State v. Prudhomme
Citations
- 210 Conn. App. 176
Syllabus
Convicted of the crimes of assault in the first degree, cruelty to persons and tampering with physical evidence, the defendant appealed to this court. He claimed that the trial court's jury instructions deprived him of his right to due process and a fair trial because they could have misled the jurors into thinking they could not consider inadequacies in the police investigation in evaluating whether the state had proved him guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. The complainant, L, and the defendant shared an apartment. After they returned to the apartment with M, the defendant's girlfriend, in the early morning hours after visiting a club, L told the defendant that he had twice slept with M. In the early evening of that same day, the defendant found L passed out in his room, covered in vomit and urine, with a red ring around his neck. The defendant told the 911 dispatcher that L had attempted suicide. The police found L on the floor of his bedroom. Although the police searched the apartment for anything that could have caused the red marks on L's neck, they did not enter or search the defendant's separate bedroom. One of the police officers who searched the apartment, relying in part on the defen- dant's statements, believed that L had attempted suicide and sought to have him seen by a psychologist after L was taken to a hospital. After L's mother reported to the police that, when L had awoken from a coma he was in at the hospital, he told her that the defendant had attempted to strangle him, the police interviewed the defendant, who changed his story and told them for the first time both that he had a form of autism and that L had told him about having had sex with M. The defendant's theory of defense was that the police conducted an inadequate investiga- tion in that, inter alia, they failed to sufficiently document the injuries to L's neck, they failed to interview L or his mother about the allegation that the defendant strangled him, they failed to analyze certain
Judges: Moll; Clark; Sheldon
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCites
21 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Crawford v. WashingtonSupreme Court· 2004-03-08· cited 14,756×
- State v. SharpeSupreme Court of Connecticut· 1985-04-16· cited 175×
- State v. WilliamsSupreme Court of Connecticut· 1975-08-05· cited 123×
- State v. SmithSupreme Court of Connecticut· 2008-11-25· cited 99×
- State v. BrownSupreme Court of Connecticut· 2006-08-15· cited 90×
- Shirley M. Critchlow v. First Unum Life Insurance Company of AmericaFirst Circuit· 2004-08-09· cited 89×
- State v. EspositoSupreme Court of Connecticut· 1992-08-04· cited 74×
- State v. CarpenterSupreme Court of Connecticut· 2005-10-11· cited 73×
- State v. AliSupreme Court of Connecticut· 1995-06-06· cited 72×
- Ellis v. EmeryNinth Circuit· 2006-03-20· cited 63×
- State v. CollinsSupreme Court of Connecticut· 2011-01-05· cited 62×
- River Dock & Pile, Inc. v. O & G Industries, Inc.Supreme Court of Connecticut· 1991-07-30· cited 56×
- State v. SimpsonSupreme Court of Connecticut· 2008-04-29· cited 55×
- Webster Bank v. FlanaganConnecticut Appellate Court· 1999-02-16· cited 46×
- State v. AvilesSupreme Court of Connecticut· 2006-02-21· cited 39×
- Connecticut Bank & Trust Co., N.A. v. ReckertConnecticut Appellate Court· 1994-03-08· cited 31×
- State v. WilliamsConnecticut Appellate Court· 1998-04-07· cited 22×
- State v. LahaiConnecticut Appellate Court· 2011-05-10· cited 10×
- State of Connecticut v. WrightConnecticut Appellate Court· 2014-04-29· cited 8×
- Bell v. Commissioner of CorrectionConnecticut Appellate Court· 2018-08-07· cited 7×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.