Supreme Court of New Hampshire· 12/29/1989
State v. Elwell
Citations
- 132 N.H. 599
- 567 A.2d 1002
- 1989 N.H. LEXIS 139
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that “[a] criminal defendant does not put his medical condition at issue simply by proclaiming his innocence”
- privilege prevented use of evidence obtained from driver’s blood sample in prosecution for negligent homicide
- disclosure in drunk driving setting may be essential if defendant was seriously injured and transported to hospital without police having adequate opportunity to obtain essential evidence of defendant’s intoxication
- litigant did not place condition at issue by pleading not guilty
- although “the physician-patient privilege is not absolute and will yield when the disclosure of information is essential,” where other sources of information are available, the effective enforcement of drunk driving laws, though compelling, is not grounds for piercing the privilege
- “A criminal defendant does not put his medical condition at issue simply by proclaiming his innocence. To hold otherwise would allow the State to defeat the physician-patient privilege simply by accusing a defendant of a crime. We do not-believe the legislature intended that result.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Brock
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
25 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- State v. CresseySupreme Court of New Hampshire· 1993-07-15· cited 94×
- State v. LaurieSupreme Court of New Hampshire· 1995-01-20· cited 54×
- State v. WilsonCourt of Appeals of Arizona· 2001-06-18· cited 32×
- State v. RoperNew Mexico Court of Appeals· 1996-06-19· cited 30×
- State v. ChamberlainSupreme Court of New Hampshire· 1993-07-15· cited 27×
- Desclos v. Southern New Hampshire Medical CenterSupreme Court of New Hampshire· 2006-06-09· cited 27×
- State v. SchreiberSupreme Court of New Jersey· 1991-02-11· cited 23×
- State v. FamigliettiDistrict Court of Appeal of Florida· 2002-05-08· cited 19×
- State v. FournierSupreme Court of New Hampshire· 2009-01-08· cited 12×
- State v. BarkaSupreme Court of New Hampshire· 2004-01-06· cited 12×
- In re Search Warrant for Medical Records of C.T.Supreme Court of New Hampshire· 2010-05-06· cited 12×
- State v. HenneberrySupreme Court of Iowa· 1997-01-22· cited 11×
- State v. SummersSupreme Court of New Hampshire· 1997-11-19· cited 10×
- State v. MacDonaldSupreme Court of New Hampshire· 2011-05-17· cited 10×
- State v. SmithCourt of Appeals of Washington· 1997-01-27· cited 9×
- State v. AllisonSupreme Court of New Hampshire· 1991-07-31· cited 9×
- State v. EnoSupreme Court of New Hampshire· 1999-04-08· cited 9×
- State v. DavisSupreme Court of New Hampshire· 2010-12-17· cited 9×
- State v. MosesHawaii Intermediate Court of Appeals· 2002-11-29· cited 8×
- State v. FavreauSupreme Court of New Hampshire· 1991-06-12· cited 8×
Cites
10 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- McGranahan v. DaharSupreme Court of New Hampshire· 1979-10-24· cited 85×
- State v. RuelkeSupreme Court of New Hampshire· 1976-11-30· cited 52×
- Nelson v. LewisSupreme Court of New Hampshire· 1987-11-09· cited 41×
- Riddle Spring Realty Co. v. StateSupreme Court of New Hampshire· 1966-06-30· cited 27×
- In Re Brenda H.Supreme Court of New Hampshire· 1979-05-23· cited 23×
- State v. KupchunSupreme Court of New Hampshire· 1977-05-27· cited 19×
- Theresa S. v. Superintendent of Youth Development CenterSupreme Court of New Hampshire· 1985-02-08· cited 17×
- State v. GodingSupreme Court of New Hampshire· 1985-02-07· cited 14×
- In re Kathleen M.Supreme Court of New Hampshire· 1985-04-18· cited 10×
- State v. HartSupreme Court of New Hampshire· 1988-03-10· cited 9×
Other cases named State v. Elwell
16 other CourtListener records share this case name.
- State v. ElwellSupreme Court of South Carolina· 2013-05-29· cited 23×
- State v. ElwellSupreme Judicial Court of Maine· 1977-12-09· cited 21×
- State v. ElwellOregon Supreme Court· 1922-10-10· cited 14×
- State v. ElwellSupreme Court of Vermont· 1973-04-03· cited 13×
- State v. ElwellCourt of Appeals of South Carolina· 2011-11-23· cited 8×
- State v. ElwellSupreme Judicial Court of Maine· 1960-06-24· cited 7×
- State v. ElwellSupreme Judicial Court of Maine· 2002-04-10· cited 6×
- State v. ElwellWashington Supreme Court· 2022-03-03· cited 4×
- State v. ElwellCourt of Appeals of Washington· 2004-08-09
- State v. ElwellOhio Supreme Court· 2007-11-20
- State v. ElwellOhio Supreme Court· 2008-01-24
- State v. ElwellOhio Supreme Court· 2008-04-23
- State v. ElwellCourt of Appeals of Washington· 1989-06-14
- State v. ElwellSupreme Court of New Jersey· 1976-09-23
- State v. ElwellSupreme Court of New Jersey· 1988-09-07
- State v. ElwellNevada Supreme Court· 1957-07-23
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.