Thompson v. Clark
Citations
- 596 U.S. 36
- 142 S. Ct. 1332
About this case
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
2022 United States Supreme Court case
Thompson v. Clark, 596 U.S. 36 (2022), was a United States Supreme Court case in which the court held that, to demonstrate a favorable termination of a criminal prosecution for malicious prosecution , a plaintiff need not show that the criminal prosecution ended with some affirmative indication of innocence. A plaintiff need only show that his prosecution ended without a conviction. The 6–3 opinion was authored by Justice Brett Kavanaugh . Justice Samuel Alito dissented from the majority opinion and was joined by Justices Thomas and Gorsuch. Media coverage of the decision portrayed the Court's ruling as a victory for civil rights lawsuits.
Background
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Thompson_v._Clark&action=edit§ion=1 "Edit section: Background")
]
Larry Thompson, a Navy veteran and postal worker, lived with his fiancée and newborn daughter in an apartment in Brooklyn, New York. When Thompson's daughter was one week old, his sister-in-law called 911 and accused Thompson of sexually abusing the child. Four police officers were dispatched to Thompson's house to investigate but Thompson refused to let them in without a search warrant. In response, the four officers forced their way into Thompson's home and attempted to restrain Thompson. Thompson resisted, was taken into custody for two days, and was subsequently charged with resisting arrest. Further investigation by law enforcement revealed no signs of child abuse. Rather than prosecute Thompson for resisting arrest, the prosecution opted to dismiss the charges. Neither the prosecutor or the judge offered any explanation as to why the charges were dismissed.[1]
Following the dismissal of his criminal charges, Thompson filed suit against the officers responsible for arresting him under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 and alleging, among other things, that he had been maliciously prosecuted in violation of his Fourth Amendment rights, which provided the right against unlawful seizures. Thompson's claims were dismissed at the trial level and his appeal to the Second Circuit Court of Appeals was similarly denied as both courts held that, under existing precedent, Thompson was required to show that he had been affirmatively found innocent of committing the underlying crime. On November 6, 2020, Thompson filed a petition for a writ of certiorari , which was granted on March 8, 2021.[2] During the October 12, 2021, oral argument, the justices posed a series of hypotheticals involving the fictional character of Jean Valjean and the mythological centaur .[3]
Decision
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Thompson_v._Clark&action=edit§ion=2 "Edit section: Decision")
]
On April 4, 2022, the Supreme Court released a 6–3 opinion authored by Justice Kavanaugh holding that Thompson was not required to show that he had been affirmatively exonerated of committing the alleged crime and, instead, "need only show that his prosecution ended without a conviction." After analyzing the historical precedent, the majority opinion concluded that the general rule is that if a criminal proceeding was terminated prior to securing a conviction, the termination could be treated as favorable to the accused. The majority further held that this conclusion was consistent with the purpose and values of the Fourth Amendment as, otherwise, the Fourth Amendment could be violated with impunity, so long as the prosecutor did not explain why the charge had been dropped. With this holding pronounced, the Court remanded the case for further proceedings regarding whether Thompson had been "seized" under the Fourth Amendment, whether the officers had probable cause to enter Thompson's home without a warrant, and whether any of the officers were entitled to qualified immunity.[4]
Justice Alito dissented from the majority's holding, arguing that Court had improperly combined precedent from different legal contexts in order to reach its conclusion. Instead, the dissent argued that Thompson should have pursued alternative constitutional claims, rather than ones under the Fourth Amendment.[4]
Reaction
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Thompson_v._Clark&action=edit§ion=3 "Edit section: Reaction")
]
Immediate media reaction to the Court's decision portrayed the ruling as victory for plaintiffs asserting civil rights claims against law enforcement officers.[5] [6]
References
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Thompson_v._Clark&action=edit§ion=4 "Edit section: References")
]
- ↑ Liptak, Adam (April 4, 2022). "Supreme Court Rules Against Police in Malicious Prosecution Case" . The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331 . Retrieved April 4, 2022.
- ↑ "Thompson v. Clark" . SCOTUSblog. Retrieved April 4, 2022.
