Vieth v. Jubelirer
Citations
- 541 U.S. 267
- 124 S. Ct. 1769
- 158 L. Ed. 2d 546
- 2004 U.S. LEXIS 3233
About this case
Vieth v. Jubelirer
Vieth v. Jubelirer, 541 U.S. 267 (2004), was a United States Supreme Court ruling that was significant in the area of partisan redistricting and political gerrymandering . The court, in a plurality opinion by Justice Antonin Scalia and joined by Chief Justice William Rehnquist and Justices Sandra Day O'Connor and Clarence Thomas , with Justice Anthony Kennedy concurring in the judgment, upheld the ruling of the District Court in favor of the appellees that the alleged political gerrymandering was not unconstitutional. Subsequent to the ruling, partisan bias in redistricting increased dramatically in the 2010 redistricting round.[1]
Contents
Background
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Vieth_v._Jubelirer&action=edit§ion=1 "Edit section: Background")
The plaintiff-appellants in this case were Norma Jean, Richard Vieth, and Susan Furey, Democrats registered to vote in the state of Pennsylvania . They contended that the Republican -controlled Pennsylvania General Assembly had unconstitutionally gerrymandered the districts for the election of congressional representatives . This, the plaintiffs claimed, denied Democrats full participation in the American political process by violating the one-person one-vote requirement of Article I of the United States Constitution , and denied Democrats equal protection of the laws under the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution .
The 2000 census determined that Pennsylvania was entitled to 19 Representatives in the United States Congress (two fewer than the previous delegation) and congressional election districts therefore had to be redrawn consistent with previous Supreme Court rulings. At the time the election districts were being drawn, the Republican Party controlled both houses of the Pennsylvania legislature as well as the Governor 's office. According to the plaintiffs, prominent Republicans in the national party put pressure on the Assembly to redistrict along partisan lines "as a punitive measure against Democrats for having enacted pro-Democratic redistricting plans elsewhere" and to benefit the party in congressional elections in Pennsylvania.
Legal arguments
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Vieth_v._Jubelirer&action=edit§ion=2 "Edit section: Legal arguments")
The Court considered the following three major questions in relation to the appeal:[2]
- Can voters affiliated with a political party sue to block implementation of a Congressional redistricting plan by claiming that it was manipulated for purely political reasons?
- Does a state violate the Equal Protection clause of the 14th Amendment when it disregards neutral redistricting principles (such as trying to avoid splitting municipalities into different Congressional districts) in order to achieve an advantage for one political party?
- Does a state exceed its power under Article I of the Constitution when it draws Congressional districts to ensure that a minority party will consistently win a super-majority of the state's Congressional seats?
Plaintiff's argument
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Vieth_v._Jubelirer&action=edit§ion=3 "Edit section: Plaintiff's argument")
Paul M. Smith represented the plaintiffs before the Supreme Court, arguing that "lower courts [have] effectively overruled [Davis v.] Bandemer" .[3] Smith contended that the District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania misapplied Bandemer by requiring evidence of voter suppression to the extent of proving complete disenfranchisement "or that your party has effectively been banned". He argued that if partisan gerrymandering was justiciable, as Bandemer held, a requirement to establish these independent constitutional violations would not make sense. The plaintiff's proposed standard, that one must be able to demonstrate with a congressional map that it would be impossible to get more than half the congressional seats with less than half the votes, came under heavy scrutiny for its supposed inapplicability.
The plaintiff also struggled to convince the Court that one could use prior voting records to decide the electoral outcome of a new redistricting scheme. Both Justice Scalia and Justice Breyer wondered how accurately this would be able to predict outcomes in future elections. Scalia stated the following:
Race does not change. You [..] are the race you are, and you're not going to change it next year. Political party doesn't work that way. How [...] do you decide what is the Republican vote? Is it just registered Republicans and is everybody that's registered a Republican now have to stay [...] I just don't understand how you run this scheme? You cannot really tell until after the election is done how many Republicans and how many Democrats there are in each district.[2]
Smith justified this by emphasizing that future cases contending electoral maps would leave the burden of proof on the plaintiffs to prove that the districting scheme was unfair. The Court also questioned how districts could be redrawn to be fair even if a court were able to find a standard by which an electoral map could be struck down.
Defense's argument
(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Vieth_v._Jubelirer&action=edit§ion=4 "Edit section: Defense's argument")
John P. Krill, Jr. of K&L Gates represented Robert Jubelirer and John Perzel at the Supreme Court. The defense's argument rested on the claim that redistricting "requires inherent political choices to be made [which] are inappropriate for the judiciary to make"[2] under the political question doctrine . This rather extreme position posited that even if the entire legislature came forward and admitted to political gerrymandering, it would not be the place of the judiciary to strike down the redistricting. The crux of this argument is that there is no constitutional requirement to draw districts impartially with regards to political party.
Furthermore, the defense took the ruling and successive elections regarding Indiana's contested electoral map in Bandemer to be instructive. Krill cites that Democrats, who were supposedly heavily gerrymandered against, won 50% of House seats from Indiana, and successively won control the following election. He also challenged the plaintiff's test used in the complaint as broken as it uses 10 years of election data, counting voters who could have died, moved, or otherwise not become involved in future elections. He also contends that the plaintiff's test assumes Democrats are evenly dispersed across the state when they are normally compacted into urban areas instead.
