In Re Duncan
Citations
- 139 U.S. 449
- 11 S. Ct. 573
- 35 L. Ed. 219
- 1891 U.S. LEXIS 2396
Syllabus
<p>When the trial court of a State has jurisdiction and power, under state laws, to determine the law. applicable to the case of an indictment and trial for murder, and the prisoner, when convicted, has an appeal to an appellate court of the State, of which he avails himself, the Circuit Court of the United States for the District, if applied to for a writ of habeas corpus, pending the appeal, upon the ground that the proceedings are in violation of provisions of the Constitution of the United States, may properly decline to interfere.</p> <p>A statute duly certified is presumed to have been duly passed until the contrary appears.</p> <p>When, in the trial of a cause, an objection is taken that the legislature failed to comply with the provisions of the Constitution in the enactment of a statute, it should lie so presented that the adverse party may have opportunity to controvert the allegations, and to prove by the record due conformity with the constitutional requirements.</p> <p>Whether a state statute has or has not binding force, by reason of compliance or non-compliance with the provisions of the constitution of the State, is a question for the state courts to determine.</p>
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- addressing rights of states to choose their own government officials and pass their own laws
- discussing the republican governments of the States
- discussing the republican governments of the States
- discussing the republican governments of the States
- discussing the republican governments of the States
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Fuller
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
75 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Baker v. CarrSupreme Court· 1962-03-26· cited 6,173×
- Braden v. 30th Judicial Circuit Court of KentuckySupreme Court· 1973-02-28· cited 2,787×
- Gregory v. AshcroftSupreme Court· 1991-06-20· cited 1,325×
- New York v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1992-06-19· cited 1,301×
- Darr v. BurfordSupreme Court· 1950-04-03· cited 969×
- Sugarman v. DougallSupreme Court· 1973-06-25· cited 451×
- Taylor and Marshall v. BeckhamSupreme Court· 1900-05-14· cited 232×
- Talton v. MayesSupreme Court· 1896-05-18· cited 217×
- Davis v. BurkeSupreme Court· 1900-12-17· cited 180×
- State Ex Rel. Huddleston v. SawyerOregon Supreme Court· 1997-02-21· cited 171×
- Puerto Rico v. Sanchez ValleSupreme Court· 2016-06-09· cited 125×
- New York v. EnoSupreme Court· 1894-10-29· cited 83×
- Louisville Trust Co. v. City of CincinnatiSixth Circuit· 1896-10-05· cited 77×
- In Re Complaint as to the Conduct of FadeleyOregon Supreme Court· 1990-11-19· cited 70×
- Minnesota v. BrundageSupreme Court· 1901-03-18· cited 68×
- Paterno v. LyonsSupreme Court· 1948-06-01· cited 68×
- McConaughy v. Secretary of StateSupreme Court of Minnesota· 1909-01-08· cited 48×
- Maryland v. Environmental Protection AgencyFourth Circuit· 1975-09-19· cited 45×
- Bates v. JonesNinth Circuit· 1997-12-19· cited 42×
- State ex rel. Knox v. DillardSupreme Court of Alabama· 1916-04-21· cited 42×
Cites
5 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Town of South Ottawa v. PerkinsSupreme Court· 1877-03-26· cited 128×
- Railroad Co. v. GeorgiaSupreme Court· 1879-01-27· cited 100×
- Post v. SupervisorsSupreme Court· 1882-05-18· cited 58×
- Ex Parte FondaSupreme Court· 1886-03-29· cited 46×
- Auditor v. HaycraftCourt of Appeals of Kentucky· 1878-10-24· cited 4×
Other cases named In Re Duncan
49 other CourtListener records share this case name.
- In Re DuncanSupreme Court of South Carolina· 1909-07-17· cited 90×
- In Re DuncanSupreme Court of Vermont· 1990-11-30· cited 49×
- In Re DuncanTex. App. Ct., 1st Dist. (Houston)· 2001-12-05· cited 26×
- In Re DuncanD. Alaska· 1984-08-10· cited 23×
- In Re DuncanE.D. Virginia· 1940-07-06· cited 15×
- In Re DuncanE.D. Tennessee· 1992-05-07· cited 13×
- In Re DuncanW.D. Missouri· 1991-03-28· cited 13×
- In Re DuncanSupreme Court of Missouri· 1992-12-18· cited 12×
- In Re DuncanW.D. Oklahoma· 1988-09-28· cited 10×
- In Re DuncanCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1987-03-03· cited 10×
- In re DuncanSupreme Court of Georgia· 2017-08-28· cited 10×
- In Re DuncanE.D. Tennessee· 2000-01-05· cited 7×
- In Re DuncanW.D. Oklahoma· 1988-12-09· cited 6×
- In re DuncanNew York Surrogate's Court· 1974-12-27· cited 6×
- In re DuncanS.D. New York· 1876-02-15· cited 4×
- In re DuncanDistrict of Columbia· 1920-05-03· cited 4×
- In Re DuncanM.D. Alabama· 1985-09-05· cited 3×
- In Re DuncanD. Arizona· 1997-07-15· cited 3×
- In re DuncanOhio Court of Appeals· 1951-05-05· cited 3×
- In re DuncanN.D. Ohio· 1980-12-18· cited 3×
- In re DuncanD. South Carolina· 1906-08-09· cited 3×
- In Re DuncanWashington Supreme Court· 2008-10-02· cited 2×
- In Re DuncanDistrict of Columbia Court of Appeals· 2011-06-23· cited 2×
- In re DuncanNew York Surrogate's Court· 1877-08-15· cited 2×
- In Re DuncanD. Montana· 2009-05-14· cited 1×
- In re DuncanDistrict of Columbia Court of Appeals· 2013-06-13· cited 1×
- In re DuncanW.D. Missouri· 1990-06-19· cited 1×
- In re DuncanSupreme Court of South Carolina· 1999-07-30· cited 1×
- In Re DuncanEighth Circuit· 1993-03-29
- In re: DuncanCourt of Appeals of North Carolina· 2018-11-20
- In re DuncanDistrict of Columbia Court of Appeals· 2013-10-10
- In re DuncanCourt of Appeals of Kentucky· 1966-10-28
- In re DuncanAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York· 1935-07-15
- In re DuncanAppellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York· 1936-05-15
- In re DuncanSupreme Court of Georgia· 2000-02-14
- In re DuncanW.D. Missouri· 1985-06-11
- In re DuncanNorthern Mariana Islands· 1988-07-08
- In re DuncanNorthern Mariana Islands· 1988-11-08
- In re DuncanSupreme Court of North Carolina· 2019-01-30
- In re DuncanSupreme Court of South Carolina· 2000-05-15
- In re DuncanS.D. New York· 1876-11-15
- In re DuncanS.D. New York· 1878-06-08
- In re DuncanNorthern Mariana Islands Commonwealth Trial Court· 1988-04-25
- In re DuncanFourth Circuit· 1918-02-08
- In re DuncanFourth Circuit· 1918-10-09
- In re DuncanFourth Circuit· 1919-02-13
- In re DuncanU.S. Circuit Court for the District of Southern New York· 1893-06-27
- In re: DuncanHawaii Supreme Court· 2023-03-29
- In re DuncanSupreme Court of Kansas· 2025-07-16
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.