Thomas L. Apple v. John Glenn, U.S. Senator

How courts have described this case

Verbatim parenthetical descriptions written by other courts when citing this decision. Ranked by citation-network relevance.

• “Tingler’s requirement that a plaintiff be given the opportunity to amend does not apply to sua sponte dismissals for lack of jurisdiction pursuant to Hagans.”
• “Tingler’s requirement that a plaintiff be given the opportunity to amend does not apply to sua sponte dismissals for lack of jurisdiction pursuant to Hagans.”
• “A citizen’s right to petition the government does not guarantee a response to the petition or the right to compel government officials to act on or adopt a citizen’s views.”
• “A citizen's right to petition the 4 government does not guarantee a response to the petition or the right to compel government 5 officials to act on or adopt a citizen's views.”

Source: CourtListener parenthetical corpus (CC0).

Cited by

67 cases in this archive cite this case; the 20 most cited are listed.

• Carrier Corporation v. Outokumpu Oyj
  Sixth Circuit· 2012-03-02· cited 255×
• Haines v. Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration
  Sixth Circuit· 2016-02-18· cited 81×
• CHKRS, LLC v. City of Dublin, Ohio
  Sixth Circuit· 2021-01-04· cited 67×
• Danforth v. Celebrezze
  Sixth Circuit· 2003-09-04· cited 58×
• United States v. Ali Boumelhem
  Sixth Circuit· 2003-08-12· cited 51×
• Williams v. Northwest Airlines, Inc.
  Sixth Circuit· 2002-12-18· cited 50×
• Fields v. Campbell
  Sixth Circuit· 2002-06-20· cited 46×
• Hamdi Ex Rel. Hamdi v. Napolitano
  Sixth Circuit· 2010-09-07· cited 39×
• United States v. Eddie D. Jeter
  Sixth Circuit· 1999-10-18· cited 38×
• Dekoven v. Bell
  E.D. Michigan· 2001-04-26· cited 38×
• Kimberly G. McLaughlin v. James Cotner
  Sixth Circuit· 1999-09-30· cited 36×
• Wagenknecht v. United States
  Sixth Circuit· 2008-07-09· cited 32×
• Hyland v. Clinton
  Sixth Circuit· 2001-02-07· cited 30×
• White v. Lamanna
  Sixth Circuit· 2002-05-03· cited 22×
• Mercurio v. American Express Centurion Bank
  N.D. Ohio· 2005-04-05· cited 21×
• Dekoven v. Bell
  Sixth Circuit· 2001-10-31· cited 18×
• Milgrom v. Burstein
  E.D. Kentucky· 2005-06-28· cited 17×
• Selvy v. Department of Housing & Urban Development
  E.D. Michigan· 2005-05-31· cited 16×
• Andrew Rice v. Village of Johnstown, Ohio
  Sixth Circuit· 2022-04-08· cited 16×
• Citizens for Responsible Government State Political Action Committee v. Davidson
  Tenth Circuit· 2000-12-26· cited 14×

Cites

9 cases in this archive are cited by this case.

• Darryl McGore v. Gene L. Wrigglesworth, Chief Sheriff Richard Chinelli, Administrator Ingham County Sheriff's Department
  Sixth Circuit· 1997-06-11· cited 5,495×
• Hagans v. Lavine
  Supreme Court· 1974-03-25· cited 2,844×
• Geoffrey Benson v. Greg O'Brian
  Sixth Circuit· 1999-06-15· cited 650×
• McDonald v. Smith
  Supreme Court· 1985-06-19· cited 449×
• Russ' Kwik Car Wash, Inc. Clean Cars, Inc. v. Marathon Petroleum Company Gastown, Inc. Emro Marketing Company
  Sixth Circuit· 1985-09-05· cited 271×
• In Re Bendectin Litigation.
  Sixth Circuit· 1988-08-30· cited 252×
• Richard L. Tingler, Jr. v. Ronald Marshall
  Sixth Circuit· 1983-09-15· cited 234×
• James H. Ricketts, Sr. v. Midwest National Bank, James H. Ricketts, Sr. v. Sharp Investment Company
  Seventh Circuit· 1989-05-11· cited 151×
• David C. Dilworth v. Dallas County Community College District Randy Conine Georgia Francis
  Fifth Circuit· 1996-05-30· cited 18×