Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 2/14/2011
Commonwealth Financial Systems, Inc. v. Smith
Citations
- 15 A.3d 492
- 2011 Pa. Super. 30
- 2011 Pa. Super. LEXIS 35
- 2011 WL 489704
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- finding that computer-generated billing statements and account information were not admissible under the business records exception where the proponent of the evidence failed to “establish circumstantial trustworthiness”
- explaining “regardless of a ‘nationwide trend’ and ‘clear federal precedent’ for allowing the introduction of business records consisting of documents generated by third parties, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court has not seen fit to adopt the rule of incorporation[]”
- “The record also supports the trial court’s finding that CFS failed to establish the- trustworthiness of its documents.”
- \Rule 803(6) requires the proponent of documentary evidence to establish circumstantial trustworthiness\
- affidavit of assignee debt buyer’s employee held inadmissible because there was no foundation testimony that the employee had personal knowledge of the “ ‘preparation and maintenance’ ’’ of the account statements and purported card agreement
- trial court acted within discretion - in finding documents proffered by appellant to be insufficiently authenticated and untrustworthy and thus inadmissible; custodial witness stated records had been qualified and had no further knowledge of records
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Musmanno, Panella, Shogan
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
18 cases in this archive cite this case.
- Parr, J. v. Ford Motor CompanySuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2014-12-22· cited 136×
- Commonwealth v. WalshSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2012-01-18· cited 112×
- U.S. Bank, N.A. Ex Rel. Bank of America, N.A. v. PautenisSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2015-05-29· cited 72×
- Keystone Dedicated Logistics, Inc. v. JGB Enterprises, Inc.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 2013-08-06· cited 70×
- Blumer v. Ford Motor Co.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 2011-05-06· cited 55×
- Bayview Loan Servicing LLC v. WickerSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2019-03-28· cited 33×
- MB Financial Bank v. Rao, J.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 2018-12-24· cited 13×
- Township of Bristol v. 1 Enterprises, LLCCommonwealth Court of Pennsylvania· 2018-01-05· cited 10×
- Unifund Ccr, Llc v. Amy ElyseCourt of Appeals of Washington· 2016-07-18· cited 4×
- Von Kiel v. U.S. Dept. of Health & Human Services (In re Von Kiel)E.D. Pennsylvania· 2012-06-19· cited 4×
- Sycamore Restaurant Group, LLC v. Stampfi Hartke Associates, LLCSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2017-07-12· cited 3×
- CreditOne, LLC v. SchofieldSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2016-01-20· cited 1×
- Citibank (S.D.), N.A. v. RhineerLancaster County Court of Common Pleas· 2013-04-26
- Sandin v. DempseyMontgomery County Court of Common Pleas· 2012-08-07
- Unifund Corp. v. SattarMonroe County Court of Common Pleas· 2014-05-09
- Commonwealth v. Wallace, J., Aplt.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 2023-02-22
- M.G. Molchan v. Mercer County TCBCommonwealth Court of Pennsylvania· 2024-07-16
- Hollinger, K. & L. v. Dietrich, J.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 2026-06-23
Cites
16 cases in this archive are cited by this case.
- Dilliplaine v. Lehigh Valley Trust Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1974-07-01· cited 817×
- United States v. Samuel Duncan, Jr., Grace Duncan, Gay Nell Duncan, Marshall Sutton, Angela F. Turner, Arthur D. Wilson, and Oscar L. WilsonFifth Circuit· 1991-01-16· cited 169×
- Eichman v. McKeonSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2003-05-07· cited 142×
- Callahan v. Pennsylvania State PoliceSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1981-07-08· cited 100×
- Linh Thanongsinh v. Board of Education, District U-46 and Hanan Javetz, Individually and in His Official CapacitySeventh Circuit· 2006-09-13· cited 89×
- Stumpf v. NyeSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2008-06-03· cited 88×
- United States v. AdefehintiD.C. Circuit· 2007-12-18· cited 83×
- American States Insurance v. Maryland Casualty Co.Superior Court of Pennsylvania· 1993-07-21· cited 77×
- In Re Estate of IndykSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1979-12-21· cited 54×
- Atlantic Credit & Finance, Inc. v. GiulianaSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2003-07-11· cited 44×
- Hall v. JacksonSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2001-11-28· cited 35×
- Croyle v. DellapeSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2003-09-04· cited 33×
- Geise v. Nationwide Life & Annuity Co. of AmericaSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2007-12-18· cited 22×
- Ganster v. Western Pennsylvania Water Co.Supreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1985-12-13· cited 19×
- Air Land Forwarders, Inc. v. United StatesFederal Claims· 1997-08-07· cited 5×
- Mietelski v. BanksSuperior Court of Pennsylvania· 2004-07-08· cited 4×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.