Wabash Railroad v. Hayes
Citations
- 234 U.S. 86
- 34 S. Ct. 729
- 58 L. Ed. 1226
- 1914 U.S. LEXIS 1191
Syllabus
<p>Plaintiff, an injured employé of an interstate common carrier by rail, sued for personal injury, alleging that he was employed in interstate commerce, and stating a good cause of action under the Federal Employers’ Liability Act, if so employed, and, if not, under the state law; the defendant asked for an instruction that the proof did not show that the injury occurred in interstate commerce, which the court gave, and then, over defendant’s objection, treated the allegation to that effect as eliminated from the declaration and submitted the case to the jury as one under the state law, and plaintiff had a Verdict. Held, that defendant having asked for the instruction that the case could not be maintained under the Federal act, was bound thereby, and, therefore, was denied no right under the Federal law by the action of the state court, and the writ of error must be dismissed.</p> <p>Where the state court treats a mistaken allegation that the injury occurred in interstate commerce as eliminated, it merely gives effect to a rule of local practice and does not deprive defendant of any Federal right.</p> <p>Queere, as to what the effect would be if the shift from a claim under the Federal act to one under the state law cut the defendant off from presenting a defense open under the latter or deprived him of a right of removal.</p>
Judges: Van Devanter
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
55 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Baltimore Steamship Co. v. PhillipsSupreme Court· 1927-05-16· cited 618×
- New York Central Railroad Company v. WinfieldSupreme Court· 1916-03-01· cited 344×
- Lane v. R.A. Sims, Jr., Inc.Fifth Circuit· 2001-02-06· cited 80×
- Earwood v. Norfolk Southern Railway Co.N.D. Georgia· 1993-12-06· cited 60×
- Corbett v. Boston & Maine RailroadMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1914-11-24· cited 60×
- Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific Railway Co. v. WrightSupreme Court· 1916-01-10· cited 59×
- Rivera v. Union Pacific RailroadFifth Circuit· 2004-08-04· cited 53×
- Armburg v. Boston & Maine RailroadMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1931-09-10· cited 46×
- Chesapeake & Ohio Railway Co. v. StapletonSupreme Court· 1929-05-27· cited 45×
- Dennison v. PayneSecond Circuit· 1923-06-20· cited 42×
- Staley v. Illinois Central RailroadIllinois Supreme Court· 1915-06-24· cited 40×
- Campbell v. BNSF Railway Co.Sixth Circuit· 2010-04-09· cited 36×
- Kansas City Western Railway Co. v. McAdowSupreme Court· 1916-01-31· cited 35×
- Louisville & Nashville Railroad v. Jolly's AdministratrixCourt of Appeals of Kentucky (pre-1976)· 1930-01-14· cited 30×
- Strother v. Union Pac. R.W.D. Missouri· 1915-03-01· cited 24×
- Myers v. Illinois Central RailroadAppellate Court of Illinois· 2001-07-19· cited 20×
- Cincinnati, New Orleans & Texas Pacific Railway Co. v. TuckerCourt of Appeals of Kentucky· 1916-01-27· cited 19×
- Illinois Central Railroad v. KellyCourt of Appeals of Kentucky· 1916-01-14· cited 17×
- Basham v. Chicago Great Western Railway Co.Supreme Court of Iowa· 1915-11-26· cited 16×
- Reidelbach v. Burlington Northern & Santa Fe Railway Co.Montana Supreme Court· 2002-12-10· cited 12×
Cites
6 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Seaboard Air Line Railway v. HortonSupreme Court· 1914-04-27· cited 737×
- North Carolina Railroad v. ZacharySupreme Court· 1914-02-02· cited 366×
- Illinois Central Railroad v. BehrensSupreme Court· 1914-04-27· cited 321×
- St. Louis, San Francisco & Texas Railway Co. v. SealeSupreme Court· 1913-05-26· cited 289×
- Sawyer v. PiperSupreme Court· 1903-04-27· cited 9×
- Hayes v. ComPanyAppellate Court of Illinois· 1913-05-26· cited 4×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.