- ↑ "Centaurs, Jean Valjean, and a proposed three-sentence ruling on the meaning of favorable termination" . SCOTUSblog. October 13, 2021. Retrieved April 4, 2022.
- 1 2 "Criminal proceedings reach "favorable termination" when they end without conviction" . SCOTUSblog. April 4, 2022. Retrieved April 5, 2022.
- ↑ "Supreme Court Rules for Plaintiffs on Civil-Rights Suits (1)" . news.bloomberglaw.com. Retrieved April 4, 2022.
- ↑ Poggio, Marco (April 4, 2022). "Justices Nix Need For Rulings Of Innocence In Anti-Cop Suits – Law360" . www.law360.com. Retrieved April 5, 2022.
External links
[(https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Thompson_v._Clark&action=edit§ion=5 "Edit section: External links")
]
- Text of Thompson v. Clark, No. 20-659, 596 U.S. ___ (2022) is available from: Internet Archive (docket files) Justia Oyez (oral argument audio) Supreme Court (slip opinion)
This article incorporates written opinion of a United States federal court . As a work of the U.S. federal government , the text is in the **public domain **.
United States Fourth Amendment case law
Scope of the Fourth Amendment
Definition of search
- _Boyd v. United States _ (1886)
- _United States v. Lee _ (1927)
- _Olmstead v. United States _ (1928)
- _Abel v. United States _ (1960)
- _Silverman v. United States _ (1961)
- _Katz v. United States _ (1967)
- _United States v. Knotts _ (1983)
- _United States v. Place _ (1983)
- _United States v. Karo _ (1984)
- _California v. Greenwood _ (1988)
- _Skinner v. Railway Labor Executives Ass'n _ (1989)
- _United States v. Verdugo-Urquidez _ (1990)
- _Bond v. United States _ (2000)
- _Kyllo v. United States _ (2001)
- _Illinois v. Caballes _ (2005)
- _United States v. Jones _ (2012)
- _Florida v. Jardines _ (2013)
- _Klayman v. Obama _ (D.D.C. 2013)
- _American Civil Liberties Union v. Clapper
…
Editorial context from Wikipedia (CC-BY-SA 4.0).
How courts have described this case
Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.
- holding that “favorable termination” is satisfied so long as the prosecution ended without a conviction; no “affirmative indication of innocence” is required
- holding that “[a] plaintiff need only show that the criminal prosecution ended without a conviction” to satisfy the favorable termination requirement
- holding that plaintiff must show a favorable termination of the criminal prosecution to bring a claim of malicious prosecution under the Fourth Amendment
- holding that plaintiff must show a favorable termination of the criminal prosecution to bring a claim of malicious prosecution
- holding that the Supreme Court’s precedents recognize a malicious-prosecution claim under the Fourth Amendment but again not deciding the scope of the amendment
- recognizing that “[t]he granting of certiorari serve[s] to alert litigants of a potential change in the law”
Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).
Judges: Brett Kavanaugh
Read full opinion on CourtListenerCited by
61 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Armstrong v. AshleyFifth Circuit· 2023-02-15· cited 156×
- Bledsoe v. Board Cty Comm. Jefferson KSTenth Circuit· 2022-11-15· cited 116×
- Chiaverini v. City of NapoleonSupreme Court· 2024-06-20· cited 86×
- Barnes v. City of New YorkSecond Circuit· 2023-05-22· cited 76×
- Guerra v. CastilloFifth Circuit· 2023-09-07· cited 56×
- Shrum v. CookeTenth Circuit· 2023-02-28· cited 45×
- Anthony Novak v. City of Parma, OhioSixth Circuit· 2022-04-29· cited 41×
- Lisa Price v. Montgomery CountySixth Circuit· 2023-07-05· cited 38×
- Brian Towne v. Karen DonnellySeventh Circuit· 2022-08-11· cited 32×
- Benfer v. City of BaytownFifth Circuit· 2024-11-01· cited 31×
- Horace Crump v. Jane BlueSixth Circuit· 2024-11-15· cited 30×
- Radiya Buchanan v. William BarrD.C. Circuit· 2023-06-23· cited 29×
- Marc Susselman v. Washtenaw Cnty. Sheriff's OfficeSixth Circuit· 2024-07-29· cited 25×
- Johnetta Carr v. Louisville-Jefferson Cnty., Ky.Sixth Circuit· 2022-06-16· cited 24×
- Michael Jones v. City of St. LouisEighth Circuit· 2024-06-17· cited 23×
- Jorge Rivera-Guadalupe v. City of HarrisburgThird Circuit· 2024-12-24· cited 23×
- Hughes v. GarciaFifth Circuit· 2024-05-03· cited 22×
- Brenda Jones v. Brent YorkSeventh Circuit· 2022-05-16· cited 21×
- Dylan Mitchell v. Eugene DohertySeventh Circuit· 2022-06-22· cited 19×
- Michael Klein v. Warren SteinkampEighth Circuit· 2022-08-16· cited 19×
Cites
28 cases in this archive are cited by this case; the 20 most cited are listed.
