Seventh Circuit· 7/25/2013
Daya Bathula v. Eric Holder, Jr.
Citations
- 723 F.3d 889
- 2013 WL 3833257
- 2013 U.S. App. LEXIS 15126
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- explaining that the Convention Against Torture's requirement to show a future likelihood of torture is a more stringent standard than persecution
- explaining that, even though a group with the ability and resolve to kill its adversaries threatened the petitioner, the nature of the threats and the group's failure to follow through despite the opportunity to do so reflected harassment, not persecution
- upholding denial where IJ did not require petitioner to “live in hiding” but instead discredited likelihood of future torture
- suggesting that the burden shifting framework may apply to CAT claims
- rejecting petitioners’ argument that agency improperly placed burden to establish unreasonableness of relocation on them, given absence of any past persecution
- explaining that, even though a group with the ability and resolve to kill its adversaries threatened the petitioner, the nature of the threats and the group’s failure to follow through despite the 10 No. 18-2618 opportunity to do so reflected harassment, not persecution
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Ripple, Tinder, Zagel
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
23 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- N.L.A. v. Eric Holder, Jr.Seventh Circuit· 2014-03-03· cited 52×
- Andre Bernard v. Jefferson Sessions, IIISeventh Circuit· 2018-02-08· cited 45×
- Zelaya-Moreno v. WilkinsonSecond Circuit· 2021-02-26· cited 43×
- Minghai Tian v. Eric Holder, Jr.Seventh Circuit· 2014-03-13· cited 36×
- Raul Antia-Perea v. Eric Holder, Jr.Seventh Circuit· 2014-09-25· cited 25×
- Sebastian Duarte-Salagoza v. Eric Holder, Jr.Seventh Circuit· 2014-12-30· cited 25×
- Sugiarto Halim v. Eric Holder, Jr.Seventh Circuit· 2014-06-17· cited 21×
- Bayanmunkh Darinchuluun v. Loretta E. LynchSeventh Circuit· 2015-10-08· cited 21×
- Victor Meraz-Saucedo v. Jeffrey A. RosenSeventh Circuit· 2021-01-15· cited 20×
- N. Y. C. C. v. William P. BarrSeventh Circuit· 2019-07-19· cited 18×
- Ricardo Sanchez v. Jefferson B. Sessions IIISeventh Circuit· 2018-07-05· cited 16×
- Katsiaryna Sobaleva v. Eric Holder, Jr.Seventh Circuit· 2014-07-24· cited 10×
- Melnik v. SessionsSeventh Circuit· 2018-05-25· cited 6×
- Oscar Guzman-Garcia v. Merrick B. GarlandSeventh Circuit· 2021-05-03· cited 5×
- Bukola Omowole v. Merrick B. GarlandSeventh Circuit· 2021-07-29· cited 4×
- Benjamin Ruiz-Cabrera v. Eric Holder, Jr.Seventh Circuit· 2014-04-08· cited 3×
- Tangka v. HolderSeventh Circuit· 2015-03-26· cited 1×
- Ruslana Melnik v. Jefferson B. Sessions IIISeventh Circuit· 2018-05-25
- Elvira Garcia-Arce v. William BarrSeventh Circuit· 2019-12-30
- Anthony Murry v. Merrick B. GarlandSeventh Circuit· 2021-10-07
Cites
25 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Immigration & Naturalization Service v. Elias-ZacariasSupreme Court· 1992-01-22· cited 8,324×
- Securities & Exchange Commission v. Chenery Corp.Supreme Court· 1947-06-23· cited 3,981×
- Ukashu Nuru, AKA Ukasha Nuru v. Alberto R. Gonzales, Attorney GeneralNinth Circuit· 2005-04-21· cited 461×
- MOGARRABIBoard of Immigration Appeals· 1987-07-01· cited 442×
- Valentin Boykov and Krassimira Boykova v. Immigration and Naturalization ServiceSeventh Circuit· 1997-03-26· cited 100×
- Rexhep Bejko v. Alberto R. GonzalesSeventh Circuit· 2006-11-13· cited 85×
- Gatimi v. HolderSeventh Circuit· 2009-08-20· cited 80×
- George Malcom Anthony Rashiah, Salomi Hiranthie Anthony Rashiah, and Anne Oshani Anthony Rashiah v. John D. AshcroftSeventh Circuit· 2004-11-16· cited 69×
- Vahora v. HolderSeventh Circuit· 2010-11-15· cited 61×
- Sarhan v. HolderSeventh Circuit· 2011-09-02· cited 61×
- Volodymyr Pavlyk, Natalia Pavlyk, and Iryna Pavlyk v. Alberto R. GonzalesSeventh Circuit· 2006-12-07· cited 60×
- Jun Ying Wang v. Alberto R. Gonzales, Attorney General of the United StatesSeventh Circuit· 2006-04-28· cited 56×
- Stanojkova v. HolderSeventh Circuit· 2011-07-14· cited 52×
- Hassan v. HolderSeventh Circuit· 2009-07-02· cited 50×
- Husni El-Gazawy v. Eric Holder, Jr.Seventh Circuit· 2012-08-16· cited 49×
- Stelian Marinov v. Eric Holder, Jr.Seventh Circuit· 2012-08-01· cited 36×
- Victor E. Sepulveda v. Alberto R. GonzalesSeventh Circuit· 2006-10-02· cited 33×
- BUESO-AVILA v. HolderSeventh Circuit· 2011-11-29· cited 32×
- Bolante v. MukaseySeventh Circuit· 2008-08-27· cited 27×
- Martinez-Buendia v. HolderSeventh Circuit· 2010-08-10· cited 14×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.