Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1/19/2005
Commonwealth v. DiNicola
Citations
- 866 A.2d 329
- 581 Pa. 550
- 2005 Pa. LEXIS 117
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- recognizing the importance of context to a determination of whether revelation of pre-arrest silence was prejudicial
- stating that an appellant’s pre-arrest silence can be used in fair response to “trial counsel’s strategy ... questioning] the government’s preparation of its case”
- holding that the defendant opened the door to reference to his refusal to cooperate with police because his strategy at trial had been “to question the government’s preparation of its case, particularly in terms of the investigating trooper's pursuit of potentially exculpatory evidence”
- indicating if one prong of the Strickland/Pierce test is not met then a petitioner has not met his burden of demonstrating ineffectiveness
- finding no violation where the defendant’s silence “was not used in any fashion that was likely to burden Appellee's Fifth Amendment right or to create an inference of an admission of guilt.”
- stating when an appellant refuses an interview with police and also claims police conducted a deficient investigation, evidence of pre-arrest silence goes to show that the “investigation was obviously limited by [Appellant’s] decision to reject the request for an interview[ ]”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Cappy, Castille, Nigro, Newman, Saylor, Eakin, Lamb, Former
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
33 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Commonwealth v. SpotzSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2014-01-17· cited 986×
- Commonwealth v. WilliamsSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2006-04-21· cited 187×
- Commonwealth v. HarrisSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2005-09-30· cited 169×
- Commonwealth v. SpotzSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2005-03-29· cited 105×
- Commonwealth v. WallaceSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2005-03-29· cited 86×
- Commonwealth, Aplt. v. Molina, M.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2014-11-20· cited 78×
- Commonwealth v. AdamsSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2012-01-20· cited 72×
- Commonwealth v. ReedSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2012-02-27· cited 72×
- Commonwealth v. McCraeSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2003-09-29· cited 64×
- Commonwealth v. Adams, S., Aplt.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2014-11-20· cited 62×
- Commonwealth v. MolinaSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2011-11-09· cited 57×
- Commonwealth v. McGriffSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2017-04-21· cited 55×
- Commonwealth v. ElliottSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1997-08-20· cited 50×
- Commonwealth v. RuderSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2013-02-25· cited 45×
- Commonwealth v. Fant, R., Aplt.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2016-09-28· cited 35×
- Commonwealth v. FischereSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2013-07-16· cited 32×
- Commonwealth v. LettauSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2008-07-10· cited 29×
- Commonwealth v. LettauSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2009-12-29· cited 27×
- Commonwealth v. GuessSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2012-09-13· cited 27×
- Com. v. Rivera, J.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 2021-05-24· cited 22×
Cites
62 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Strickland v. WashingtonSupreme Court· 1984-06-25· cited 123,578×
- Miranda v. ArizonaSupreme Court· 1966-06-13· cited 58,288×
- United States v. CronicSupreme Court· 1984-05-14· cited 6,497×
- Doyle v. OhioSupreme Court· 1976-06-17· cited 4,773×
- Griffin v. CaliforniaSupreme Court· 1965-04-28· cited 4,680×
- Bell v. ConeSupreme Court· 2002-05-28· cited 4,309×
- Griffin v. CaliforniaSupreme Court· 1965-06-07· cited 4,088×
- Commonwealth v. PierceSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1987-06-09· cited 2,071×
- Dickerson v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2000-06-26· cited 1,932×
- Mickens v. TaylorSupreme Court· 2002-03-27· cited 1,451×
- Jenkins v. AndersonSupreme Court· 1980-06-10· cited 1,359×
- Commonwealth v. GrantSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2002-12-31· cited 1,205×
- Wainwright v. GreenfieldSupreme Court· 1986-01-14· cited 752×
- Fletcher v. WeirSupreme Court· 1982-03-23· cited 749×
- Helvering v. GowranSupreme Court· 1937-12-06· cited 748×
- United States v. RobinsonSupreme Court· 1988-02-24· cited 647×
- Commonwealth v. StarrSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1995-08-29· cited 545×
- Commonwealth v. TravagliaSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1995-06-23· cited 541×
- Commonwealth v. BomarSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2003-05-30· cited 478×
- Ronald Dean Combs v. Ralph CoyleSixth Circuit· 2000-02-23· cited 380×
Other cases named Commonwealth v. DiNicola
7 other CourtListener records share this case name.
- Commonwealth v. DiNicolaSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1983-12-06· cited 26×
- Commonwealth v. DiNicolaSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2000-04-18· cited 19×
- Commonwealth v. DiNicolaSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1985-12-20· cited 14×
- Commonwealth v. DinicolaSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2002-04-17· cited 10×
- Commonwealth v. DiNicolaSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1983-06-24· cited 6×
- Commonwealth v. DiNicolaSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 1985-12-06· cited 1×
- Commonwealth v. DinicolaSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2016-09-23
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.