E.D. Pennsylvania· 10/4/1995
Forman v. Data Transfer, Inc.
Citations
- 164 F.R.D. 400
- 1995 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 14547
- 1995 WL 590172
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that the court could not determine class membership where the class definition required “addressing the central issue of liability to be decided in the case”
- finding that the statutory remedy provides adequate incentive for individual plaintiffs to bring suit on their own behalf
- finding that “[a] class action would be inconsistent with the specific and personal remedy provided by Congress to address the minor nuisance of unsolicited facsimile advertisements”
- rejecting purported class consisting of \ ‘all residents and businesses who have received unsolicited facsimile advertisements’ \ because addressing central liability issue required
- denying class certification because the plaintiffs definition of the class would require a mini-hearing on the merits of each plaintiffs claim and liability would be determined by facts specific to each plaintiff
- denying certification because “the proposed class definition flies directly in the face of a basic tenet of class certification: a court may not inquire into the merits of the ease at the class certification stage.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Giles
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
76 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- William Barnes v. The American Tobacco CompanyThird Circuit· 1998-11-12· cited 337×
- Rollins, Inc. v. ButlandDistrict Court of Appeal of Florida· 2006-12-15· cited 284×
- Ford Motor Co. v. SheldonTexas Supreme Court· 2000-05-11· cited 142×
- Intratex Gas Co. v. BeesonTexas Supreme Court· 2000-03-09· cited 118×
- Shuette v. Beazer Homes Holdings Corp.Nevada Supreme Court· 2005-12-15· cited 104×
- Landsman & Funk PC v. Skinder-Strauss AssociatesThird Circuit· 2011-04-04· cited 91×
- Noble v. 93 University Place Corp.S.D. New York· 2004-05-03· cited 73×
- Kenro, Inc. v. Fax Daily, Inc.S.D. Indiana· 1997-04-10· cited 71×
- Espinoza v. 953 Associates LLCS.D. New York· 2011-11-16· cited 70×
- Arch v. American Tobacco Co.E.D. Pennsylvania· 1997-06-03· cited 68×
- Carnett's, Inc. v. HammondSupreme Court of Georgia· 2005-03-14· cited 67×
- Barnes v. United StatesFederal Claims· 2005-11-03· cited 66×
- Daniels v. City of New YorkS.D. New York· 2001-01-25· cited 62×
- Floyd v. City of New YorkS.D. New York· 2012-05-16· cited 57×
- Sanneman v. Chrysler Corp.E.D. Pennsylvania· 2000-03-02· cited 47×
- Agostino v. Quest Diagnostics Inc.D. New Jersey· 2009-02-11· cited 47×
- Perez v. Metabolife International, Inc.S.D. Florida· 2003-09-26· cited 45×
- Universal Underwriters Insurance Company v. Lou Fusz Automotive Network, Inc.Eighth Circuit· 2005-03-21· cited 42×
- Kavu, Inc. v. Omnipak Corp.W.D. Washington· 2007-01-23· cited 39×
- McGee v. East Ohio Gas Co.S.D. Ohio· 2001-05-23· cited 35×
Cites
16 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Eisen v. Carlisle & JacquelinSupreme Court· 1974-05-28· cited 3,301×
- In Re General Motors Corporation Pick-Up Truck Fuel Tank Products Liability Litigation. Jack French, Robert M. West, Charles E. Merritt, Gary Blades, Dawn and Tracey Best, Gary and Jackie Barnes, Betty Marteny, John and Mary Southands, Edmund Berning, Dale W. Plummer, Edmund and Anneta Casey, John aThird Circuit· 1995-04-17· cited 850×
- Unnamed caseThird Circuit· 1975-02-25· cited 621×
- Baby Neal v. CaseyThird Circuit· 1994-12-15· cited 562×
- Bogosian v. Gulf Oil Corp.Third Circuit· 1977-07-21· cited 553×
- Woodrow Sterling v. Velsicol Chemical CorporationSixth Circuit· 1988-10-20· cited 445×
- Green v. Wolf Corp.Second Circuit· 1968-12-09· cited 440×
- Ratner v. Chemical Bank New York Trust Co.S.D. New York· 1972-02-14· cited 105×
- Liberty Lincoln Mercury, Inc. v. Ford Marketing Corp.D. New Jersey· 1993-05-14· cited 85×
- Moskowitz v. LoppE.D. Pennsylvania· 1989-12-07· cited 71×
- Coca-Cola Bottling Co. of Elizabethtown, Inc. v. Coca-Cola Co.D. Delaware· 1982-08-17· cited 34×
- Gavron v. Blinder Robinson & Co.E.D. Pennsylvania· 1987-04-16· cited 34×
- Hagen v. City of WinnemuccaD. Nevada· 1985-10-11· cited 33×
- Safran v. United Steelworkers of AmericaW.D. Pennsylvania· 1989-10-31· cited 10×
- Dunn v. Midwest Buslines, Inc.E.D. Arkansas· 1982-04-28· cited 9×
- In re Scott Paper Co. Securities LitigationE.D. Pennsylvania· 1992-05-29· cited 9×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.