D.C. Circuit· 9/30/1988
Spagnola v. Mathis
Citations
- 273 U.S. App. D.C. 247
- 859 F.2d 223
- 1988 WL 100500
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that the CSRA precludes a Bivens action premised on conduct amounting to a prohibited personnel practice
- noting that the CSRA does not preclude “the exercise of federal jurisdiction over the constitutional claims of federal employees ... altogether”
- noting that Congress had “not inadvertently” omitted a damages remedy “against officials” when passing the CSRA
- noting that CSRA “condemn[ed] the underlying actions as ‘prohibited personnel practices’ ”
- noting that, “[a]fter Chilicky, it is quite clear that if Congress has ‘not inadvertently’ omitted damages against officials in the statute at issue, then courts must abstain from supplementing Congress’ otherwise comprehensive statutory relief scheme with Bivens remedies”
- noting that CSRA “condemn[ed] the underlying actions as ‘prohibited personnel practices’”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Bork, Buckley, Edwards, Ginsburg, Mikva, Robinson, Silberman, Starr, Wald, Williams
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
156 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Jeffrey A. Saul v. United States of America Ray Larsen Colleen St. Louis John Doe St. LouisNinth Circuit· 1991-03-11· cited 486×
- Johnson v. Executive Office for United States AttorneysD.C. Circuit· 2002-11-22· cited 292×
- Wilson v. LibbyD.C. Circuit· 2008-08-12· cited 203×
- Davis v. District of ColumbiaD.C. Circuit· 1998-10-27· cited 197×
- Jacqueline P. Taylor v. Resolution Trust CorporationD.C. Circuit· 1995-10-04· cited 189×
- Vanover v. HantmanDistrict of Columbia· 1999-11-19· cited 188×
- Fornaro, Carmine v. James, Kay ColesD.C. Circuit· 2005-07-26· cited 169×
- Chung v. U.S. Department of JusticeD.C. Circuit· 2003-07-08· cited 163×
- District of Columbia v. ThompsonDistrict of Columbia Court of Appeals· 1991-06-17· cited 126×
- Leonard Rollon Crawford-El v. Patricia Britton and the District of ColumbiaD.C. Circuit· 1996-08-27· cited 124×
- Abdelfattah v. United States Department of Homeland SecurityD.C. Circuit· 2015-05-15· cited 121×
- Joseph Feit v. John Ward and Eugene GrapaSeventh Circuit· 1989-09-26· cited 109×
- Dotson v. GriesaSecond Circuit· 2005-02-02· cited 95×
- Michael E. Hubbard v. Administrator, Environmental Protection Agency, Michael E. Hubbard v. Environmental Protection AgencyD.C. Circuit· 1992-11-27· cited 84×
- Seymour A. Kleiman v. Department of EnergyD.C. Circuit· 1992-04-28· cited 82×
- Joanne K. Petrini v. Dorothy M. Howard Edward T. Doler, and United States of America, Department of the Interior, Bureau of Indian AffairsTenth Circuit· 1990-11-15· cited 80×
- Paul E. Montplaisir v. Richard J. LeightonFirst Circuit· 1989-05-11· cited 76×
- Townsend v. United StatesDistrict of Columbia· 2017-02-21· cited 69×
- Frank K. Kotarski v. V.L. Cooper, A.E. Navarro, W.J. Tinston, J.H. Kirkpatrick, Naval Air Rework Facility, Capt. P.A. Monroe, in His Official CapacityNinth Circuit· 1989-01-27· cited 64×
- V. Carol Robbins v. Lloyd Bentsen in His Capacity as Secretary of the Treasury v. Carol Robbins v. Keith Faust, Joe Williams and Donald WernerSeventh Circuit· 1994-12-08· cited 60×
Cites
21 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Bush v. LucasSupreme Court· 1983-06-13· cited 1,430×
- Chappell v. WallaceSupreme Court· 1983-06-13· cited 1,183×
- Schweiker v. ChilickySupreme Court· 1988-06-24· cited 1,110×
- Louis A. Carducci v. Donald T. Regan, Secretary, U.S. Treasury DepartmentD.C. Circuit· 1983-08-12· cited 680×
- Michael E. Hubbard v. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, AdministratorD.C. Circuit· 1987-01-06· cited 238×
- Krodel v. YoungD.C. Circuit· 1984-11-20· cited 149×
- Joseph C. Spagnola, Jr. v. William Mathis, (Two Cases) Joseph C. Spagnola, Jr. v. William MathisD.C. Circuit· 1987-01-06· cited 101×
- Linda H. Broadway v. John R. Block, Secretary of AgricultureFifth Circuit· 1982-12-15· cited 96×
- Phyllis F. Borrell v. United States International Communications AgencyD.C. Circuit· 1982-06-22· cited 88×
- Pinar v. DoleFourth Circuit· 1984-10-22· cited 81×
- McIntosh v. WeinbergerEighth Circuit· 1987-01-14· cited 79×
- Barbara Cutts v. Mark S. Fowler, Chairman, Federal Communications CommissionD.C. Circuit· 1982-10-29· cited 58×
- Frank K. Kotarski v. V.L. Cooper, A.E. Navarro, W.J. Tinston, J.H. Kirkpatrick, Naval Air Rework Facility, Capt. P.A. Monroe, in His Official CapacityNinth Circuit· 1986-09-16· cited 51×
- Technograph Liquidating Trust v. General Motors Corp.Supreme Court· 1988-06-27· cited 40×
- Turner v. McIntoshSupreme Court· 1988-06-27· cited 39×
- Braun v. United StatesSixth Circuit· 1983-05-27· cited 31×
- Charles E. Williams v. Internal Revenue Service, Office of the Chief CounselD.C. Circuit· 1984-10-09· cited 30×
- Pre-School Owners Ass'n v. Illinois Department of Children & Family ServicesSupreme Court· 1988-06-27· cited 27×
- Hallock v. MosesEleventh Circuit· 1984-05-03· cited 20×
- Cooper v. KotarskiSupreme Court· 1988-06-27· cited 17×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.