M.D. Ex Rel. Stukenberg v. Perry

How courts have described this case

Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.

• noting that “[t]he district court clearly rejected” the defendant’s individualization argument but had not “sufficiently analyzed” it
• noting that commonality is not shown when plaintiffs allege an amorphous claim of undefined and unspecified systemic misconduct
• noting that the deliberate indifference standard mandates “an individualized inquiry regarding the harm or risk of harm experienced by each class member”
• noting that cases challenging system-wide practices are appropriate for (b)(2) certification
• noting that cases challenging system-wide practices are appropriate for (b)(2) certification
• noting that the district court needed to explain why it had rejected the defendant’s argument that “resolution of each of the class member’s . . . claims require[d] individual analysis” that could have prevented the litigation from “generat[ing] common answers”

Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).

Cited by

48 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.

• Victor Parsons v. Charles Ryan
  Ninth Circuit· 2014-06-05· cited 333×
• In Re: Deepwater Horizon
  Fifth Circuit· 2014-01-10· cited 187×
• Bice v. Louisiana Public Defender Board
  Fifth Circuit· 2012-04-16· cited 133×
• Quinton Brown v. Nucor Corporation
  Fourth Circuit· 2015-05-11· cited 131×
• Jones v. Gusman
  E.D. Louisiana· 2013-06-06· cited 129×
• Melvin Phillips v. Sheriff of Cook County
  Seventh Circuit· 2016-07-06· cited 102×
• Rodriguez v. Countrywide Home Loans, Inc. (In Re Rodriguez)
  Fifth Circuit· 2012-09-14· cited 86×
• DL v. District of Columbia
  D.C. Circuit· 2013-04-12· cited 83×
• M. D. Ex Rel. Stukenberg v. Abbott
  Fifth Circuit· 2018-10-18· cited 73×
• David Bailey v. Bryan Collier
  Fifth Circuit· 2017-08-18· cited 61×
• Braidwood Management v. EEOC
  Fifth Circuit· 2023-06-20· cited 36×
• M.D. v. Perry
  S.D. Texas· 2013-08-27· cited 34×
• Heriberto Chavez v. Plan Benefit Services
  Fifth Circuit· 2020-04-29· cited 33×
• Butler v. Suffolk County
  E.D. New York· 2013-03-19· cited 31×
• Soutter v. Equifax Information Services, LLC
  E.D. Virginia· 2015-04-15· cited 31×
• Thorpe v. District of Columbia
  District of Columbia· 2014-03-29· cited 30×
• Dl v. District of Columbia
  District of Columbia· 2013-11-08· cited 30×
• Kenneth R. v. Hassan
  D. New Hampshire· 2013-09-17· cited 30×
• Prantil v. Arkema
  Fifth Circuit· 2021-01-22· cited 28×
• In re Oil Spill
  E.D. Louisiana· 2013-01-11· cited 25×

Cites

28 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.

• Lewis v. Casey
  Supreme Court· 1996-06-24· cited 7,493×
• County of Sacramento v. Lewis
  Supreme Court· 1998-05-26· cited 6,212×
• Amchem Products, Inc. v. Windsor
  Supreme Court· 1997-06-25· cited 4,991×
• Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. v. Dukes
  Supreme Court· 2011-06-20· cited 4,653×
• General Telephone Co. of Southwest v. Falcon
  Supreme Court· 1982-06-14· cited 4,068×
• Collins v. City of Harker Heights
  Supreme Court· 1992-02-26· cited 3,302×
• Youngberg v. Romeo Ex Rel. Romeo
  Supreme Court· 1982-06-18· cited 2,433×
• Dianne Castano v. The American Tobacco Company
  Fifth Circuit· 1996-05-23· cited 871×
• Nicini v. Morra
  Third Circuit· 2000-05-19· cited 680×
• Baby Neal v. Casey
  Third Circuit· 1994-12-15· cited 562×
• Marisol A. ex rel. Forbes v. Giuliani
  Second Circuit· 1997-09-26· cited 306×
• Mullen v. Treasure Chest Casino, LLC
  Fifth Circuit· 1999-08-20· cited 267×
• J.B. Ex Rel. Hart v. Valdez
  Tenth Circuit· 1999-08-12· cited 220×
• DG Ex Rel. Stricklin v. DeVaughn
  Tenth Circuit· 2010-02-08· cited 215×
• Mary Jane Forbush v. J.C. Penney Company, Inc., Pension Plan
  Fifth Circuit· 1993-06-25· cited 215×
• Jamie S. v. Milwaukee Public Schools
  Seventh Circuit· 2012-02-03· cited 193×
• Bell Atlantic Corp. v. AT&T Corp.
  Fifth Circuit· 2003-08-05· cited 143×
• James v. City of Dallas
  Fifth Circuit· 2001-07-17· cited 136×
• Eugene Stewart v. William Winter, Individually and in His Official Capacity as Governor of the State of Mississippi
  Fifth Circuit· 1982-03-05· cited 129×
• Shook v. Board of County Commissioners
  Tenth Circuit· 2008-08-29· cited 120×