Bott v. DeLand

How courts have described this case

Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.

• holding that plaintiff had money damages claim for violation of “unnecessary rigor” clause of Utah Constitution, which is similar to cruel and unusual punishment section of federal constitution
• stating that rights granted to citizens under the Utah Constitution \are subject to reasonable regulation\
• recognizing “the guarantee against unnecessarily rigorous treatment extends both to prisoners and to arrestees and protects them against unnecessary abuse”
• stating that there was no violation of the unnecessary rigor clause where arresting officers provided medical treatment for a fractured leg several hours after an arrest
• stating that there was no violation of the unnecessary rigor clause where arresting officers provided medical treatment for a fractured leg several hours after an arrest
• holding a private cause of action could be brought for a violation of the unnecessary-rigor clause in the Utah Constitution

Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).

Cited by

38 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.

• Binette v. Sabo
  Supreme Court of Connecticut· 1998-03-10· cited 161×
• Spackman Ex Rel. Spackman v. Board of Education
  Utah Supreme Court· 2000-10-31· cited 103×
• State v. Lafferty
  Utah Supreme Court· 2001-02-23· cited 89×
• Lyon v. Burton
  Utah Supreme Court· 2000-01-19· cited 88×
• Christopher J. Godfrey v. State of Iowa Terry Branstad, Governor of the State of Iowa, Individually and in His Official Capacity Kimberly Reynolds, Lieutenant Governor of the State of Iowa, Individually and in Her Official Capacity Jeffrey Boeyink, Chief of Staff to the Governor of the State of Iowa, Individually and in His Official Capacity Brenna Findley, Legal Counsel to the Governor of The
  Supreme Court of Iowa· 2017-06-30· cited 80×
• Craftsman Builder's Supply, Inc. v. Butler Manufacturing Co.
  Utah Supreme Court· 1999-03-05· cited 71×
• Gallivan v. Walker
  Utah Supreme Court· 2002-08-26· cited 70×
• Cheves v. Williams
  Utah Supreme Court· 1999-09-10· cited 56×
• Winward v. State
  Utah Supreme Court· 2012-12-07· cited 56×
• Jensen v. Intermountain Power Agency
  Utah Supreme Court· 1999-02-02· cited 52×
• Dorwart v. Caraway
  Montana Supreme Court· 2002-10-30· cited 50×
• Dexter v. Bosko
  Utah Supreme Court· 2008-04-11· cited 46×
• State v. Herrera
  Utah Supreme Court· 1999-06-29· cited 43×
• Benjamin v. Washington State Bar Ass'n
  Washington Supreme Court· 1999-07-22· cited 43×
• State v. Gardner
  Utah Supreme Court· 1997-09-30· cited 37×
• Hart v. Salt Lake County Commission
  Court of Appeals of Utah· 1997-08-28· cited 34×
• Ryan Harvey, Rocks Off, Inc. v. Ute Indian Tribe of the Uintah
  Utah Supreme Court· 2017-11-07· cited 28×
• Ross v. Schackel
  Utah Supreme Court· 1996-07-12· cited 21×
• State v. Davis
  Court of Appeals of Utah· 1998-08-06· cited 20×
• State v. Schweitzer
  Court of Appeals of Utah· 1997-07-31· cited 15×

Cites

61 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.

• Monell v. New York City Dept. of Social Servs.
  Supreme Court· 1978-06-06· cited 41,449×
• Estelle v. Gamble
  Supreme Court· 1976-11-30· cited 28,035×
• Wolff v. McDonnell
  Supreme Court· 1974-06-26· cited 12,327×
• Gregg v. Georgia
  Supreme Court· 1976-07-22· cited 7,936×
• Whitley v. Albers
  Supreme Court· 1986-03-04· cited 6,155×
• Monroe v. Pape
  Supreme Court· 1961-02-20· cited 4,784×
• Pierson v. Ray
  Supreme Court· 1967-04-11· cited 4,282×
• Carlson v. Green
  Supreme Court· 1980-04-22· cited 2,910×
• Price v. Johnston
  Supreme Court· 1948-05-24· cited 1,320×
• Billy R. Shapley v. Nevada Board of State Prison Commissioners, an Administrative Body
  Ninth Circuit· 1985-07-16· cited 869×
• Carrol Richard Olson v. Gary Stotts, Secretary of Corrections David R. McKune Warden Joan Finney, Governor the State of Kansas
  Tenth Circuit· 1993-11-16· cited 292×
• Berry v. City of Muskogee
  Tenth Circuit· 1990-04-10· cited 256×
• People v. Western Air Lines, Inc.
  California Supreme Court· 1954-04-02· cited 247×
• Moresi v. State, Dept. of Wildlife & Fisheries
  Supreme Court of Louisiana· 1990-09-06· cited 245×
• Nathaniel Williams v. Leon J. Vincent, Superintendent of Green Haven Correctional Facility
  Second Circuit· 1974-12-30· cited 228×
• Sterling v. Cupp
  Oregon Supreme Court· 1981-03-04· cited 206×
• State v. Moen
  Oregon Supreme Court· 1990-01-11· cited 189×
• Supre v. Ricketts
  Tenth Circuit· 1986-06-02· cited 188×
• Wright v. Central Du Page Hospital Ass'n
  Illinois Supreme Court· 1976-05-14· cited 182×
• Davis v. Burke
  Supreme Court· 1900-12-17· cited 180×