Colegrove v. Green
Citations
- 328 U.S. 549
- 66 S. Ct. 1198
- 90 L. Ed. 1432
- 1946 U.S. LEXIS 2179
About this case
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
1946 United States Supreme Court case
Colegrove v. Green, 328 U.S. 549 (1946), was a United States Supreme Court case. Writing for a 4–3 plurality, Justice Felix Frankfurter held that the federal judiciary had no power to interfere with malapportioned Congressional districts.[1] [2] [3] The Court held that the Elections Clause in Article I, section IV of the U.S. Constitution left to the legislature of each state the authority to establish the time, place, and manner of holding elections for Congressional Representatives, and that only Congress (and thus not the federal judiciary) could determine whether individual state legislatures had fulfilled their responsibility to secure fair representation for citizens.[4]
However, in _Baker v. Carr _, 369 U.S. 186 (1962) the United States Supreme Court distinguished the Colegrove decision holding that malapportionment claims under the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment were not exempt from judicial review under Article IV, Section 4 , as the equal protection issue in this case was separate from any political questions.
The "one person, one vote " doctrine which requires electoral districts to be apportioned according to population, thus making each district roughly equal in population, was further cemented in the cases that followed Baker v. Carr, including _Gray v. Sanders _, 372 U.S. 368 (1963), which concerned state county districts; _Reynolds v. Sims _, 377 U.S. 533 (1964), which concerned state legislature districts; _Wesberry v. Sanders _, 376 U.S. 1 (1964), which concerned U.S. Congressional districts; and _Avery v. Midland County _, 390 U.S. 474 (1968), which concerned local government districts, a decision which was upheld in _Board of Estimate of City of New York v. Morris _, 489 U.S. 688 (1989).[5]
Ruling
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Colegrove_v._Green&action=edit§ion=1 "Edit section: Ruling")
]
Colegrove arose from the failure of Illinois to redistrict its Congressional delegation since 1901, despite internal migration that had left wide population disparities between various districts.[2] Three voters sued, asserting what would now be known as malapportionment : a rural county of 1,000 and an urban county of 100,000 would have an equal vote.[2]
The court characterized the case as "an appeal to the federal courts to reconstruct the electoral process of Illinois in order that it may be adequately represented in the councils of the Nation. Because the Illinois legislature has failed to revise its Congressional Representative districts in order to reflect great changes, during more than a generation, in the distribution of its population, we are asked to do this, as it were, for Illinois." The court decided that this was a nonjusticiable question: "The remedy for unfairness in districting is to secure State legislatures that will apportion properly, or to invoke the ample powers of Congress."[2]
Dissent by Justice Black
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Colegrove_v._Green&action=edit§ion=2 "Edit section: Dissent by Justice Black")
]
Dissenting, Justice Hugo Black argued that the Constitution required each citizen's vote carry equal weight.[6] "While the Constitution contains no express provision requiring that congressional election districts established by the States must contain approximately equal populations," Black wrote, "the constitutionally guaranteed right to vote, and the right to have one's vote counted clearly imply the policy that state election systems, no matter what their form, should be designed to give approximately equal weight to each vote cast."[2] Black thought it wrong that a citizen living in a district of 900,000 people had a much smaller percentage of a vote than someone living in a district with 112,000.[6]
Plurality opinion
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Colegrove_v._Green&action=edit§ion=3 "Edit section: Plurality opinion")
]
The Colegrove case was decided by a 4–3 plurality. Plurality opinions result when a majority of Justices (usually five or more but in this rare occasion, four) agree on the result in a particular case but no single rationale or opinion garners five votes.[7] The case was voted on by seven rather than nine justices because Chief Justice Stone had just died, and Justice Robert Jackson had taken leave to serve as chief prosecutor of the Nuremberg Trials .[6]
Aftermath
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Colegrove_v._Green&action=edit§ion=4 "Edit section: Aftermath")
]
The plaintiff responded with a second suit demonstrating that the Illinois State Legislature districts were even more malapportioned than the Congressional districts (so how then was he to succeed in using either the powers of State Legislatures or Congress when they are both heavily biased against him?). This second case arrived as appeal to the Supreme Court in Colegrove v. Barrett, 330 U.S. 804 (1947) for which Frankfurter was with the majority again issuing Per Curiam dismissal for want of a substantial federal question.
