Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 12/10/2013
Commonwealth v. Stewart
Citations
- 84 A.3d 701
- 2013 Pa. Super. 317
- 2013 WL 6449457
- 2013 Pa. Super. LEXIS 3196
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding the defendant was prejudiced by counsel’s failure to call alibi witness where the evidence was not overwhelming; “This case hinged on whether the jury believed [the defendant] had an alibi or [believed the lone eyewitness’s] testimony.”
- affirming grant of new trial where trial counsel failed to interview alibi witness who testified at the evidentiary (Footnote Continued
- citing, inter alia, Commonwealth v. Perry, 644 A.2d 705 (Pa. 1994); Commonwealth v. Jones, 437 A.2d 958 (Pa. 1991)
- stating, “failure to prepare is not an example of forgoing one possible avenue to pursue another approach; it is simply an abdication of the minimum performance required of defense counsel” (citations, original quotation marks, and brackets omitted)
- stating, “failure to prepare is not an example of forgoing one possible avenue to pursue another approach; it is simply an abdication of the minimum performance required of defense counsel” (citations, original quotation marks, and brackets omitted)
- “Prejudice is established if there is a reasonable probability that, but for counsel’s errors, the result of the proceeding would have been different”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Bender, Bowes, Donohue, Elliott, Lazarus, Olson, Panella, Shogan, Wecht
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
12 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Commonwealth v. SanduskySuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2019-02-05· cited 419×
- Commonwealth v. PanderSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2014-09-17· cited 153×
- Commonwealth v. BarnettSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2015-07-29· cited 105×
- Com. v. McCready, P.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 2023-05-17· cited 40×
- Com. v. Pitt, W.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 2024-03-27· cited 23×
- Commonwealth v. MaldonodoSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2017-09-12· cited 21×
- Com. v. Evans, M.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 2023-09-22· cited 20×
- Com. v. Hawkins, J.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 2020-12-10· cited 15×
- Com. v. Stultz, J.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 2015-04-28
- Com. v. Muzzy, D.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 2016-09-15
- Com. v. Boyer, F.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 2022-05-24
- Com. v. Yaw, L.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 2023-11-21
Cites
32 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Strickland v. WashingtonSupreme Court· 1984-06-25· cited 123,578×
- Commonwealth v. JohnsonSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2009-03-18· cited 958×
- Commonwealth v. ChmielSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2011-11-09· cited 553×
- Commonwealth v. WilliamsSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1999-06-04· cited 461×
- Commonwealth v. SimpsonSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2013-03-26· cited 361×
- Commonwealth v. ColavitaSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2010-04-29· cited 319×
- Commonwealth v. BurkettSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2010-09-30· cited 296×
- Commonwealth v. SteeleSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2008-12-18· cited 284×
- Commonwealth v. YoungSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1974-03-25· cited 276×
- Commonwealth v. DennisSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2008-06-20· cited 200×
- Commonwealth v. RathfonSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2006-05-09· cited 197×
- Commonwealth v. CarterSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2011-05-26· cited 179×
- Commonwealth v. RushSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2008-10-01· cited 176×
- Commonwealth v. MillerSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2009-12-28· cited 162×
- Commonwealth v. MabieSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1976-07-06· cited 129×
- Commonwealth v. JonesSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2005-06-21· cited 111×
- Commonwealth v. WeissSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1992-03-18· cited 111×
- Commonwealth v. SamSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2008-07-22· cited 95×
- Commonwealth v. AfricaSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1976-03-17· cited 89×
- Commonwealth v. SaranchakSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2005-01-19· cited 88×
Other cases named Commonwealth v. Stewart
104 other CourtListener records share this case name; the 50 most cited are listed.
- Commonwealth v. StewartMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1981-04-01· cited 164×
- Commonwealth v. StewartSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2005-01-21· cited 134×
- Commonwealth v. StewartMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1978-06-14· cited 83×
- Commonwealth v. StewartMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1971-03-01· cited 81×
- Commonwealth v. StewartSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1972-10-04· cited 79×
- Commonwealth v. StewartSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1997-02-24· cited 76×
- Commonwealth v. StewartMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1974-04-10· cited 71×
- Commonwealth v. StewartSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1974-03-25· cited 69×
- Commonwealth v. StewartSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1975-04-17· cited 64×
- Commonwealth v. StewartMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1991-12-09· cited 59×
- Commonwealth v. StewartMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1986-11-10· cited 50×
- Commonwealth v. StewartSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1981-01-30· cited 42×
- Commonwealth v. StewartSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1999-09-13· cited 35×
- Commonwealth v. StewartSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1988-07-13· cited 34×
- Commonwealth v. StewartMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 2014-08-07· cited 34×
- Commonwealth v. StewartSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1982-09-17· cited 31×
- Commonwealth v. StewartMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1926-02-25· cited 31×
- Commonwealth v. StewartMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1971-06-16· cited 28×
- Commonwealth v. StewartSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1968-05-03· cited 25×
- Commonwealth v. StewartMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 2009-08-14· cited 23×
- Commonwealth v. StewartSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1978-11-18· cited 22×
- Commonwealth v. StewartSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1994-10-13· cited 21×
- Commonwealth v. StewartSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1985-06-28· cited 19×
- Commonwealth v. StewartSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1984-02-24· cited 18×
- Commonwealth v. StewartSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1978-07-12· cited 17×
- Commonwealth v. StewartMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1972-02-10· cited 16×
- Commonwealth v. StewartMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 2007-11-07· cited 16×
- Commonwealth v. StewartMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 2011-11-10· cited 16×
- Commonwealth v. StewartSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1972-03-24· cited 13×
- Commonwealth v. StewartSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1969-10-09· cited 12×
- Commonwealth v. StewartMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1996-04-04· cited 12×
- Commonwealth v. StewartSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1994-08-02· cited 9×
- Commonwealth v. StewartMassachusetts Appeals Court· 1991-05-14· cited 9×
- Commonwealth v. StewartSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1815-04-10· cited 9×
- Commonwealth v. StewartCommonwealth Court of Pennsylvania· 1987-07-01· cited 8×
- Commonwealth v. StewartSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2004-03-26· cited 8×
- Commonwealth v. StewartSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1988-06-01· cited 6×
- Commonwealth v. StewartSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1983-01-14· cited 6×
- Commonwealth v. StewartSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1988-09-12· cited 4×
- Commonwealth v. StewartMassachusetts Appeals Court· 2001-10-09· cited 4×
- Commonwealth v. StewartSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1917-03-07· cited 3×
- Commonwealth v. StewartSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2010-02-12· cited 2×
- Commonwealth v. StewartSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1910-12-12· cited 2×
- Commonwealth v. StewartSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1970-09-18· cited 2×
- Commonwealth v. StewartSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1977-02-02· cited 1×
- Commonwealth v. StewartSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1988-05-16· cited 1×
- Commonwealth v. StewartMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court· 1993-03-11· cited 1×
- Commonwealth v. StewartNorfolk County Circuit Court· 2000-10-17· cited 1×
- Commonwealth v. StewartPortsmouth County Circuit Court· 2004-10-22· cited 1×
- Commonwealth v. StewartMassachusetts Appeals Court· 2018-11-14
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.