Supreme Court of Alabama· 2/4/2000
Smith v. Atkinson
Citations
- 771 So. 2d 429
- 2000 WL 127181
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- recognizing cause of action for negligent spoliation against third party, but not against first party
- stating that the duty to preserve evidence can be “imposed upon the defendant through a voluntary undertaking, an agreement, or a specific request” (emphasis added)
- “a third party’s constructive notice of a pending or potential action is not sufficient to force upon the third party the duty to preserve evidence”
- “If the third party does not wish to take responsibility for evidence, it can decline the responsibility, shifting the risk of loss back to the plaintiff.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Lyons, See
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
26 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Davis v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc.Ohio Supreme Court· 2001-10-31· cited 71×
- Rizzuto v. Davidson Ladders, Inc.Supreme Court of Connecticut· 2006-10-03· cited 61×
- Hannah v. HeeterWest Virginia Supreme Court· 2003-06-30· cited 59×
- Southland Bank v. a & a Drywall Supply Co.Supreme Court of Alabama· 2009-04-24· cited 54×
- Walker v. City of HuntsvilleSupreme Court of Alabama· 2010-09-30· cited 50×
- Fletcher v. Dorchester Mutual InsuranceMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 2002-08-16· cited 44×
- Reynolds v. BordelonSupreme Court of Louisiana· 2015-06-30· cited 41×
- Dowdle Butane Gas Co., Inc. v. MooreMississippi Supreme Court· 2002-12-05· cited 32×
- Teel v. MeredithMichigan Court of Appeals· 2009-07-02· cited 26×
- Verchot v. General Motors Corp.Supreme Court of Alabama· 2001-05-25· cited 26×
- Gilleski v. Community Med. CenterNew Jersey Superior Court App Division· 2001-01-30· cited 19×
- MacE v. Ford Motor CompanyWest Virginia Supreme Court· 2007-05-25· cited 15×
- Pikey v. BryantMissouri Court of Appeals· 2006-10-30· cited 13×
- COLE VISION CORP. v. HobbsSupreme Court of South Carolina· 2011-06-20· cited 9×
- Hills v. United Parcel Service, Inc.Utah Supreme Court· 2010-05-14· cited 6×
- Howard Regional Health System v. Gordon Ex Rel. GordonIndiana Court of Appeals· 2010-04-16· cited 5×
- KAUFMANN & ASSOCIATES, INC. v. DavisCourt of Civil Appeals of Alabama· 2004-07-30· cited 4×
- Rodda v. Joy Mining MachineryN.D. Alabama· 2014-04-15· cited 3×
- Brown Electro Mechanical Systems, Inc. v. Thompson Engineering, Inc.Supreme Court of Alabama· 2002-10-11· cited 2×
- Killings v. Enterprise Leasing Co., Inc.Supreme Court of Alabama· 2008-11-21· cited 2×
Cites
39 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Story Parchment Co. v. Paterson Parchment Paper Co.Supreme Court· 1931-02-24· cited 1,290×
- Bigelow v. RKO Radio Pictures, Inc.Supreme Court· 1946-03-25· cited 1,158×
- Boyd v. Travelers InsuranceIllinois Supreme Court· 1995-01-19· cited 281×
- Cedars-Sinai Medical Center v. Superior CourtCalifornia Supreme Court· 1998-05-11· cited 271×
- Trevino v. OrtegaTexas Supreme Court· 1998-07-03· cited 263×
- Smith v. Howard Johnson Co.Ohio Supreme Court· 1993-08-04· cited 212×
- Nellie F. Welsh, Administratrix of the Estate of Francis John Welsh, Deceased, and Nellie Welsh, Individually v. United StatesSixth Circuit· 1988-06-07· cited 170×
- Smith v. Superior CourtCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1984-01-31· cited 128×
- Hazen v. Municipality of AnchorageAlaska Supreme Court· 1986-07-31· cited 124×
- Bondu v. GurvichDistrict Court of Appeal of Florida· 1984-06-05· cited 92×
- Temple Community Hospital v. Superior CourtCalifornia Supreme Court· 1999-05-27· cited 84×
- Coleman v. Eddy Potash, Inc.New Mexico Supreme Court· 1995-09-22· cited 79×
- Koplin v. Rosel Well Perforators, Inc.Supreme Court of Kansas· 1987-03-27· cited 74×
- Crowne Investments, Inc. v. BryantSupreme Court of Alabama· 1994-03-25· cited 74×
- Torres v. El Paso Electric Co.New Mexico Supreme Court· 1999-06-30· cited 73×
- Brewer v. DowlingCourt of Appeals of Texas· 1993-10-26· cited 73×
- Miller v. Montgomery CountyCourt of Special Appeals of Maryland· 1985-07-09· cited 62×
- Townsend v. General Motors Corp.Supreme Court of Alabama· 1994-05-06· cited 59×
- Panich v. Iron Wood Products Corp.Michigan Court of Appeals· 1989-08-07· cited 55×
- Federated Mutual Insurance Co. v. Litchfield Precision Components, Inc.Supreme Court of Minnesota· 1990-05-25· cited 54×
Other cases named Smith v. Atkinson
10 other CourtListener records share this case name.
- Smith v. AtkinsonCalifornia Supreme Court· 1973-03-15· cited 21×
- Smith v. AtkinsonSupreme Court of Colorado· 1893-01-15· cited 11×
- Smith v. AtkinsonM.D. Alabama· 1998-10-29· cited 2×
- Smith v. AtkinsonM.D. Alabama· 2000-06-12· cited 1×
- Smith v. AtkinsonTennessee Supreme Court· 1871-05-13· cited 1×
- Smith v. AtkinsonFourth Circuit· 2013-11-22· cited 1×
- Smith v. AtkinsonSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1969-02-07
- Smith v. AtkinsonTennessee Supreme Court· 1871-05-13
- Smith v. AtkinsonFourth Circuit· 2011-05-23
- Smith v. AtkinsonFourth Circuit· 2014-05-06
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.