Critics of Colegrove complained that it deprived state citizens of federal remedies, and that the outdated apportionments – dating to 1901, 45 years prior[2] – were the vehicle by which rural, conservative interests were allowed to keep a disproportionate influence over the country's politics.[2] Until it was overruled by Baker, Colegrove made it almost impossible for citizens' groups to get help from the federal courts in apportioning legislative and congressional districts.[6]
An exception to the reach of Colegrove was allowed in a 1960 case called _Gomillion v. Lightfoot _, in which the appellants showed that the boundary lines of a district in Alabama had deliberately been drawn to minimize the voting rights of black residents.[6] Frankfurter wrote the opinion in this case as well, making sure that Colegrove would not be seen as allowing blatant racial gerrymandering by recasting the issue as a Fifteenth Amendment case.[8]
One week after the Gomillion ruling was handed down, Justice Black persuaded his colleagues to hear arguments in _Baker v. Carr _, the case which would ultimately overrule Colegrove.[9]
See also
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Colegrove_v._Green&action=edit§ion=5 "Edit section: See also")
]
References
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Colegrove_v._Green&action=edit§ion=6 "Edit section: References")
]
- ↑ Katz, Ellis. 2006. "Colegrove v. Green ." Federalism in America: An Encyclopedia.
- 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Colegrove v. Green, 328 U.S. [549](https://supreme.justia.com/cases/fede
…
Editorial context from Wikipedia (CC-BY-SA 4.0).
Judges: Frankfurter, Rutledge, Black, Jackson, Douglas, Murpht
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
250 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Baker v. CarrSupreme Court· 1962-03-26· cited 6,173×
- Reynolds v. SimsSupreme Court· 1964-10-12· cited 3,703×
- District of Columbia v. HellerSupreme Court· 2008-06-26· cited 3,086×
- Republican Party of North Carolina v. MartinFourth Circuit· 1992-11-24· cited 1,890×
- Skelly Oil Co. v. Phillips Petroleum Co.Supreme Court· 1950-06-05· cited 1,625×
- Williams v. RhodesSupreme Court· 1968-10-15· cited 1,576×
- New York v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1992-06-19· cited 1,301×
- Public Serv. Comm'n of Utah v. Wycoff Co.Supreme Court· 1952-12-22· cited 1,215×
- Wesberry v. SandersSupreme Court· 1964-02-17· cited 1,150×
- Gomillion v. LightfootSupreme Court· 1960-11-14· cited 1,079×
- Gray v. SandersSupreme Court· 1963-03-18· cited 785×
- Moore v. OgilvieSupreme Court· 1969-06-16· cited 714×
- Rescue Army v. Municipal Court of Los AngelesSupreme Court· 1947-06-09· cited 667×
- Oregon v. MitchellSupreme Court· 1970-12-21· cited 575×
- Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health OrganizationSupreme Court· 2022-06-24· cited 482×
- Rogers v. LodgeSupreme Court· 1982-10-04· cited 451×
- Vieth v. JubelirerSupreme Court· 2004-04-28· cited 394×
- Davis v. BandemerSupreme Court· 1986-06-30· cited 371×
- Karcher v. DaggettSupreme Court· 1983-06-22· cited 353×
- Shaw v. HuntSupreme Court· 1996-06-13· cited 323×
Cites
29 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Bell v. HoodSupreme Court· 1946-04-01· cited 4,157×
- Haguer v. Committee for Industrial OrganizationSupreme Court· 1939-06-05· cited 2,178×
- United States v. ClassicSupreme Court· 1941-10-13· cited 2,081×
- Smith v. TexasSupreme Court· 1941-01-08· cited 711×
- United States v. LovettSupreme Court· 1946-06-03· cited 654×
- Great Lakes Dredge & Dock Co. v. HuffmanSupreme Court· 1943-05-24· cited 645×
- Coleman v. MillerSupreme Court· 1939-06-05· cited 641×
- Ex Parte YarbroughSupreme Court· 1884-03-03· cited 548×
- Lane v. WilsonSupreme Court· 1939-05-22· cited 476×
- Matthews v. RodgersSupreme Court· 1932-02-15· cited 474×
- Sterling v. ConstantinSupreme Court· 1932-12-12· cited 368×
- Nixon v. HerndonSupreme Court· 1927-03-21· cited 329×
- McPherson v. BlackerSupreme Court· 1892-10-17· cited 312×
- Nashville, C. & St. LR Co. v. WallaceSupreme Court· 1933-02-06· cited 291×
- Smiley v. HolmSupreme Court· 1932-04-11· cited 285×
- American Federation of Labor v. WatsonSupreme Court· 1946-03-25· cited 277×
- Nixon v. CondonSupreme Court· 1932-05-02· cited 274×
- Nashville, Chattanooga & St. Louis Railway Co. v. WallaceSupreme Court· 1933-02-06· cited 247×
- United States v. MosleySupreme Court· 1915-06-21· cited 241×
- United States v. GradwellSupreme Court· 1917-04-09· cited 176×
Other cases named Colegrove v. Green
3 other CourtListener records share this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.