Third Circuit· 4/20/2010
United States v. Merced
Citations
- 603 F.3d 203
- 2010 U.S. App. LEXIS 8141
- 2010 WL 1542263
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- finding that, though there is no “mandatory script for sentencing,” the District Court must demonstrate that it has carefully considered and analyzed the sentencing factors
- explaining that “[i]f the district court commits procedural error, our preferred course is to remand the case for re-sentencing without going any further.” (citation and footnote omitted)
- requiring remand where Merced’s sentence was 128 months less than what a similarly situated defendant could expect to receive under the circumstances and there was no explicit discussion or indication in the record that the district court considered this disparity
- meaningful consideration requires the District Court to acknowledge and respond to any properly presented sentencing argument, and “a ‘brief’ statement of reasons can be ‘legally sufficient.’” (quoting Rita v. United States, 551 U.S. 338, 358 (2007))
- “[T]he broad substantive discretion afforded district courts ... makes adherence to procedural sentencing requirements all the more important.”
- “If the district court commits procedural error, our preferred course is to remand the case for re-sentencing, without going any further.”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Ambro, Smith, Michel
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
30 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- United States v. Jose Flores-MejiaThird Circuit· 2014-07-16· cited 249×
- United States v. FumoThird Circuit· 2011-08-23· cited 110×
- United States v. GroberThird Circuit· 2010-10-26· cited 91×
- United States v. FriedmanThird Circuit· 2011-09-28· cited 83×
- United States v. LenteTenth Circuit· 2011-07-29· cited 78×
- United States v. Henry FreemanThird Circuit· 2014-08-18· cited 71×
- United States v. Blaine HanderhanThird Circuit· 2014-01-07· cited 66×
- United States v. Michael BeginThird Circuit· 2012-10-09· cited 62×
- United States v. Daniel SiddonsThird Circuit· 2011-10-05· cited 60×
- United States v. WrightThird Circuit· 2011-06-01· cited 59×
- United States v. KlugerThird Circuit· 2013-07-09· cited 52×
- United States v. Patricia FountainThird Circuit· 2015-07-10· cited 49×
- United States v. MaurerThird Circuit· 2011-04-22· cited 47×
- United States v. Michael Seibert, Jr.Third Circuit· 2020-08-19· cited 44×
- United States v. Theresa ThornhillThird Circuit· 2014-07-08· cited 43×
- United States v. Carlo CastroThird Circuit· 2013-01-08· cited 42×
- United States v. NegroniThird Circuit· 2011-03-29· cited 41×
- United States v. Francisco Azcona-PolancoThird Circuit· 2017-07-27· cited 39×
- United States v. Jermel LewisThird Circuit· 2015-09-16· cited 29×
- United States v. Maximo Mateo-MedinaThird Circuit· 2017-01-09· cited 23×
Cites
34 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- United States v. BookerSupreme Court· 2004-10-01· cited 23,210×
- Gall v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2007-12-10· cited 20,598×
- Rita v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2007-06-21· cited 7,739×
- Kimbrough v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2007-12-10· cited 3,379×
- United States v. CaveraSecond Circuit· 2008-12-04· cited 1,656×
- United States v. TomkoThird Circuit· 2009-04-17· cited 1,020×
- United States v. Lydia CooperThird Circuit· 2006-02-14· cited 959×
- United States v. Sean Michael GrierThird Circuit· 2007-02-05· cited 823×
- United States v. Brian A. Moreland, United States of America v. Brian A. MorelandFourth Circuit· 2006-02-22· cited 576×
- United States v. Johnny GunterThird Circuit· 2006-09-11· cited 572×
- Spears v. United StatesSupreme Court· 2009-01-21· cited 508×
- United States v. MartinFirst Circuit· 2008-03-21· cited 412×
- United States v. Ronald BungarThird Circuit· 2007-03-05· cited 287×
- United States v. LessnerThird Circuit· 2007-08-08· cited 283×
- Swift & Co. v. Hocking Valley Railway Co.Supreme Court· 1917-03-06· cited 264×
- United States v. LevinsonThird Circuit· 2008-09-18· cited 228×
- United States v. SharkeyTenth Circuit· 2008-10-07· cited 211×
- United States v. CornerSeventh Circuit· 2010-03-17· cited 185×
- United States v. Dorcely, DanielD.C. Circuit· 2006-07-21· cited 136×
- United States v. GoffThird Circuit· 2007-08-30· cited 125×
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.