Stuart v. State

How courts have described this case

Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.

• holding the district court’s conclusion was clearly erroneous and remanding to the district court with instructions to weigh the evidence a second time
• “[C]oncealment is one method of proving that the exculpatory value of the evidence was known to the government prior to its destruction.”

Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).

Cited by

35 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.

• DeRushé v. State
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2009-01-22· cited 372×
• Ex Parte Napper
  Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas· 2010-09-29· cited 207×
• McCarty v. Gilchrist
  Tenth Circuit· 2011-07-14· cited 118×
• State v. Azad Haji Abdullah
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2015-03-02· cited 106×
• State v. Hawkins
  Idaho Court of Appeals· 1998-04-13· cited 75×
• Stuart v. State
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2010-05-10· cited 44×
• Stuart v. State
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2001-12-04· cited 39×
• Bromley v. Garey
  Idaho Supreme Court· 1999-05-26· cited 35×
• Rome v. State
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2018-11-29· cited 25×
• State v. Ish
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2020-04-13· cited 24×
• State v. Dopp
  Idaho Court of Appeals· 1996-12-04· cited 23×
• Baker v. Boren
  Idaho Court of Appeals· 1997-03-21· cited 15×
• Randy L. McKinney v. State
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2017-06-20· cited 15×
• Garcia v. STATE TAX COM'N OF STATE OF ID
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2002-01-09· cited 14×
• Curtis v. Becker
  Idaho Court of Appeals· 1997-06-13· cited 13×
• Whiteley v. State
  Idaho Supreme Court· 1998-04-02· cited 13×
• State v. Wright
  Idaho Supreme Court· 2000-02-25· cited 12×
• State v. Wade Lamonte Peterson
  Idaho Court of Appeals· 2012-05-21· cited 8×
• Stuart v. State
  Idaho Supreme Court· 1996-02-15· cited 8×
• Woodward v. State
  Idaho Court of Appeals· 2005-07-18· cited 8×

Cites

11 cases in this archive are cited by this case.

• Brady v. Maryland
  Supreme Court· 1963-05-13· cited 33,902×
• United States v. Bagley
  Supreme Court· 1985-07-02· cited 8,539×
• California v. Trombetta
  Supreme Court· 1984-06-11· cited 3,405×
• Arizona v. Youngblood
  Supreme Court· 1989-01-23· cited 3,366×
• Stuart v. State
  Idaho Supreme Court· 1990-10-16· cited 262×
• Paradis v. State
  Idaho Supreme Court· 1986-03-25· cited 111×
• Stuart v. State
  Idaho Supreme Court· 1990-11-28· cited 111×
• State v. Stuart
  Idaho Supreme Court· 1986-02-20· cited 80×
• United States v. Wayne R. Cooper and Vincent Gammill
  Ninth Circuit· 1993-01-08· cited 77×
• Pace v. Hymas
  Idaho Supreme Court· 1986-10-28· cited 32×
• State v. Dulaney
  Supreme Court of Iowa· 1992-12-23· cited 27×