- Heck v. HumphreySupreme Court· 1994-06-24· cited 15,294×
- Whren v. United StatesSupreme Court· 1996-05-15· cited 7,105×
- Albright v. OliverSupreme Court· 1994-01-24· cited 7,028×
- Wallace v. KatoSupreme Court· 2007-02-21· cited 4,908×
- Gerstein v. PughSupreme Court· 1975-02-18· cited 4,350×
- United States v. Detroit Timber & Lumber Co.Supreme Court· 1906-02-19· cited 1,300×
- Manuel v. City of JolietSupreme Court· 2017-03-21· cited 1,069×
- Sykes v. AndersonSixth Circuit· 2010-11-09· cited 670×
- Lanning v. City of Glens FallsSecond Circuit· 2018-11-07· cited 283×
- Kossler v. CrisantiThird Circuit· 2009-04-21· cited 278×
- Hernandez-Cuevas v. TaylorFirst Circuit· 2013-07-17· cited 220×
- Michael Durham v. David HornerFourth Circuit· 2012-08-08· cited 200×
- Christopher G. Pitt, Sr. And Tela Hansom-Pitt v. District of ColumbiaD.C. Circuit· 2007-06-26· cited 148×
- Myers v. KoopmanTenth Circuit· 2013-12-20· cited 127×
- Cordova v. City of AlbuquerqueTenth Circuit· 2016-03-08· cited 84×
- David Jones v. Clark Cty., Ky.Sixth Circuit· 2020-05-18· cited 82×
- Joy Laskar, PH.D. v. Phillip W. HurdEleventh Circuit· 2020-08-28· cited 62×
- Jordan v. Town of WaldoboroFirst Circuit· 2019-11-27· cited 36×
- Pagan-Gonzalez v. MorenoFirst Circuit· 2019-03-22· cited 31×
- Burhans v. Sanford & BrownNew York Supreme Court· 1838-05-15· cited 31×
Other cases named Thompson v. Clark
12 other CourtListener records share this case name.
- Thompson v. ClarkE.D. New York· 2019-03-12· cited 16×
- Thompson v. ClarkSupreme Court of Virginia· 1886-02-11· cited 12×
- Thompson v. ClarkCalifornia Supreme Court· 1936-05-01· cited 10×
- Thompson v. ClarkSupreme Court of Pennsylvania· 1867-10-28· cited 7×
- Thompson v. ClarkDistrict of Columbia Court of Appeals· 1948-09-21· cited 3×
- Thompson v. ClarkSupreme Court of Arkansas· 1953-04-20· cited 3×
- Thompson v. ClarkDistrict of Columbia Court of Appeals· 1949-01-26· cited 2×
- Thompson v. ClarkE.D. New York· 2019-02-12· cited 1×
- Thompson v. ClarkCalifornia Supreme Court· 1936-05-01
- Thompson v. ClarkSupreme Court· 1971-12-07
- Thompson v. ClarkSupreme Court· 1974-11-11
- Thompson v. ClarkSupreme Court· 1974-12-23
Sourced from CourtListener / Free Law Project (CC0).
This is legal information, not legal advice. Laws vary by jurisdiction and change frequently. Always verify current law with official sources and consult a licensed attorney in your jurisdiction for advice on your specific situation.