Dibert v. Carpenter
Citations
- 2017 Ohio 689
Syllabus
Trial court did not err in failing to provide plaintiff a jury trial on defendant's counterclaims plaintiff did not demand a jury trial on the counterclaims, and he had no constitutional or statutory right to a jury trial on those claims, which arose in equity. Trial court did not err in adjudicating defendant's counterclaims plaintiff failed to raise a \same capacity\ defense in response to defendant's counterclaims as originally pled, and any error in that regard was corrected in the amended counterclaim. Defendant, as a beneficiary of the trust, was a real party in interest for her claims, brought in her individual capacity, against her plaintiff-brother for conduct he engaged in as a co-trustee of the trust. Plaintiff's claim that the trial judge should have recused herself should have been raised in an affidavit of disqualification to the Ohio Supreme Court regardless, plaintiff agreed to the judge's participation and failed to allege the nature of any bias or prejudice by the judge or that plaintiff was prejudiced by any alleged bias. Successor judge did not abuse his discretion in denying plaintiff's renewed motion to amend his answer to defendant's amended counterclaims and denying plaintiff's motion to close the case. Trial court did not err in granting defendant-counterclaimant's motion for attorney fees and costs. Judgment affirmed.
Judges: Froelich
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
6 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Hicks v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co.Ohio Court of Appeals· 2017-08-04· cited 10×
- In re K.B.Ohio Court of Appeals· 2018-09-07· cited 6×
- State v. ShabazzOhio Court of Appeals· 2017-08-11· cited 3×
- CitiMortgage, Inc. v. StanleyOhio Court of Appeals· 2018-10-19· cited 3×
- Tax Ease Ohio, L.L.C. v. WellsOhio Court of Appeals· 2020-01-31· cited 1×
- McClain v. StateOhio Court of Appeals· 2021-04-23· cited 1×
Cites
18 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Wilmington Steel Products, Inc. v. Cleveland Electric Illuminating Co.Ohio Supreme Court· 1991-06-05· cited 371×
- State v. Osie (Slip Opinion)Ohio Supreme Court· 2014-07-10· cited 155×
- Ehrlich v. American Moninger Greenhouse Manufacturing Corp.New York Court of Appeals· 1970-03-05· cited 139×
- Shealy v. CampbellOhio Supreme Court· 1985-11-13· cited 117×
- United States Fidelity & Guaranty Co. v. GoudeauTexas Supreme Court· 2008-12-19· cited 73×
- Soler v. EvansOhio Supreme Court· 2002-03-20· cited 49×
- Rhodes, Inc. v. MorrowM.D. North Carolina· 1996-09-13· cited 24×
- Pomfret Farms Ltd. Partnership v. Pomfret AssociatesSupreme Court of Vermont· 2002-08-23· cited 23×
- Papiernik v. PapiernikOhio Supreme Court· 1989-09-27· cited 19×
- In re Disqualification of CapperOhio Supreme Court· 2012-08-03· cited 18×
- Collection Center, Inc. v. BydalNorth Dakota Supreme Court· 2011-03-22· cited 17×
- McLeod v. Sandy Island Corp.Supreme Court of South Carolina· 1973-03-08· cited 13×
- Blanchard v. KatzS.D. New York· 1987-11-10· cited 13×
- Han v. Univ. of DaytonOhio Court of Appeals· 2015-01-30· cited 8×
- City of Trotwood v. South Central Construction, L.L.C.Ohio Court of Appeals· 2011-01-21· cited 8×
- State v. HudsonOhio Court of Appeals· 2014-12-05· cited 7×
- Easterling v. HaferOhio Court of Appeals· 2012-05-11· cited 6×
- Dibert v. CarpenterOhio Court of Appeals· 2011-11-04· cited 4×
Other cases named Dibert v. Carpenter
3 other CourtListener records share this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.