Ninth Circuit· 10/28/2009
Brodheim v. Cry
Citations
- 584 F.3d 1262
- 2009 U.S. App. LEXIS 23721
- 2009 WL 3448411
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that retaliation against prisoners for exercising their First Amendment right to file grievances “is itself a constitutional violation”
- holding that a \mere threat of harm can be an adverse action\ if issued in retaliation for a prisoner’s use of grievance procedures
- concluding that 15 plaintiff’s protected conduct must be the “substantial” or “motivating” factor for defendant’s 16 conduct
- holding that the statement, “I’d also 21 like to warn you to be careful what you write, req[u]est on this form,” was an adverse action
- holding that “the mere threat of harm can be an adverse action, regardless of whether it is carried out” in a case involving a First Amendment retaliation claim
- holding that 4 defendant’s warning “to be careful what you write, req[u]est on this form,” in response to a 5 grievance filing, met the causation and protected conduct elements
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Reinhardt, Bea, Larson
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
44 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Raymond Watison v. Mary CarterNinth Circuit· 2012-02-13· cited 2,138×
- Patrick Booker v. South Carolina Department of CorrectionsFourth Circuit· 2017-04-28· cited 668×
- Clarence Jones v. Max WilliamsNinth Circuit· 2015-06-26· cited 422×
- Watkins v. KasperSeventh Circuit· 2010-03-31· cited 235×
- James McBride v. S. LopezNinth Circuit· 2015-11-24· cited 181×
- John Entler v. Christine GregoireNinth Circuit· 2017-10-06· cited 143×
- Grenning v. KlemmeE.D. Washington· 2014-07-22· cited 94×
- Lamont Shepard v. T. QuillenNinth Circuit· 2016-10-26· cited 92×
- Edward Furnace v. G. GiurbinoNinth Circuit· 2016-09-29· cited 69×
- Gonzales v. California Department of CorrectionsNinth Circuit· 2014-01-15· cited 66×
- Daniel Chavez v. David RobinsonNinth Circuit· 2021-09-08· cited 53×
- Riley's American Heritage Farm v. James ElsasserNinth Circuit· 2022-03-17· cited 53×
- ADAM BROS. FARMING v. County of Santa BarbaraNinth Circuit· 2010-05-14· cited 49×
- Davis v. PowellS.D. California· 2012-10-04· cited 41×
- Twitter, Inc. v. Ken PaxtonNinth Circuit· 2022-03-02· cited 34×
- De Witt Long v. SugaiNinth Circuit· 2024-02-05· cited 30×
- Rodriguez v. Lockheed Martin Corp.Ninth Circuit· 2010-11-30· cited 21×
- Quiroz v. HorelN.D. California· 2015-03-31· cited 19×
- Mattei v. DunbarD. Massachusetts· 2016-11-08· cited 17×
- Filmore v. WalkerAppellate Court of Illinois· 2013-04-17· cited 16×
Cites
25 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Bell v. WolfishSupreme Court· 1979-05-14· cited 11,438×
- Turner v. SafleySupreme Court· 1987-06-01· cited 6,491×
- Migra v. Warren City School District Board of EducationSupreme Court· 1984-01-23· cited 3,103×
- Rhodes v. RobinsonNinth Circuit· 2005-04-25· cited 1,970×
- Lee Max Barnett v. Helen Centoni, Correctional Officer, San Quentin State Prison S. Donahue, Correctional Officer, San Quentin State PrisonNinth Circuit· 1994-07-27· cited 1,314×
- Elmer PRATT, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. James K. ROWLAND; James Gomez, Director; Daniel Vasquez; Robert Borg, Et Al., Defendants-AppellantsNinth Circuit· 1995-09-18· cited 957×
- Shakur v. SchriroNinth Circuit· 2008-01-23· cited 858×
- Yanowitz v. L'OREAL USA, INC.California Supreme Court· 2005-08-11· cited 838×
- Shaw v. MurphySupreme Court· 2001-04-18· cited 586×
- People v. DuvallCalifornia Supreme Court· 1995-01-19· cited 405×
- Nano Maldonado v. Tony Harris, in His Capacity as Acting Director of the California Department of TransportationNinth Circuit· 2004-06-04· cited 395×
- Agarwal v. JohnsonCalifornia Supreme Court· 1979-12-07· cited 357×
- Hines v. GomezNinth Circuit· 1997-03-07· cited 317×
- Gomez v. VernonNinth Circuit· 2001-07-10· cited 279×
- Bruce v. YlstNinth Circuit· 2003-12-10· cited 230×
- Bradley v. HallNinth Circuit· 1995-08-23· cited 192×
- Jones-Hamilton Co., a California Corporation v. Beazer Materials & Services, Inc. Kop-Coat, Inc., a Pennsylvania Corporation Koppers Company, Inc.Ninth Circuit· 1992-08-24· cited 140×
- San Diego Police Officers' Ass'n v. San Diego City Employees' Retirement SystemNinth Circuit· 2009-06-10· cited 138×
- Grisham v. Philip Morris U.S.A., Inc.California Supreme Court· 2007-02-15· cited 138×
- Citizens for Open Access to Sand and Tide, Inc. v. Seadrift Ass'nCalifornia Court of Appeal· 1998-01-14· cited 126×
Other cases named Brodheim v. Cry
1 other CourtListener record shares this case name.
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.