal v. AshcroftSupreme Court· 2004-11-09· cited 1,254×
- United States v. BestfoodsSupreme Court· 1998-06-08· cited 1,059×
- In Re Ocsulis DorsainvilThird Circuit· 1997-08-15· cited 1,045×
- Jose Evaristo Reyes-Requena v. United StatesFifth Circuit· 2001-02-28· cited 948×
- Muscarello v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1998-06-08· cited 848×
- Uchenna H. Okereke v. United States of America. United States of America v. Uchenna H. OkerekeThird Circuit· 2002-09-12· cited 795×
- Melencio Legui Lim v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceNinth Circuit· 2000-08-29· cited 762×
- Home Depot U. S. A., Inc. v. JacksonSupreme Court· 2019-05-28· cited 714×
- TGS-NOPEC GEOPHYSICAL CO. v. CombsTexas Supreme Court· 2011-05-27· cited 659×
- McCain v. StateCourt of Criminal Appeals of Texas· 2000-03-22· cited 634×
- Jones v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2000-05-22· cited 626×
- In Re James Davenport and Sherman NicholsSeventh Circuit· 1998-06-18· cited 613×
- Monge v. CaliforniaSupreme Court· 1998-06-26· cited 610×
- United States v. JohnsonSupreme Court· 2000-03-21· cited 600×
- United States v. WellsSupreme Court· 1997-02-26· cited 565×
Cites
15 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- United Sav. Assn. of Tex. v. Timbers of Inwood Forest Associates, Ltd.Supreme Court· 1988-01-20· cited 1,871×
- Smith v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1993-08-09· cited 1,468×
- Ratzlaf v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1994-01-11· cited 1,218×
- Brown v. GardnerSupreme Court· 1994-12-12· cited 1,044×
- King v. St. Vincent's HospitalSupreme Court· 1991-12-16· cited 703×
- Platt v. Union Pacific RailroadSupreme Court· 1879-04-21· cited 197×
- United States v. TheodoropoulosThird Circuit· 1989-01-17· cited 177×
- United States v. Jorge Feliz-Cordero and Alexander Feliz-EncarnacionSecond Circuit· 1988-10-11· cited 151×
- United States v. Robert Lee HagerTenth Circuit· 1992-07-07· cited 122×
- United States v. Ernest Michael WilsonFifth Circuit· 1989-09-07· cited 121×
- United States v. Ramon Castro-Lara, United States of America v. Abraham Objio SarraffFirst Circuit· 1992-07-29· cited 99×
- United States v. Roland J. Bailey, United States of America v. Candisha Summerita Robinson A/K/A Candysha RobinsonD.C. Circuit· 1994-10-04· cited 64×
- United States v. McFaddenFirst Circuit· 1994-01-19· cited 51×
- United States v. Candisha S. RobinsonD.C. Circuit· 1993-10-08· cited 13×
- United States v. Roland J. BaileyD.C. Circuit· 1993-10-08· cited 9×
Other cases named Bailey v. United States
244 other CourtListener records share this case name; the 50 most cited are listed.
- Bailey v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2013-02-19· cited 390×
- Bailey v. United StatesD.C. Circuit· 1967-12-14· cited 180×
- Bailey v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1983-01-10· cited 105×
- Bailey v. United StatesTenth Circuit· 1969-05-16· cited 70×
- Bailey v. United StatesNinth Circuit· 1981-04-20· cited 63×
- Bailey v. United StatesTenth Circuit· 1934-11-30· cited 44×
- Bailey v. United StatesNinth Circuit· 2010-09-29· cited 38×
- Bailey v. United StatesFifth Circuit· 2007-11-26· cited 37×
- Bailey v. United StatesFifth Circuit· 1925-03-11· cited 32×
- Bailey v. United StatesDistrict of Columbia Court of Appeals· 1971-07-14· cited 32×
- Bailey v. United StatesCourt of Claims· 1983-01-13· cited 23×
- Bailey v. United StatesDistrict of Columbia Court of Appeals· 2003-09-18· cited 22×
- Bailey v. United StatesSixth Circuit· 1919-02-05· cited 21×
- Bailey v. United StatesFederal Claims· 2002-11-21· cited 20×
- Bailey v. United StatesFederal Circuit· 2003-08-27· cited 20×
- Bailey v. United StatesDistrict of Columbia Court of Appeals· 2010-12-30· cited 19×
- Bailey v. United StatesCourt of Claims· 1959-01-14· cited 17×
- Bailey v. United StatesD.C. Circuit· 1938-05-23· cited 16×
- Bailey v. United StatesNinth Circuit· 1926-06-07· cited 16×
- Bailey v. United StatesDistrict of Columbia Court of Appeals· 1982-07-28· cited 15×
- Bailey v. United StatesCourt of Claims· 1956-03-06· cited 15×
- Bailey v. United StatesFifth Circuit· 1931-12-03· cited 14×
- Bailey v. United StatesCourt of Claims· 1940-03-04· cited 14×
- Bailey v. United StatesFederal Claims· 2002-03-13· cited 14×
- Bailey v. United StatesFederal Claims· 2007-08-10· cited 13×
- Bailey v. United StatesCourt of Claims· 1939-05-29· cited 12×
- Bailey v. United StatesFederal Claims· 2000-01-21· cited 12×
- Bailey v. United StatesSeventh Circuit· 1922-08-11· cited 12×
- Bailey v. United StatesDistrict of Columbia Court of Appeals· 1997-08-14· cited 11×
- Bailey v. United StatesN.D. Ohio· 2015-07-27· cited 10×
- Bailey v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2014-12-01· cited 9×
- Bailey v. United StatesCourt of Claims· 1926-04-19· cited 9×
- Bailey v. United StatesCourt of Claims· 1975-02-19· cited 9×
- Bailey v. United StatesFederal Claims· 1998-02-10· cited 8×
- Bailey v. United StatesFederal Claims· 2002-08-14· cited 8×
- Bailey v. United StatesFifth Circuit· 1937-11-05· cited 8×
- Bailey v. United StatesDistrict of Columbia Court of Appeals· 1978-04-05· cited 6×
- Bailey v. United StatesSixth Circuit· 1922-03-17· cited 6×
- Bailey v. United StatesFederal Circuit· 2003-08-27· cited 5×
- Bailey v. United StatesCourt of Claims· 1939-12-04· cited 5×
- Bailey v. United StatesD. New Jersey· 1976-06-23· cited 5×
- Bailey v. United StatesFederal Circuit· 2004-02-27· cited 5×
- Bailey v. United StatesE.D. Virginia· 1966-11-01· cited 5×
- Bailey v. United StatesD. Hawaii· 2003-10-10· cited 4×
- Bailey v. United StatesCourt of Claims· 1952-06-03· cited 4×
- Bailey v. United StatesD. Arizona· 1996-04-11· cited 3×
- Bailey v. United StatesDistrict of Columbia Court of Appeals· 1988-07-21· cited 3×
- Bailey v. United StatesEighth Circuit· 1933-04-01· cited 3×
- Bailey v. United StatesD. Alaska· 1962-02-09· cited 3×
- Bailey v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1981-10-05· cited 3×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.