Seventh Circuit· 4/14/2004
Ujjaval B. Dave v. John D. Ashcroft
Citations
- 363 F.3d 649
- 2004 U.S. App. LEXIS 7209
- 2004 WL 787242
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that “in immigration proceedings, a petitioner has no liberty or property interest in obtaining purely discre- tionary relief . . . and the denial of such relief therefore cannot implicate due process”
- “[I]n immigration proceedings, a petitioner has no liberty or property interest in ■obtaining purely discretionary relief[.]”
- deny- ing alien’s petition for review of removal order where alien was convicted of reckless discharge of a firearm
- con- cluding that, even if the petitioner had asserted properly a denial of due process under the Fifth Amendment, § 1252(a)(2) (B)(i
- “[T]he decision when to commence deportation proceedings is within the discretion of the Attorney General and does not, therefore, involve a protected property or liberty interest.”
- “[W]e may not decide a case without subject matter jurisdiction and thus neither the parties nor their lawyers may . . . waive arguments that the court lacks jurisdiction.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Kanne, Rovner, Williams
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
47 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Jose Cruz v. Attorney General of the United StatesThird Circuit· 2006-06-21· cited 188×
- Bassel Nabih Assaad v. John Ashcroft, U.S. Attorney GeneralFifth Circuit· 2004-07-19· cited 180×
- Infanzon v. AshcroftTenth Circuit· 2004-10-28· cited 178×
- Mohammed Subhan v. John D. Ashcroft, Attorney General of the United StatesSeventh Circuit· 2004-10-26· cited 146×
- Guzman v. United States Department of Homeland SecuritySixth Circuit· 2012-05-10· cited 110×
- Zamora-Mallari v. MukaseySeventh Circuit· 2008-01-24· cited 105×
- Arambula-Medina v. HolderTenth Circuit· 2009-07-10· cited 76×
- Kenneth Durant v. United States Immigration and Naturalization ServiceSecond Circuit· 2004-12-16· cited 71×
- Dexia Credit Local v. RoganSeventh Circuit· 2010-04-26· cited 69×
- Husam F. Hamdan v. Alberto Gonzales, 1 United States Attorney GeneralSeventh Circuit· 2005-10-13· cited 59×
- Maria Del Consuelo Cevilla v. Alberto R. GonzalesSeventh Circuit· 2006-05-01· cited 57×
- Ricardo Calma v. Eric Holder, Jr.Seventh Circuit· 2011-12-05· cited 52×
- Khan v. MukaseySeventh Circuit· 2008-02-25· cited 51×
- Jose Martinez-Maldonado v. Alberto R. Gonzales, United States Attorney GeneralSeventh Circuit· 2006-02-10· cited 50×
- Galeano-Romero v. BarrTenth Circuit· 2020-08-04· cited 47×
- Robert Bronisz v. John D. Ashcroft, United States Attorney GeneralSeventh Circuit· 2004-08-05· cited 46×
- Salgado-Toribio v. HolderTenth Circuit· 2013-04-23· cited 45×
- Mirwais Ali v. John D. Ashcroft, Attorney General of the United States, 1Seventh Circuit· 2005-01-11· cited 42×
- Srinivasa Musunuru v. Loretta E. LynchSeventh Circuit· 2016-08-03· cited 26×
- Jimenez-Gonzalez v. MukaseySeventh Circuit· 2008-11-21· cited 22×
Cites
38 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Reno v. FloresSupreme Court· 1993-03-23· cited 2,046×
- LOZADABoard of Immigration Appeals· 1988-07-01· cited 1,900×
- Oscar Rojas-Garcia v. John Ashcroft, Attorney General Immigration and Naturalization Service Robert S. Coleman, Jr.Ninth Circuit· 2003-07-29· cited 443×
- Virginia Ragon Achacoso-Sanchez v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceSeventh Circuit· 1985-12-13· cited 365×
- MARINBoard of Immigration Appeals· 1978-07-01· cited 360×
- Julio Lozada v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceFirst Circuit· 1988-09-14· cited 277×
- Nabil Raja Dandan, Ketty Dandan, Souzi Dandan, A.K.A. Souzy Dandan, Sandra Dandan, and Raja Nabil Dandan v. John Ashcroft, Attorney GeneralSeventh Circuit· 2003-08-11· cited 229×
- Gary Laguerre v. Janet Reno, Jose, Martin Avelar-Cruz v. Janet RenoSeventh Circuit· 1999-04-09· cited 220×
- Carlos Huicochea-Gomez and Margot Huicochea-Reza v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceSixth Circuit· 2001-01-02· cited 215×
- Mejia Rodriguez v. RenoEleventh Circuit· 1999-06-22· cited 169×
- Patel v. U.S. Attorney GeneralEleventh Circuit· 2003-06-27· cited 142×
- Ricardo Lara-Ruiz v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceSeventh Circuit· 2001-03-06· cited 123×
- EDWARDSBoard of Immigration Appeals· 1990-07-01· cited 112×
- Nehme v. Immigration & Naturalization ServiceFifth Circuit· 2001-06-05· cited 105×
- Aguilera v. KirkpatrickTenth Circuit· 2001-03-07· cited 100×
- Leszek Hughes, A.K.A. Thomas Lloyd Hughes, A.K.A. Tom v. John Ashcroft, Attorney GeneralNinth Circuit· 2001-06-22· cited 95×
- Coralia Patricia Garcia v. Attorney General of the United States, Immigration and Naturalization ServiceEleventh Circuit· 2003-03-13· cited 90×
- Philomena Iweka Nwaokolo v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceSeventh Circuit· 2002-12-27· cited 86×
- United States v. Anton TittjungSeventh Circuit· 2000-12-15· cited 84×
- Samuel Appiah v. U.S. Immigration & Naturalization ServiceFourth Circuit· 2000-01-20· cited 83×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.