J. Bart DeLone from the Pennsylvania's Attorney General's Office represented Pedro Cortés and Monna Accurti (Commissioner of the Bureau of Commissions, Legislation and Elections) at the Supreme Court. He argued that even if the Court holds political gerrymandering justiciable, a districting scheme could only be found unconstitutional if "the disadvantaged group has been shut out of a political process as a whole."[2] He also contends that Krill's claim that there is nothing wrong with judicial intent to gerrymander an electoral map
…
Editorial context from Wikipedia (CC-BY-SA 4.0).
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- concluding that political gerrymandering eases are nonjusticiable because no judicially discernible and manageable standards for adjudicating such claims now exist
- noting that Baker set forth “six independent tests for the existence of a political question”
- noting that the Baker factors “are probably listed in descending order of both importance and certainty”
- noting that separation of powers between the three branches of government prevents the giving of advisory opinions
- noting that these two tests were listed first and stating that the six tests in Baker v. Carr were \probably listed in descending order of both importance and certainty\
- noting that these two tests were listed first and stating that the six tests in Baker v. Carr were “probably listed in descending order of both importance and certainty”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Scalia, Kennedy, Stevens, Souter, Breyer, Ginsburg
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
250 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Alleyne v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2013-06-17· cited 5,868×
- Arizona v. GantSupreme Court· 2009-04-21· cited 2,725×
- Bartlett v. StricklandSupreme Court· 2009-03-09· cited 2,505×
- Citizens United v. Federal Election CommissionSupreme Court· 2010-01-21· cited 1,732×
- Caperton v. A. T. Massey Coal Co., Inc.Supreme Court· 2009-06-08· cited 1,119×
- Johnson v. CaliforniaSupreme Court· 2005-02-23· cited 577×
- Lane v. HalliburtonFifth Circuit· 2008-05-28· cited 480×
- Doe v. ReedSupreme Court· 2010-06-24· cited 410×
- Gill v. WhitfordSupreme Court· 2018-06-18· cited 372×
- Heller v. District of ColumbiaD.C. Circuit· 2011-10-04· cited 321×
- League of United Latin American Citizens v. PerrySupreme Court· 2006-06-28· cited 297×
- Initiative & Referendum Institute v. WalkerTenth Circuit· 2006-05-17· cited 289×
- Zivotofsky Ex Rel. Zivotofsky v. ClintonSupreme Court· 2012-03-26· cited 264×
- Cooper v. HarrisSupreme Court· 2017-05-22· cited 259×
- Randall v. SorrellSupreme Court· 2006-06-26· cited 254×
- Clingman v. BeaverSupreme Court· 2005-05-23· cited 242×
- Rucho v. Common CauseSupreme Court· 2019-06-27· cited 237×
- Gannon v. StateSupreme Court of Kansas· 2014-03-07· cited 235×
- Jesus Gonzalez v. State of ArizonaNinth Circuit· 2012-04-17· cited 226×
- Lobato v. StateSupreme Court of Colorado· 2009-10-19· cited 214×
Cites
92 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- McDonnell Douglas Corp. v. GreenSupreme Court· 1973-05-14· cited 38,518×
- Lujan v. Defenders of WildlifeSupreme Court· 1992-06-12· cited 24,791×
- City of Cleburne v. Cleburne Living Center, Inc.Supreme Court· 1985-07-01· cited 7,112×
- Baker v. CarrSupreme Court· 1962-03-26· cited 6,173×
- Allen v. WrightSupreme Court· 1984-09-18· cited 4,763×
- Valley Forge Christian College v. Americans United for Separation of Church and State, Inc.Supreme Court· 1982-01-12· cited 4,651×
- Elrod v. BurnsSupreme Court· 1976-06-28· cited 4,553×
- Reynolds v. SimsSupreme Court· 1964-10-12· cited 3,703×
- Payne v. TennesseeSupreme Court· 1991-09-13· cited 3,458×
- Washington v. DavisSupreme Court· 1976-06-07· cited 3,450×
- Board of Trustees of Univ. of Ala. v. GarrettSupreme Court· 2001-02-21· cited 2,166×
- Republican Party of North Carolina v. MartinFourth Circuit· 1992-11-24· cited 1,890×
- Branti v. FinkelSupreme Court· 1980-03-31· cited 1,881×
- Anderson v. CelebrezzeSupreme Court· 1983-04-19· cited 1,828×
- Police Dept. of Chicago v. MosleySupreme Court· 1972-06-26· cited 1,516×
- Romer v. EvansSupreme Court· 1996-06-03· cited 1,427×
- Lehr v. RobertsonSupreme Court· 1983-06-27· cited 1,333×
- United States Civil Service Commission v. National Ass'n of Letter CarriersSupreme Court· 1973-06-25· cited 1,290×
- Rutan v. Republican Party of IllinoisSupreme Court· 1990-08-30· cited 1,236×
- Thornburg v. GinglesSupreme Court· 1986-06-30· cited 1,221×
Other cases named Vieth v. Jubelirer
2 other CourtListener records share this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.