Supreme Court of The Virgin Islands· 8/13/2013
Simmonds v. People
Citations
- 59 V.I. 480
- 2013 WL 4404592
- 2013 V.I. Supreme LEXIS 42
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- concluding that sufficient evidence existed where the accused moved closer to the victim to fire additional gunshots “far more likely to result in death”
- stating that Congress intended for “the Fifth Amendment to have the same effect in the Virgin Islands as it does in the states”
- noting that in comparison to the former rule governing prior inconsistent statements, “Rule 801(d)(1)(A) sets forth significantly more stringent requirements for the admission of prior inconsistent statements as substantive evidence”
- finding sufficient evidence for first-degree assault when the defendant fired shots at the victim
- “[a]s with all policy matters entrusted to the Legislature, this Court must defer to the Legislature’s decision”
- trial court erred by admitting police interview statement under local rather than federal evidentiary rule but error was harmless (citing Castro-Ayon for discussion of FRE 801(d)(1)(A)’s legislative history)
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Cabret, Hodge, Swan
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
39 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- State v. OttonWashington Supreme Court· 2016-06-09· cited 58×
- Rivera-Moreno v. Government of the Virgin IslandsSupreme Court of The Virgin Islands· 2014-09-26· cited 51×
- Vanterpool v. Government of the Virgin IslandsSupreme Court of The Virgin Islands· 2015-08-10· cited 49×
- Better Building Maintenance of the Virgin Islands, Inc. v. LeeSupreme Court of The Virgin Islands· 2014-04-15· cited 46×
- Antilles School, Inc. v. LembachSupreme Court of The Virgin Islands· 2016-03-14· cited 44×
- Cascen v. PeopleSupreme Court of The Virgin Islands· 2014-01-08· cited 38×
- King v. AppletonSupreme Court of The Virgin Islands· 2014-10-06· cited 34×
- Haynes v. OttleySupreme Court of The Virgin Islands· 2014-12-01· cited 32×
- Malloy v. ReyesSupreme Court of The Virgin Islands· 2014-07-22· cited 31×
- Ottley v. Estate of BellSupreme Court of The Virgin Islands· 2014-10-29· cited 31×
- Williams v. PeopleSupreme Court of The Virgin Islands· 2013-11-05· cited 24×
- In re the Estate of GeorgeSupreme Court of The Virgin Islands· 2013-10-11· cited 22×
- Virgin Islands Waste Management Authority v. Bovoni Investments, LLCSupreme Court of The Virgin Islands· 2014-10-07· cited 18×
- Estick v. PeopleSupreme Court of The Virgin Islands· 2015-04-15· cited 15×
- Thomas v. PeopleSupreme Court of The Virgin Islands· 2013-12-02· cited 14×
- Sarauw v. FawkesSupreme Court of The Virgin Islands· 2017-01-08· cited 13×
- Rivera v. PeopleSupreme Court of The Virgin Islands· 2016-05-04· cited 12×
- Joseph v. PeopleSupreme Court of The Virgin Islands· 2013-12-23· cited 11×
- Fahie v. PeopleSupreme Court of The Virgin Islands· 2015-05-18· cited 10×
- Samuel v. United Corp.Supreme Court of The Virgin Islands· 2016-05-02· cited 9×
Cites
60 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Kotteakos v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1946-06-10· cited 7,845×
- Johnson v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1997-05-12· cited 4,572×
- California v. GreenSupreme Court· 1970-06-23· cited 3,363×
- McKaskle v. WigginsSupreme Court· 1984-01-23· cited 2,288×
- People v. ZapienCalifornia Supreme Court· 1993-03-04· cited 691×
- Bridges v. WixonSupreme Court· 1945-06-18· cited 672×
- United States v. Robert Joseph Carr, Jr., in No. 93-1376. United States of America v. Walter Orlando Cardona-Usquiano, in No. 93-1383Third Circuit· 1994-06-28· cited 207×
- Southern Scrap Material Co. v. Abc InsuranceFifth Circuit· 2008-08-25· cited 198×
- St. Thomas-St. John Board of Elections v. DanielSupreme Court of The Virgin Islands· 2007-09-17· cited 196×
- United States v. Jesus Losada and Rosalinda LosadaSecond Circuit· 1982-03-12· cited 169×
- United States v. Francis J. De SistoSecond Circuit· 1964-06-15· cited 153×
- United States v. William F. HelblingThird Circuit· 2000-03-14· cited 147×
- United States v. Clinton WebsterSeventh Circuit· 1984-05-09· cited 116×
- United States v. Larry PetermanTenth Circuit· 1988-06-07· cited 78×
- Latalladi v. PeopleSupreme Court of The Virgin Islands· 2009-02-11· cited 72×
- Blyden v. PeopleSupreme Court of The Virgin Islands· 2010-07-07· cited 68×
- United States v. Emilano Gomez-GallardoNinth Circuit· 1990-10-02· cited 48×
- State v. SpadaforeWest Virginia Supreme Court· 1975-12-16· cited 48×
- Phillips v. PeopleSupreme Court of The Virgin Islands· 2009-03-12· cited 47×
- United States v. Rafael Castro-AyonNinth Circuit· 1976-06-08· cited 45×
Other cases named Simmonds v. People
2 other CourtListener records share this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.